M-Pesa

back to index

description: mobile banking service

91 results

Money, Real Quick: The Story of M-PESA

by Tonny K. Omwansa, Nicholas P. Sullivan and The Guardian  · 28 Feb 2012  · 140pp  · 91,067 words

19 ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* million Kenyans, nearly 70% of the adult population, have signed up for mobile money services. Sixteen million are customers of M-PESA (‘M’ for Mobile and pesa means money in Swahili), the mobile money service offered by Safaricom, the leading mobile operator in Kenya. In 115 years

…

-money and vice versa was surprisingly simple. Safaricom identified airtime dealer stores near target areas, and after some explanation most resellers agreed to take on M-PESA. Safaricom had been so successful so fast, acquiring 5 million customers in five years, that airtime agents figured another Safaricom innovation could not fail.

…

promise and might work in several of the many emerging markets where it had operations; in fact, Vodafone has since exported M-PESA to Tanzania, South Africa, Afghanistan and India. M-PESA might also form the basis of a low-cost international remittance service. Globally, international remittances are a $400 billion business, fueled

…

.” That wish was eventually granted, and Vaughan, who had been in charge of products and services, became the lead manager for and exclusively dedicated to M-PESA. Joseph was quickly becoming a believer. ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* Safaricom was not quite ready for a nationwide rollout. The product functionality was right,

…

also convincingly showed that collaborating with Faulu Kenya or any other microfinance institution would be a millstone during a national launch. The consumer proposition for M-PESA was compelling enough that attracting customers would not be a problem. Of course, that consumer proposition had to be spelled out clearly. “Send Money

…

ride back to Wajir. While in Nairobi, Fawzia stayed with her daughter and her husband. That was before M-PESA. Now, with M-PESA, Fawzia can send the money in seconds! There are more than 20 M-PESA agents in Wajir. Transport has also improved. Wajir Airport, formerly used just by the military, was opened to

…

as those of the many small villages in between, and beyond. If banks are dour and stolid ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* buildings with imposing entrances, M-PESA shops are colorful and eyecatching, located near matatu (small bus) stops and residential neighborhoods, and the doors are often open. Banks are typically open from

…

stations and supermarkets and other high-traffic distribution points as agencies, the ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* virtue being that they weren’t dependent on M-PESA for profits but could treat it as just another hot item to sell. Soon enough, as these agencies looked to expand with employees (cash merchants

…

backing for loans to agencies at favorable rates. KCB has also agreed to set up overdraft protection for agents’ working capital, to be delivered through M-PESA. An agency’s central functions are to maintain office space, develop signage and marketing, hire employees (using some combination of salary and commissions), and

…

able to meet her family needs. Risper is always on her phone, coordinating float-related issues, talking to business partners, interacting with M-PESA cash merchants as well as Safaricom M-PESA staff. She also has to ensure that cash merchants are well trained and know how to handle different situations. With such a

…

him get “discipline”. Before, he would pass by the local bar and sometimes spend his entire earnings on cheap liquor. ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* M-PESA has solved many problems for Juma, and, he says, for the “common man.” Juma is grateful that Safaricom charges neither registration fees to its subscribers

…

subscribers —more customers than all 43 banks combined—Kenya’s Acting Finance Minister, Mr. John Michuki, asked the Central Bank to audit M-PESA. He said he was not sure M-PESA would “end up well,” hinting at vulnerability to money launderers and pyramid schemes. He asked the Central Bank to study the “scheme

…

the financial system at risk. The Central Bank had created some loose guidelines for mobile money transfer, but certainly no clear regulatory and legal framework. M-PESA, for example, was free to skirt onerous “know-yourcustomer” regulations, which made it much easier to sign up subscribers with marginal background checks. Cash

…

agents to Mwangi’s 165 branches and 550 ATMs. But the two fast-growing institutions are symbiotic, for most Equity account holders use M-PESA, and a third of M-PESA subscribers have accounts at Equity. It was only natural that they connect, although complex because they were in many ways fighting over “ownership

…

liquidity had become an issue for Safaricom. A year after the contentious audit, the biggest bank in Kenya had created a winwin arrangement with M-PESA. To reassure M-PESA agents, many of whom now depended on the MPESA agency business for their daily livelihood, Joseph laid out the facts: “We have about

…

for banks to build a network than it was for Safaricom. First, they have to offer better deals than Safaricom. Second, they cannot “share” M-PESA agents, because M-PESA agencies have signed exclusivity contracts with Safaricom. Third, banks cannot create their own exclusive agents, according to the law, so any network one bank

…

may earn from there on and deposits it the next morning. Once home, using his mobile phone, he transfers money from his M-PESA account to his employer’s M-PESA account. With M-PESA, he keeps his accounts straight and his earnings safe. And he stays out of jail. ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* Chapter 4

…

mobile phone—and incur few transaction costs. Kagure, the youngest of his three wives, reports receiving KShs. 500 ($5) per month since she subscribed to M-PESA, a big increase and a vital one, as such remittances constitute a substantial part of her household income. **** ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* Send money

…

the Anglican Church to help residents mobilize money. He formed a savings group called Jipange Sasa (Plan Now), noteworthy for its reliance on M-PESA as a transactional tool. M-PESA speeds up collections and bookkeeping, increases the amount saved in group funds, and has even been used to invest in the stock market

…

increased transfers and lower transactions costs, along with instantaneous communications, translated into more money in the village, which of course has sparked local economies. As M-PESA remittances redistribute money from urban to rural areas, savings are more productively allocated across households, families and businesses. Instead of shopping in the market town

