Clever Hans

back to index

15 results

The Food Lab: Better Home Cooking Through Science

by J. Kenji López-Alt  · 20 Sep 2015

want to see and find the answers they want to find, even if they don’t realize it. Have you ever heard the story of Clever Hans the counting horse? Early in the twentieth century, Hans made quite a name for himself by apparently being intelligent enough to understand German, do arithmetic

The Atlas of AI: Power, Politics, and the Planetary Costs of Artificial Intelligence

by Kate Crawford  · 5 Apr 2021  · 355pp  · 89,587 words

Notes Bibliography Index Introduction The Smartest Horse in the World At the end of the nineteenth century, Europe was captivated by a horse called Hans. “Clever Hans” was nothing less than a marvel: he could solve math problems, tell time, identify days on a calendar, differentiate musical tones, and spell out words

…

complex questions, such as, “I have a number in mind. I subtract nine and have three as a remainder. What is the number?” By 1904, Clever Hans was an international celebrity, with the New York Times championing him as “Berlin’s Wonderful Horse; He Can Do Almost Everything but Talk.”1 Hans

…

answer. This led Pfungst and Strumpf to consider whether some sort of unintentional signal had been providing Hans with the answers. Wilhelm von Osten and Clever Hans As Pfungst would describe in his 1911 book, their intuition was right: the questioner’s posture, breathing, and facial expression would subtly change around the

…

. What fascinated him most about this discovery was that questioners were generally unaware that they were providing pointers to the horse. The solution to the Clever Hans riddle, Pfungst wrote, was the unconscious direction from the horse’s questioners.5 The horse was trained to produce the results his owner wanted to

…

see, but audiences felt that this was not the extraordinary intelligence they had imagined. The story of Clever Hans is compelling from many angles: the relationship between desire, illusion, and action, the business of spectacles, how we anthropomorphize the nonhuman, how biases emerge, and

…

the politics of intelligence. Hans inspired a term in psychology for a particular type of conceptual trap, the Clever Hans Effect or observer-expectancy effect, to describe the influence of experimenters’ unintentional cues on their subjects. The relationship between Hans and von Osten points to

…

world. This opens a central question of this book: How is intelligence “made,” and what traps can that create? At first glance, the story of Clever Hans is a story of how one man constructed intelligence by training a horse to follow cues and emulate humanlike cognition. But at another level, we

…

AI systems at a planetary scale, and their systems are once again hailed as comparable or even superior to human intelligence. Yet the story of Clever Hans also reminds us how narrowly we consider or recognize intelligence. Hans was taught to mimic tasks within a very constrained range: add, subtract, and spell

…

are due to Jason and Elliott, my favorite cartographers. Notes Introduction 1. Heyn, “Berlin’s Wonderful Horse.” 2. Pfungst, Clever Hans. 3. “‘Clever Hans’ Again.” 4. Pfungst, Clever Hans. 5. Pfungst. 6. Lapuschkin et al., “Unmasking Clever Hans Predictors.” 7. See the work of philosopher Val Plumwood on the dualisms of intelligence-stupid, emotional-rational, and master-slave

…

: Its Place in the Seventeenth-Century Episteme.” Journal of the History of Ideas 43, no. 4 (1982): 531–53. https://doi.org/10.2307/2709342. “‘Clever Hans’ Again: Expert Commission Decides That the Horse Actually Reasons.’” New York Times, October 2, 1904. https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1904/10/02/120289067.pdf

…

and Possible Breaknecks,” electrek, November 1, 2016. https://electrek.co/2016/11/01/breakdown-raw-materials-tesla-batteries-possible-bottleneck/. Lapuschkin, Sebastian, et al. “Unmasking Clever Hans Predictors and Assessing What Machines Really Learn.” Nature Communications 10, no. 1 (2019): 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-08987-4. Latour

…

24, 2016. http://social.techcrunch.com/2016/03/24/microsoft-silences-its-new-a-i-bot-tay-after-twitter-users-teach-it-racism/. Pfungst, Oskar. Clever Hans (The Horse of Mr. von Osten): A Contribution to Experimental Animal and Human Psychology. Translated by Carl L. Rahn. New York: Henry Holt, 1911. Phillips