…

and pay for it on time. This virtuous circle frees money for other agricultural inputs, and even labor. A study on the impact of M-PESA concludes that M-PESA is associated with increases in employment, but that these are almost exclusively changes in farm employment. “One possible explanation,” write authors Isaac Mbiti and

…

but most of its initial success was driven by middle- and upperincome urban dwellers. They are the people putting money into the M-PESA ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* system. But M-PESA’s biggest impact has been on the poor, who are more disconnected from the world’s grids than any other segment, for

…

the 2000s ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* in developed economies. In the U.S., Google and Microsoft engineers eventually filter into the broader ecosystem; in Kenya, M-PESA engineers are behind some of the most promising startups. Companies with names like Symbiotic, Tangazoletu, Webtribe, Zege Technologies, Mobile Commerce Ventures, MTL Systems, Coretec Systems

…

first 100% mobile-powered, cashless, microfinance ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* institution (MFI). All loans are disbursed to a mobile phone; all loans are repaid via M-PESA, with future plans to connect to the other mobile money providers. When clients are in arrears, they receive an SMS notification. While cashless, Musoni is

…

to teachers and suppliers. Record-keeping is enhanced, although Bridge, like many other Pay Bill clients, would like to find a way to better integrate M-PESA records with its own accounting software. “Everything we do is about efficiency,” says founder Jay Kimmelman, an American educational-software entrepreneur who started the business

…

Grundfos Lifelink, a global water-pump manufacturer, allows villagers to buy water with micropayments from a ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* community water pump. Villagers transfer M-PESA to a smart card (“key bobs”) that can be used to draw water from specially calibrated, solarpowered water pumps. This maji ya compiuta (computer water

…

monitored by local communities. In case of pump malfunction, an alarm carried by the Safaricom network sounds in Grundfos’s regional office. Water remittances through M-PESA encourage private investors to enter rural areas they previously would have bypassed. Grundfos Lifelink is looking to deploy 10 such solar pumps in different communities

…

and payment system and distribution through rural retailers—that are micro-insurance firsts. THE “NEW COMMERCE” PLAYERS Hundreds of Kenyan businesses are now integrated with M-PESA and other mobile money services, according to survey conducted by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. And since few of these companies have their own software

…

says the World Bank’s Wolfgang ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* Fengler. “Kenya shows the world innovation. That’s quite unique.” Even Budhabhatti agrees. “Luckily, because M-PESA has made Kenya popular, we are now getting some deals in European countries. I even did a presentation in Papua, New Guinea, and they said

…

want to use your system.” ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* Regulating cash merchants and bank agents Another burning policy issue, which pits the banks against M-PESA, is how to devise regulations for cash merchants and bank agents without giving either an unfair advantage. Tangentially related to that is a cry for

…

In 2011, a year or so after issuing bank agency regulations, the Central Bank issued draft regulations covering “retail payment” agents—aka cash merchants, or M-PESA agents. This precipitated another request from banks ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* to review bank-agent regulations against those of payment agents. Bank agents, for example

…

to operate retail cash merchants as well as bank agents. Thus, banks can offer cash-in/cash-out merchants to compete with M-PESA, although they still cannot piggyback on M-PESA’s exclusive network. The Central Bank’s new retail-payments regulation essentially unbundles the different services that cash merchants and bank agents

…

their phones to interact with the bank and to transfer money. Customers received an ATM card, upgradeable to a MasterCard debit card. Much later, after M-PESA started, MTN rolled out MTN MobileMoney in eight other African countries (Benin, Botswana, Cameroon, Cote d’Ivoire, Ghana, Rwanda, Uganda, Swaziland). Outside of South

…

Watermarks******* lower commission. And since True Money is primarily a payments system, it does not face the issue of cashing out, as M-PESA does. Thus, the landscape pre-M-PESA has three major players: Smart Money in The Philippines, MTN Banking in South Africa and True Money in Thailand. All were gradations on

…

an intermediary. None were “pure mobile plays” like M-PESA. The landscape post-M-PESA is not unlike the pre-M-PESA landscape, in terms of hybrid mobile money applications, except that it is extremely crowded. That includes several M-PESA clones sparked by Vodafone. M-PESA CLONES After the launch of M-PESA and its meteoric uptake, Nick Hughes’s role

…

and withdrawn, with few exceptions. This is really no different than a cash transfer, except for the mode of transfer. Extensive financial diaries of M-PESA and non-M-PESA users essentially confirm this statistical finding. An in-depth study of 92 low-income (median income of roughly $2 a day) individuals in three

…

the lowest margin part of the mobile money business, while electronic transactions are the highest. Mobile money analysts Kabil Kumar and Toru Mino estimate that M-PESA earns Safaricom an estimated 18% average gross margin on agent-based transactions compared with almost 100% gross margin on electronic-only transactions. And in their

…

estimate, M-PESA Kenya’s “electronic-only” transactions grew 35% faster than agent transactions in 2010. That means the e-money loop is lengthening. “Growth in electronic

…

$10. These relentless forces will quickly change consumer behaviour, as we have already seen with the rapid ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* and widespread adoption of M-PESA. Add to the above an exogenous force of nature—the increasing youthfulness of the world’s population. Demographics, coupled with the spread of spread of

…

banking advocates, this is the “nightmare scenario.” A 2009 Kenyan news report (Business Nation) hints at the potential for panic: “A technical hitch in the M-PESA money transfer service caused anxious customers to crowd at service outlets to have their accounts updated. Customers had initially been barred from accessing the premises

…

in Kenya, and helped push both cash and increasingly e-money into villages, which sparks more ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* commerce and jobs. And M-PESA has dramatically increased bank liquidity, by pushing money that had long been stored in the metaphorical “mattresses” into trust accounts to back the e-float

…

was $1,217 and the average was $39. This suggests, interestingly, that many more customers, even local ones, are choosing to pay by M-PESA rather than cash. M-PESA, in effect, serves as Mercy’s accounting tool. It provides figures for how much fish she should buy based on the sales revenue deposited

…

KickStart, which manufactures and sells foot-powered water pumps in Africa; Frederick Eijkman, co-founder and CEO of Pep Intermedius, which owns and operates numerous M-PESA agencies; Wolfgang Fengler, lead economist in the Nairobi office of the World Bank; David Ferrand, director of Financial Sector Deepening in Nairobi,; ******ebook converter

…

DEMO Watermarks******* Jared Getenga, project manager, Kenya Credit Information Sharing Initiative; Nick Hughes, the “godfather” of M-PESA dating to his tenure at Vodafone, and who is now a director of SignalPoint Partners; Steve Isaboke, general manager of MultiChoice Kenya, a satellite TV

…

Maina and Hellen Kabira, and from Strathmore University, led ******ebook converter DEMO Watermarks******* by John Wachira. Many thanks to Safaricom, which gave us access to M-PESA agents, partners and customers, and to the GSMA Development Fund, which provided travel and research support. The University of Nairobi gave Tonny Omwansa local logistical

Matchmakers: The New Economics of Multisided Platforms

by David S. Evans and Richard Schmalensee  · 23 May 2016  · 383pp  · 81,118 words

building or investing in multisided platforms—in the cloud or on the ground. It’s not only full of great stories like the rise of M-PESA, it’s also a practical guide to getting your platform business off the ground. If the people behind Apple Pay had this book to

…

to massively reduce important market frictions, and to provide financial services to millions of impoverished people. And it is a story of how multisided platforms—M-PESA and other mobile money schemes that have started in Kenya and elsewhere—are leapfrogging traditional industries. Kenyans don’t need to rely on banks for

…

out. Building a network of specialized cash-in and cash-out (CICO) agents that would cover the country, particularly its rural areas, was unattractive to M-PESA for the same reason that banks found it uneconomical to build many rural branches: volumes would be too low at many locations to cover fixed

…

had to solve two chicken-and-egg puzzles. How It Works A Safaricom subscriber needs to go to a CICO agent to set up an M-PESA account. The CICO agents are typically small shops, gas stations, bank branches, or post offices that offer these services as part of their businesses

…

and that can thus make a profit on relatively small volumes of M-PESA transactions.10 The agent records personal information about the subscriber, replaces the SIM card in the subscriber’s phone, and provides him a PIN for

…

accessing the account. To obtain e-money for his account, the subscriber hands cash over to the agent, and the agent uses the M-PESA system to deposit e-money in his account. To send e-money, the subscriber needs to type in the mobile phone number of the recipient

…

to withdraw the money in cash. She enters the agent’s number, the amount of the withdrawal, and her PIN. The agent uses the M-PESA system to reduce the balance in the recipient’s e-money account and gives her the withdrawal amount in cash. Meanwhile, the sender’s e

…

-money account is debited. Both the sender and receiver get SMS receipts for these transactions. M-PESA receives and pays various fees during this process. While the company doesn’t charge the sender anything to put money into his account, it charges

…

a fee to send money and another to receive it. M-PESA pays the CICO agents a commission for each new customer they sign up and for cash-in and cash-out transactions. The Start-Up Problem

…

The M-PESA system sounds great, just as OpenTable and other successful multisided platforms do, with twenty-twenty hindsight. But a moment’s reflection reveals just how

…

difficult it was to get this mobile money platform off the ground. Suppose a young man working in Nairobi signs up for M-PESA so he can send money to his parents. The service is worthless to him unless his parents are willing to use the service. One

…

to get off the ground than single-sided firms. While some people are mainly senders and others are mainly receivers, most people probably use the M-PESA system both to send and to receive money. Thus, senders and receivers aren’t groups of different people; they are people playing different roles at

…

his parents—farmers in a rural village—money for groceries, for instance, and they may occasionally send him money on special occasions. Similarly, most M-PESA agents both get and give out cash, even though some do more cash-in and others do more cash-out. The need for cash-in

…

and cash-out outlets compounded the M-PESA start-up problem. Senders can’t use the platform if they can’t put cash in, and receivers won’t use the platform if

…

agents. But moving cash to and from rural areas is costly, and holding it in anticipation of withdrawals has both costs and risks. Since M-PESA pays agents only for transactions, a shop needs to make sure there is enough demand from senders and receivers before it signs up to be

…

reasonably close to a CICO agent where they could buy e-money and cash it in. In setting up the CICO network and expanding it, M-PESA had to balance two conflicting forces. Senders and receivers would value having more agents nearby. That argued for recruiting more agents and increasing the density

…

it also ensured that the stores could receive transaction fees that were high enough to make it worthwhile for the stores to devote attention to M-PESA customers. Some Kenyans were more often senders, and others were more often receivers. To get a significant volume of transactions flowing through its system

…

disproportionately located in the urban areas, and receivers were disproportionately located in the rural areas. To make sure both types of customers were on board, M-PESA made sure it had agents who could register people and provide both cash-in and cash-out services throughout the country, including the important rural

…

areas. M-PESA adopted a pricing model that would encourage senders to recruit receivers. It was possible to send e-money to anyone in the country who had

…

structure provided strong incentives for senders to persuade those to whom they wanted to send money to register for M-PESA. Table 11-1 summarizes M-PESA’s fees as of 2009.13 TABLE 11-1 M-PESA’s fee structure, 2009 (in KShs) Transaction type Transaction range Customer charge Minimum Maximum Deposit cash 100 35