…

power and, 222–23 Chinese Society of Rare Earths, 36 Chun, Wendy, 12, 187 Church, Frank, 160 CIA. See Central Intelligence Agency Citizen (app), 201 Clever Hans Effect, 1–4, 6 Clickworker, 64 climate justice, 226–27. See also environmental impacts cloud computing, carbon footprint of, 41–42 Club of Rome, 267n17

…

Newell, Allen, 6 Newton, Isaac, 79 New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission, 110–11 New York Taxi Workers Alliance, 86 New York Times: on Clever Hans, 1 on Ekman, 170 Nextdoor (app), 201 Next Generation Identification (NGI), 92 Nietzsche, Friedrich, 222 Nilsson, Nils, 111–12 NIST. See National Institute of Standards

Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow

by Yuval Noah Harari  · 1 Mar 2015  · 479pp  · 144,453 words

not only bad science, but it also prevents us from understanding and valuing other animals on their terms. In the early 1900s, a horse called Clever Hans became a German celebrity. Touring Germany’s towns and villages, Hans showed off a remarkable grasp of the German language, and an even more remarkable

…

the human’s face. He then stopped tapping, and watched how tension was replaced by amazement or laughter. Hans knew he had got it right. Clever Hans is often given as an example of the way humans erroneously humanise animals, ascribing to them far more amazing abilities than they actually possess. In

…

is four times three, there is no way that I could correctly tap my foot twelve times simply by observing facial expressions and body language. Clever Hans enjoyed this ability because horses normally communicate with each other through body language. What was remarkable about Hans, however, is that he could use the

…

method to decipher the emotions and intentions not only of his fellow horses, but also of unfamiliar humans. Clever Hans on stage in 1904. © 2004 TopFoto. If animals are so clever, why don’t horses harness humans to carts, rats conduct experiments on us, and

…

205; homosexuality and 192–3, 225–6, 275–6; immortality and 22 see also Bible and Catholic Church Chukwu 47 CIA 57, 160, 293–4 Clever Hans (horse) 128–30, 129 climate change 20, 73, 151, 213, 214–17, 376, 377, 397 Clinton, Bill 57 Clovis, King of France 227, 227 Cognitive

Stranger Than Fiction: Lives of the Twentieth-Century Novel

by Edwin Frank  · 19 Nov 2024  · 467pp  · 168,546 words

, it is called, or Lucky Per, a title that puts its hero in the charmed company of such fairy-tale adventurers as the Grimm brothers’ Clever Hans. Per is in that sense a human type and a mythic character. At the same time, he is, in the words of his wealthy Jewish

Thinking in Pictures: And Other Reports From My Life With Autism

by Temple Grandin  · 10 Jan 2006  · 291pp  · 92,406 words

box and controlled by a computer to insure that the pigeons did not receive cues from the trainer. (Whenever animal thinking is being evaluated, the “Clever Hans effect ” must be taken into account. Hans was a famous horse that had been trained to count by tapping his hoof. Many people were very

…

of these tasks with a person, the next step is to have it look at a videotape of the person. This helps to prevent the Clever Hans effect. The simple command sentences are rearranged into hundreds of different combinations so the dolphins cannot memorize a set routine. Dolphins can easily transfer instructions

Think Like a Rocket Scientist: Simple Strategies You Can Use to Make Giant Leaps in Work and Life

by Ozan Varol  · 13 Apr 2020  · 389pp  · 112,319 words

—even when we’re careful to not dislodge that coin in the couch cushion—we might be cuing them in subtle but significant ways. Consider Clever Hans the horse.48 Hans was the closest thing a horse could come to a rocket scientist. He became a worldwide sensation for his ability to

…

21, 2017, http://podcasts.joerogan.net/podcasts/neil-degrasse-tyson. 47. The discussion on Seinfeld is based on Thompson, Hit Makers. 48. The discussion on Clever Hans is based on Stuart Firestein, Ignorance: How It Drives Science (New York: Oxford University Press, 2012), 94–95. 49. Tim Ferriss, “Cal Fussman Corners Tim