…

100 5,001 10,000 175 10,001 20,000 350 20,001 35,000 400 Withdraw cash by registered 100 2,500 25 M-PESA user at M-PESA 2,501 5,000 45 agent outlet 5,001 10,000 75 10,001 20,000 145 20,001 35,000 170 Withdraw cash

…

by registered 200 2,500 30 M-PESA user at PesaPoint 2,501 5,000 60 ATM 5,001 10,000 100 10,001 20,000 175 Withdraw cash by 100 35,

…

, and it had successfully recruited CICO agents across the country. It had solved the initial coordination problem. Yet that did not guarantee its success. M-PESA tried to get people to subscribe by emphasizing how the platform could solve a single major friction for them. It focused on “Send Money Home

…

-winning commercial shows a young man in a suit and tie at his desk at work.14 He picks up his mobile phone and selects “M-PESA” and then “Send Money” from the menus. The commercial then shows Kenyan shillings shooting out of the phone and landing in the apron of

…

on June 3, 2007. The voice-over is “You can send pesa fast and safe using Safaricom’s new service.” Several charts reveal how M-PESA did during these dangerous early months. Figure 11-1 shows the number of registered users and the value of transfers that took place over the

…

registered users increased dramatically during this period and, in parallel, so did the value of transactions on the e-money platform. FIGURE 11-1 Registered M-PESA users and value of transactions in US$ By February 2010, there were 9.7 million registered users (42 percent of people over the age of

…

volume. The number of agents grew from the initial 307 in March 2007 to 25,394 in February 2010. FIGURE 11-2 CICO agents and M-PESA transaction volume Figure 11-3 shows transaction volume per agent and registered users per agent. During the first few months, the agents’ economics improved,

…

and went on to enjoy overwhelming success. Other mobile network operators in Kenya followed Safaricom’s lead and established mobile money systems. Mainly because of M-PESA’s great success, the people of this poor African country of only 44.9 million are more likely to use mobile money, and to conduct

…

more transactions monthly, than the people of any other country in the world.19 But M-PESA’s success was far from inevitable. There’s an App for That Once people had signed on and were actively using the platform to transfer

…

money, and M-PESA had its dense agent network throughout the country, it could consider other services that could use the same platform. Many were part of the original

…

2015, the Commercial Bank had lent KShs 24 billion ($271 million). In early 2015, the KCB Bank Group launched a program in partnership with M-PESA. This program allowed users to access loans of between KShs 50 and KShs 1 million ($0.565–$11,300), due in one to six months

…

, at interest rates between 4 percent and 12 percent. M-PESA and the other mobile money schemes replace many of the services that traditional banks would provide. People can use mobile money as they would a

…

they want to buy the expensive physical point-of-sale terminals that are used in countries where most consumers use cards? As of late 2015, M-PESA consisted of four intersecting two-sided platforms: (1) a sender–receiver money-transfer platform; (2) a registered user–CICO agent platform; (3) a financial

…

registered user platform. All four platforms intersect with the registered user, who relies on her phone to interact with all the other sides. Africa Rising M-PESA has shown the way for countries in the rest of Africa to bring financial services to people across the income spectrum, from the poorest rural

…

11-2, have these schemes cracked the chicken-and-egg problem and obtained significant growth and penetration.22 Others are sure to follow, though, since M-PESA, as a pioneering platform, has shown a way to do it successfully and has demonstrated that successful mobile money schemes can speed up economic development

…

women, back in a village can’t support themselves. They have made families less susceptible to income shocks. One study found that the use of M-PESA enabled Kenyan families to maintain consumption in the face of negative income shocks, while those who didn’t use this money transfer service saw household

…

were third parties—in most countries worldwide. In most ways, except for the use of mobile phones, its business model since 1871 is similar to M-PESA’s. In short, many of the multisided platforms that are transforming industries today are turbocharged versions of matchmakers that did more or less the same

…

will transform industries over decades rather than years. That’s not to say some things won’t happen quickly. Just look at the impact of M-PESA’s leapfrogging of traditional banking on Kenya. BlaBlaCar may be poised for similar growth in a number of developing countries in which poor infrastructure means

…

to buy, that can harm sellers. Ignition: When a multisided platform achieves critical mass and starts a process of self-sustaining growth. For example, once M-PESA had enough people with accounts who wanted to send or receive, and enough cash-in/cash-out agents who sold e-money to senders or

…

“Commercial Bank Branches (per 100,000 Adults)” http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/FB.CBK.BRCH.P5 (data for 2006). 4. Sarit Markovich and Charlotte Snyder, “M-Pesa and Mobile Money in Kenya: Pricing for Success,” no. 5-213-250 (Evanston, IL: Northwestern University, December 3, 2013). 5. No data is available for

…

Connections, excluding cellular M2M: Q4 2006,” https://gsmaintelligence.com/. 10. Olga Morawczynski, “Examining the Adoption, Usage and Outcomes of Mobile Money Services: The Case of M-Pesa in Kenya,” May 2011, 61, https://www.era.lib.ed.ac.uk/bitstream/handle/1842/5558/Morawczynski2011.pdf;jsessionid=8C18972CF709DB8AA70C004302F5CFA6?sequence=2. 11. Central Bank

…

of Kenya, “Mobile Payments,” https://www.centralbank.go.ke/index.php/nps-modernization/mobile-payments. 12. Ignacio Mas and Amolo Ng’weno, “Three Keys to M-Pesa’s Success: Branding, Channel Management and Pricing,” Journal of Payments Strategy and Systems 4, no. 4 (2010). Dollar figures shown in this chapter were converted

…

and we show this calculation just to give the reader sense of scale. 17. After 2010, a few other mobile money platforms entered Kenya, although M-PESA still accounted for the preponderance of transactions. The data in figures 11-4–11-6 includes these other schemes. Therefore, it accurately reflects the overall

…

growth in Kenya but overstates the growth of M-PESA somewhat. 18. Central Bank of Kenya, “Mobile Payments,” https://www.centralbank.go.ke/index.php/nps-modernization/mobile-payments. 19. GSMA Staff, personal communication

…

with the authors, October 1, 2015. 20. Safaricom, “Lipa Na M-PESA,” http://www.safaricom.co.ke/business/m-pesa/lipa-na-m-pesa. 21. GSMA, “2014 State of the Industry: Mobile Financial Services for the Unbanked,” 2014, http://www.gsma.com/mobilefordevelopment/wp-content

…

market cap of, 40 operating system, 47–48 stores, 195 apps, 47–48. Apple and, 80, 100, 113–114, 117 Facebook, 109 messaging, 201 M-PESA, 164, 167–181 open source licensing, 115–116 quality control and, 139, 142–143 retail and, 185–196 standards for, 126 Ariba, 67–68, 82

…

188. See also mobile communications browsers, 42 Burberry, 194–195 cash, 203–204 cash-in and cash-out (CICO) agents, 169, 170, 171. See also M-PESA chat rooms, Alibaba, 60 Chen, Steven, 69–70. See also YouTube Chestnut Hill Mall, 95 chicken-and-egg problem. See critical mass China Alibaba, 58

…

164 coordination problem and, 70–73 design in creating, 121–133 economic model for, 76–78 ecosystems and, 104 landline telephones and, 22–23 for M-PESA, 169–170 network effects and, 21–31 origins of term, 71–73 pricing and, 96–98 warning signs of failure in, 155–156 Cue,

…

and, 70–73 driving traffic and, 73–76 economic model for, 76–78 failure in, 82–83 modification of strategies for, 151, 154–155 at M-PESA, 174–178 at OpenTable, 11–12 pricing and, 82 strategies for, 78–82, 151, 154–155, 159–160 warning signs of failure in, 155

…

69–70, 80. See also YouTube Kohan, Shelley, 184 legal environment, 140 lemons problem, 138–139 Levchin, Max, 80–81 light bulb, 204 Lipa Na M-PESA, 179 Lohan, Lindsay, 135–138, 140 London Stock Exchange, 140–142 loss leaders, 31 Love’s Travel Stops, 86 Lundgren, Terry, 194–195 Lyft, 30

…

ISPs for, 45–46 shopping changed by, 183–196 mobile payment systems African economic development and, 180–181 Apple Pay, 58, 149–150, 156–164 M-PESA, 164, 167–181 momentum, 73. See also critical mass; ignition money side of the platform, 33–34, 93–94 Monster, 50, 124 Motorola, 113,

Bank 3.0: Why Banking Is No Longer Somewhere You Go but Something You Do

by Brett King  · 26 Dec 2012  · 382pp  · 120,064 words

who don’t yet have a bank account and who currently rely heavily on cash and prepaid debit cards, but as we will see with M-Pesa and G-Cash (Chapter 6), this is hardly a hurdle for mobile cash and payments. The success of the Octopus card in Hong Kong, T

…

expected to increase to one-third of consumers in 2012. Many of us would be familiar with the rapid rise of M-Pesa as the world’s leading mobile-centric financial system. M-Pesa started as a project funded by the UK Government Department for International Development (DFID) to provide a means for more

…

efficient collection of microfinance loan repayments (see the case study later in this chapter). While the initial goal for M-Pesa was quite humble, no one was prepared for its incredible growth. The system addressed a long-time systemic deficiency in the Kenyan financial system that

…

2012, the World Bank estimated that 25 per cent of Kenya’s Gross Domestic Product runs through M-Pesa each year—not surprising, considering that around 50 per cent of the Kenyan population is on M-Pesa, which also has a positive effect on the users’ financial lives. Only one per cent of Kenyans

…

bank account. So how do you enable financial inclusion for the poorest populations in Africa? You turn their phone into a bank account. Registration for M-Pesa also increases the likelihood of users having some savings by more than 20 per cent, according to World Bank findings released in 2012. The survey

…

found that 65 per cent of M-Pesa users reported having some savings compared with 31 per cent of those who were not M-Pesa users.7 Since M-Pesa’s creation, the GSM Association (GSMA) has identified 130 similar deployments across the globe, with another

…

in this case mobile is both the transactional and customer acquisition channel, and often the mobile is the only way to interact with the business. M-Pesa, G-Cash, WING and MTN Mobile Money are prominent examples. Mobile Banking refers to the adding of mobile as a channel for existing bank customers

…

make financial transactions or transfers across the country conveniently and at low cost. The two most successful of these are M-Pesa in Kenya and G-Cash in the Philippines (see the M-Pesa case study later in the chapter). The Edgar Dunn research also found that the number one barrier to successful deployment

…

governing the deployment and usage of mobile financial services is proportionate to the risks involved. As reported in the Nairobi Star in December 2008,22 M-Pesa with all its success represented a clear threat to the Big Four banks in Kenya. The Big Four have a combined market coverage of around

…

three million account holders and 750 banking outlets. M-Pesa, in comparison, has more than 15 million customers and 37,000 sales agents and outlets across the country. The massive threat that

…

M-Pesa holds for the Big-Four banks is patently obvious. A similar story can be told in other markets where new payment mechanisms have been successful.