How to Prevent the Next Pandemic

by Bill Gates  · 2 May 2022  · 406pp  · 88,977 words

Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division (2019), World Population Prospectus 2019, Special Aggregates, Online Edition, Rev. 1. GO TO FIGURE IN TEXT I admired the clever: Hans Rosling, “Will Saving Poor Children Lead to Overpopulation?,” https://www.gapminder.org; Our World in Data, “Where in the World Are Children Dying?,” https://ourworldindata

Time Paradox

by Philip G. Zimbardo and John Boyd  · 1 Jan 2008  · 297pp  · 96,509 words

close to losing that distinction to a horse. Wilhelm von Osten was a retired schoolteacher who in 1891 claimed that his stallion, whom he called Clever Hans, could answer questions about current events, mathematics, and a host of other topics by tapping the ground with his foreleg. For instance, when Osten would

…

ask Clever Hans to add three and five, the horse would wait until his master had finished asking the question, tap eight times, then stop. Sometimes, instead of

…

asking a question, Osten would write it on a card and hold it up for Clever Hans to read, and the horse seemed to understand written language every bit as well as it understood speech. Clever Hans didn’t get every question right, of course, but he did much better than anyone else

…

in 1904 the director of the Berlin Psychological Institute sent his student, Oskar Pfungst, to look into the matter more carefully, and Pfungst noticed that Clever Hans was much more likely to give the wrong answer when Osten was standing in back of the horse than in front of it, or when

…

horse had been asked. In a series of experiments, Clever Pfungst was able to show that Clever Hans could indeed read—but that what he could read was Osten’s body language. When Osten bent slightly, Clever Hans would start tapping, and when Osten straightened up, or tilted his head a bit, or faintly

…

raised an eyebrow, Clever Hans would stop. In other words, Osten was signaling Clever Hans to start and stop tapping at just the right moments to create

…

the illusion of horse sense. Clever Hans was no genius, but Osten was no fraud. Indeed, he’d spent

The Human Cosmos: A Secret History of the Stars

by Jo Marchant  · 15 Jan 2020  · 544pp  · 134,483 words

of research into telepathy made no convincing discoveries. And in an episode that shaped the future study of animal behavior, a world-famous horse named Clever Hans, who could apparently answer questions and solve math sums by tapping his hoof, was shown in 1907 to be responding to unconscious cues from his

…

turtles, even appeared to have a magnetic map sense, telling them not just direction but position. Decades earlier, telepathy and clairvoyance were exposed as myths; Clever Hans was exposed as a fraud. Now organisms were revealing other abilities that were perhaps just as impressive. Life, it seems, really is plugged into the

…

in the History and Philosophy of Science: An Introduction and Review,” Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 48 (2014): 38–45. Clever Hans: Edward Heyn, “Berlin’s Wonderful Horse: He Can Do Almost Everything But Talk—How He Was Taught,” New York Times, September 4, 1904; Fabio De

…

Sio and Chantal Marazia, “Clever Hans and His Effects: Karl Krall and the Origins of Experimental Parapsychology in Germany,” Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 48 (2014

…

): 94–102. Clever Hans’s influence on the field of animal behavior: Michael Beran, “To Err Is (Not Only) Human: Fallibility as a Window into Primate Cognition,” Comparative and

…

–53 period gene and, 237–38 traditional societies on, 238–45 Chumash people, 13–20 Church of the Holy Sepulchre (Jerusalem), 77 Cicero, 103–4 Clever Hans (horse), 191n, 228, 249 Clinton, Bill, 271, 275 Clottes, Jean, 17 Cole, LaMont, 232 comets, discovery of, 190 Common Sense (Paine), 161–62, 168 Comte

…

used to estimate the motion of stars, including Sirius. * Kepler could apparently answer simple mathematical problems by barking (several years before a German horse named Clever Hans gained fame for a similar trick), and was terrified of butchers’ shops. Kepler’s father and grandfather had the same fear—Huggins described this to

Artificial Intelligence: A Guide for Thinking Humans

by Melanie Mitchell  · 14 Oct 2019  · 350pp  · 98,077 words

, made a very provocative analogy when he noted that there is “a lot of interest in whether Deep Learning is ‘real intelligence’ or a ‘Clever Hans.’”28 Clever Hans was a horse in early twentieth-century Germany who could—his owner claimed—perform arithmetic calculations as well as understand German. The horse responded to