…

the systems level without interfering with the customer interface. What is the outcome for banks? Well, as G-Cash from Globe in the Philippines, and M-Pesa from Safaricom in Kenya show, the biggest threat to banks is from telecom operators. So banks need to team quickly with network operators so as

…

to take HTML 5. More on that in a moment when I discuss Beyond the App Store. M-Pesa Success Story Mobile remittances taking the developing world by storm Kenya’s mobile payment service, known as M-Pesa, provided by the main mobile phone company in Kenya, Safaricom, in conjunction with Vodafone, represents a

…

good example of how low-cost approaches that use modern technology can effectively expand the financial services frontier. M-Pesa (M for mobile, “Pesa” for money in Swahili) is the product name of a mobile-phone-based money transfer service that was developed by Sagentia

…

(now owned by IBM) for Vodafone. The concept of M-Pesa was initially to create a service that allowed microfinance borrowers to receive and repay loans conveniently using the network of mobile provider, Safaricom, and utilising

…

of dealing in cash is reduced. The users of the service would gain through being able to track their finances more easily. In 2006, when M-Pesa was launched, over 70 per cent of Kenyan households did not have bank accounts, or relied on informal sources of finance. When the service was

…

trialled, customers adopted the service for a variety of alternative uses, and complications arose with Faulu, the partnering microfinance institution (MFI). M-Pesa was refocused and launched with a different value proposition: sending remittances home across the country and making payments. Today, millions of Kenyans use

…

M-Pesa to make payments, send remittances and store funds for short periods. Many of those without bank accounts are able to use this service, at low

…

risk and cost. As noted in a recent article in the Economist,24 Kenya’s M-Pesa is the most celebrated success story of mobile banking and payments in a developing country. What started as a mobile money transfer service has become

…

nation significantly. By the end of its first month, the service had just over 19,000 subscribers. Within three months, there were 268,499 registered M-Pesa customers and within the first year, one million. By 2012, that number had climbed to 15 million customers. Almost half of the Kenyan population of

…

35 million have embraced M-Pesa in its short five-year history. Also impressive has been the increase in the number of monthly transactions, which increased by 4627 per cent over

…

the period from July 2007 to July 2009. M-Pesa averages 11 to 14.6 person-to-person transfers each month, with over 56 billion Kenyan shillings a month (US$675m/month) moved through the

…

M-Pesa network. Mobile money transfers in total crossed the 1-trillion shilling mark in 2011. With over 37,000 outlets and reseller agencies around Kenya, M-Pesa outstrips the top four banks’ reach by more than 50 to 1. This

…

is why M-Pesa has become ubiquitous so quickly. M-Pesa also facilitates bill payments for more than 700 companies across Africa. M-Pesa has now expanded its field abroad. In October 2009

…

, Safaricom launched its M-Pesa services in the UK through Western Union, Provident Capital Transfers, KenTV

…

and others. While there are some AML restrictions on the usage of M-Pesa for transfers by a single individual, the system still allows a Kenyan working in the UK to deposit pounds or euros in the UK with

…

mobile phone. With 37,000 outlets, 15 million users and close to $700m per month, the M-Pesa mobile payments network is a huge success. M-Pesa has extended its reach further across Africa with its relaunch of M-Pesa in Tanzania. While the take-up in Tanzania has been slightly slower than in Kenya, there

…

million users in that country. Vodafone has also partnered Roshan to provide M-Paisa, a local variant of M-Pesa, in Afghanistan. Early in 2010, Nedbank and mobile operator Vodacom teamed up to launch M-Pesa in South Africa. Scenario 4: Apple Rules! If Apple continues on its current growth path, with the launch

…

promise to make the mobile experience much more relevant to consumers, and hence place further demands on financial institutions. Keywords: Mobile Payments, Mobile Wallets, iPhone, M-Pesa, Mobile Banking, Unbanked, Remittances, Marketing, Promotion Endnotes 1 Sources: http://148apps.biz/app-store-metrics/, http://www.androidtapp.com/android-apps-statistics-summary-for-2010

…

/it/page.jsp?id=1924314) 20 GSMA: gsmworld.com 21 Edgar, Dunn and Company: edgardunn.com 22 Nairobi Star, “Big Banks in Plot to Kill M-Pesa”, 23 December 2008 23 Finextra, “Philippines mobile phone-based microfinance bank set for launch”, 13 October 2009 24 The Economist, 26 September 2009 Chapter 7

…

the Middle East, for remitting funds to their families back home. A similar scheme operates in Kenya called M-Pesa. It also provides for person-to-person fund transfers using mobile phones. Interestingly, with the M-Pesa scheme, it is the cash conversion which is one of its biggest issues. The shopkeeper who signs

…

up as an agent for M-Pesa is required to keep a cash float which can cause problems in isolated areas, and results in the merchant having to travel to the nearest

…

town to replenish the cash. M-Pesa has attempted to solve this problem through ATM cash withdrawal through PesaPoint, Equity Bank Code and Diamond Trust. More on the

…

M-Pesa case study can be found in Chapter 6 on Mobile Banking. Personalisation, data and analytics ATMs could truly become automated “tellers” in the next few

…

-sector payment systems. This is one of the key reasons we see fragmented success. In Kenya, for example, where regulators took a more relaxed approach, M-Pesa mobile payments quickly dominated the landscape. In South Africa, on the other hand, where the regulator insisted on cash-in and cash-out functions being

…

to be an attractive customer group. This was the case in Kenya where the four Big Banks have 3.5 million customers between them, but M-Pesa, the mobile payments solution, already has 17 million customers and that’s in just six short years.23 This is the fastest “banking” of an

…

—they will find themselves out of the loop on this one. Keywords: EMV, Chip and PIN, NFC, Near Field Communication, PayPal, Square, Dwolla, Bitcoin, QQ, M-Pesa, Mobile Payments, Mobile Wallet, Google Wallet, ISIS, v.me, PayPass, Amex, Visa, MasterCard Endnotes 1 Dave Birch (Consult Hyperion), “The Mobile Payment Horizon” (https://www

…

Bank, “Migration and Remittances Factbook 2011” 2nd edition 23 Safaricom and thinkM-Pesa.com (http://www.thinkm-pesa.com/2012/04/every-business-should-have-m-pesa.html) 24 Mercantile Bank press release, 3 November 2009 25 “What will credit cards look like in 25, 50 or 100 years?”, Jay MacDonald, December

…

mobile phone interfaces and mini-browsers. Mobile Money: Bank-like services delivered over a mobile device to enable payments between two parties; successful providers include M-Pesa, Edy, G-CASH, MTN Money, T-money, Edy, Suica. Mobile Wallet: An electronic account, dominated in a currency, held on a mobile phone that can

…

Markowitz, J. “Illinois little guy takes on big stink at Goldman”. Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, 10 January 2010. Mbugua, J. “Big Banks in Plot to Kill M-Pesa”. Nairobi Star, 23 December 2008. McDonald, J. “What will credit cards look like in 25, 50 or 100 years?” (17 February, 2009) From CreditCards.com

Before Babylon, Beyond Bitcoin: From Money That We Understand to Money That Understands Us (Perspectives)

by David Birch  · 14 Jun 2017  · 275pp  · 84,980 words

processing two billion direct credits per annum. But today? Today it could well be sent by PayM or Internet transfer, WeChat or Venmo, Facebook or M-Pesa. So how will that birthday £500 (adjusted for inflation) wend its way in 2025 to celebrate the diamond anniversary of that New Scientist prediction? Futurology

…

West Country. The first lesson is that banks are very probably the wrong people to launch this kind of initiative. Our experiences with (for example) M-Pesa suggest that a lot of the things that I remember that I was baffled and confused by at the time come down to the fact

…

reasons. But we are all moving to mobile, and that brings the future of money closer. The M-Pesa story No treatise on the future of money is complete without a discussion of the M-Pesa mobile money transfer scheme in Kenya. It will be a business school case study for years to come

…

economist Tim Harford featured it in his 2016 BBC World Service series 50 Things That Made the Modern Economy (available at http://bbc.in/2fjzkYf). M-Pesa launched in Kenya in 2007 and subsequently spread to Tanzania and Afghanistan in 2008, South Africa in 2010, India in 2011, Romania in 2014 and

…

Albania in 2015. M-Pesa is so important that its origins and trajectory need to be recorded and reported from many perspectives. In their definitive history Money, Real Quick – The

…

Shorts, 2012), Tonny Omwansa and Nicholas Sullivan tell its story, which I shall précis here to make a couple of points. M-Pesa uses inexpensive feature phones to deliver financial services. The first hero of the story (in my eyes, anyway) is Nick Hughes. Nick was then Head

…

Africa more efficient and he submitted a proposal to the UK Department for International Development for matching funding. This was granted back in 2003, and M-Pesa was born.******** The second hero of the story is Susie Lonie, also from Vodafone. Susie had been working on mobile commerce in the United Kingdom

…

, and in 2005 she was sent to Nairobi to get the M-Pesa pilot up and running. She combined first-class project management skills with real vision, and together with Nick steered the system from a pilot that

…

was done and about the issues that needed to be managed: agent incentives, float management, trading and so forth. Suffice to say that becoming an M-Pesa agent became an attractive proposition. When the system went live it was immediately apparent that the market was using it in ways that had not

…

a kind of ‘night safe’) as well as settling transactions and paying wages. Now there are some 600 businesses in Kenya that accept payments through M-Pesa. These include the national airline, the power utilities and insurance companies. In summary, a non-bank payment system founded on new technology rather than legacy

…

mere 1,000 bank branches, 1,500 ATMs and 100,000 credit card customers. Lessons from M-Pesa What general lessons can we draw from M-Pesa’s rise? One lesson is about the regulatory environment that allowed M-Pesa to flourish and about how, despite banks’ reservations about the scheme, once it was successful banks

…

expand their borders beyond branches by hiring agents [but] only after they tried, and failed, to shut down M-Pesa’. This is why, for me, the most interesting part of the story came after M-Pesa reached five million subscribers (more than all forty-three of Kenya’s commercial banks combined) back in 2008

…

. At that time the acting finance minister said he was not sure that M-Pesa would ‘end up well’. No one was sure who

…

was supposed to be regulating M-Pesa, but the minister asked the central bank to study the scheme******** with the result being that the permanent

…

service ‘safe and reliable’. He also said ‘there is nothing wrong with competition’. From the beginning the commercial banks had offered new services over the M-Pesa network, thereby demonstrating that mobile money could deliver financial inclusion. As the banks began to offer more services, and became part of the

…

M-Pesa ecosystem as savings accounts and super agents, it seems to me that the whole financial sector was invigorated. Dynamic partnerships (such as the one with

…

sector emerged. Another lesson I draw is that I simply do not believe that a bank-led solution would have triggered the innovation revolution that M-Pesa clearly did. A key element in its success is that it was born in telco culture, and conceived as an infrastructure for others to build

…

specialist at the Consultative Group to Assist the Poor, which is part of the World Bank, makes a point about the ‘adjacent industries’ stimulated by M-Pesa and this seems to have led to a high-tech boom in ‘Swahili Silicon Valley’ around iHub in Nairobi. Cashless schools, pay-for-use water