…

questions such as “What is fifteen divided by three?” by tapping his hoof the correct number of times. After Clever Hans became an international celebrity, a careful investigation eventually revealed that the horse did not actually understand the questions or mathematical concepts put to him, but

…

was tapping in response to subtle, unconscious cues given by the questioner. Clever Hans has become a metaphor for any individual (or program!) that gives the appearance of understanding but is actually responding to unintentional cues given by a

…

trainer. Does deep learning exhibit “true understanding,” or is it instead a computational Clever Hans responding to superficial cues in the data? This is currently the subject of heated debates in the AI community, compounded by the fact that AI

…

checkers; see also Samuel’s checkers-playing program chess; see also Deep Blue Clark, Andy Clarke, Arthur C. classification; in convolutional neural networks classification module Clever Hans Clune, Jeff cognitron common sense; in babies; knowledge in Cyc; for self-driving cars concepts as mental simulations conceptual slippage connectionism connectionist networks, see connectionism

…

Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency Dartmouth AI workshop data snooping Davis, Ernest decoder network Deep Blue deep learning; adversarial examples for, see adversarial examples; as “Clever Hans”; difference from human perception; explainability of; inspiration from neuroscience; lack of reliability; as narrow AI; need for big data; see also convolutional neural networks; encoder

Alex's Adventures in Numberland

by Alex Bellos  · 3 Apr 2011  · 437pp  · 132,041 words

who have no words or symbols for numbers has traditionally focused on animals. One of the best-known research subjects was a trotting stallion called Clever Hans. In the early 1900s, crowds gathered regularly in a Berlin courtyard to watch Hans’s owner, Wilhelm von Osten, a retired maths instructor, set the

…

. So renowned had Alex become among scientists and birdlovers that when he died unexpectedly in 2007, his obituary appeared in The Economist. The lesson of Clever Hans was that when teaching animals to count, supreme care must be taken to eliminate involuntary human prompting. For the maths education of Ai, a chimpanzee

Escape From Model Land: How Mathematical Models Can Lead Us Astray and What We Can Do About It

by Erica Thompson  · 6 Dec 2022  · 250pp  · 79,360 words

the definition of adequacy-for-purpose. And this often happens without the makers even realising that any other perspectives exist. Clever horses and stochastic parrots Clever Hans was a performance act at the beginning of the twentieth century, a horse that was able to tap a hoof to indicate the correct answer

…

performance of the ‘horse’ with respect to that data, we will have to conclude that it is a very good model – or, for example, that Clever Hans is in fact able to perform arithmetic. The detection of the confounding factors in the case of an unexpectedly mathematically talented equine happened because of

…

training data, to remove the potential confounding factors that make it look like the model is doing well when it is not. Of course, both Clever Hans and the tank detector were doing interesting things – just not what their handlers thought they were doing. The ‘stochastic parrot’ language models are doing very

Leadership by Algorithm: Who Leads and Who Follows in the AI Era?

by David de Cremer  · 25 May 2020  · 241pp  · 70,307 words

.org/2012/11/data-humans-and-the-new-oil 91 Lapuschkin, S., Wäldchen, S., Binder, A., Montavon, G., Samek, W., & Mueller, K.-R. (2019). ‘Unmasking clever Hans predictors and assessing what machines really learn.’ Nature Communications, 10, 1096. 92 Editorial (2017). ‘How does the brain work?’ Neuron, 94(5), 933. 93 Goldhill

Peak Everything: Waking Up to the Century of Declines

by Richard Heinberg and James Howard (frw) Kunstler  · 1 Sep 2007  · 235pp  · 65,885 words

using their methods to train other parrots to do the same things. They are also using rigorous controls to avoid cueing the birds via the “clever Hans” effect. Alex and his avian colleagues evince numeric cognition, categorization and word comprehension among other abilities previously assumed to exist perhaps among the great apes

You're Not Fooling Anyone When You Take Your Laptop to a Coffee Shop: Scalzi on Writing

by John Scalzi  · 28 Jan 2007  · 168pp  · 9,044 words

it became clear that I wasn't likely to become an astronomer (my first choice of professions) because I did math only slightly better than Clever Hans, and that wasn't going to be acceptable if I wanted to be a truly useful astronomer. The confirmation that I was going to be