…

for the twenty-first century. As the CEO of Kenya Commercial Bank is quoted as saying in the book, in response to being asked if M-Pesa is a threat to banks: ‘if you don’t respond it’s a threat, but if you embrace it, then it’s an opportunity’. I

…

cannot help but point to the relationship between identity and money. One of the most unexpected impacts of M-Pesa was the use of M-Pesa transaction histories as substitutes for conventional credit ratings. Remember that many M-Pesa agents are merchants, so it is natural for them to extend credit in this way. In other

…

words, M-Pesa became a means for previously excluded people to demonstrate identity and reputation. And on a final semi-technical note, I can see a future in

…

, though, is another story. Implications for cashlessness In Kenya there are only two payment choices for most people: cash or M-Pesa. A raft of economic activity is now floating on the M-Pesa river of money, supporting businesses that simply could not exist in a cash-only economy, so it is always interesting

…

licences in this new category to a variety of fintech, tech and telecoms companies and consortia. Among the successful bidders were the mobile operators Vodafone M-Pesa and Bharti Airtel, the technology companies Fino PayTech and Tech Mahindra, as well as the Department of Posts. These payment banks can accept deposits from

…

revenues, or they can find alternative sources of tax income. Since the former is a fantasy, the latter is inevitable. As is often the case, M-Pesa helps us to make these issues concrete. M-Pesa is widely used, but it clearly isn’t part of Kenyan M0 since the ultimate liability for the

…

M-Pesa balances rests with the commercial banks where the float is deposited (M-Pesa has a 100 per cent reserve). The fact that it isn’t part of M0 is a potential problem, however, from the

…

government’s point of view. If M-Pesa keeps growing and M0 keeps shrinking, this deprives the state of seigniorage revenue. This has indeed happened, and the Kenyan government decided to compensate with

…

service providers was introduced in a 2012 Finance Act there). The predictable impact of this was that Safaricom (Kenya’s largest taxpayer) put up its M-Pesa fees by 10 per cent. So just as the unbanked trapped in a cash economy pay the stealth tax on notes and coins, so too

…

feasible because of key technological advances such as mobile payments. Look again at what is going on in Africa as discussed earlier in relation to M-Pesa in Chapter 7. People who aren’t allowed to hold dollar bank accounts hold dollar-denominated mobile top-up vouchers instead. Before Ugandans had an

…

effective electronic payment system they used M-Pesa from Kenya to execute local transactions in Kenyan shillings! Congolese without access to any banking network were using mobile money instead (and may never ever

…

but I’d say that the combination of central register plus tamper-resistant hardware, so that low-value payments can be handled quickly (e.g. M-Pesa), is pretty good, especially if it can be extended to work offline in some environments. As discussed in chapter 9, I think that what the

…

appropriately private protocol for moving value between accounts. My prediction is that this is likely to look more like the bastard child of Ripple and M-Pesa than a blockchain cryptocurrency with a one-to-one reserve in sterling. Does this kind of digital fiat currency make sense? I think it does

…

nothing to do with shared ledgers, distributed ledgers or blockchains. The cheapest alternative for running such a system would clearly be a fully centralized architecture (M-Pesa in Kenya is the obvious example), but as the Bank notes this will come with increased resiliency risks that are likely to be deemed unacceptable

…

in payment systems. When looking at the options for central bank digital cash and when reflecting on our experiences with population-scale schemes such as M-Pesa in Kenya, it seems to me that providing a good API on top of the system and allowing innovators to build new products and services

…

, mining pools. Brit-Pesa-ledger it is Let’s summarize, then. A central bank digital currency? This is an entirely reasonable proposition. Imagine something like M-Pesa but run by the Bank of England. Everyone has an account and you can transfer money from one account to another using a mobile phone

…

the Bank of England API to access the accounts or by phoning a voice recognition and authentication service. Drawing on my company’s experiences from M-Pesa, the Token Administration Platform in Nigeria and other population-scale mobile-centric systems that we have advised on, I think that this API might be

…

. This is different from observing that there will be a panoply of payment mechanisms. The cash replacement technologies discussed earlier in this book – PayPal and M-Pesa, iDEAL (which dominates online payments in the Netherlands) and EMV – do not understand that sterling is a ‘real’ currency and that World of Warcraft Gold

…

notes ‘in circulation’ suggest. Kenya A decade on from the then-radical step of allowing a non-bank payment scheme (discussed in detail in ‘The M-Pesa story’ in chapter 7), Kenya has more than 33 million mobile money users and 174,000 mobile agent locations. The most recent figures from the

…

Central Bank of Kenya show an astonishing trend. Between February 2013 and September 2016 the number of monthly M-Pesa transactions almost tripled, going from 53 million per month to 131 million, while the number of card transactions fell from 34 million per month to

…

was tripling, card use was halving. I am told by reliable sources that one of the key reasons for this – apart from the fact that M-Pesa is now accepted at some 150,000 retail outlets in a country with only around 10,000 card terminals – is that when it came time

…

since they had already started to use mobile money instead of cards. An astonishing 96 per cent of Kenyan households now have at least one M-Pesa user. As a Deutsche Bank report on electronic payments noted (Mai 2014), a preference for electronic payments as an alternative to cash payments is not

…

can see the effect very clearly in Kenya, where for most people there are only two payment choices: cash or M-Pesa. A raft of economic activity is now floating on the M-Pesa river of money – businesses that simply could not exist in a cash-only economy – so it is always interesting to

…

example, came up with a very specific use that I’m sure we can all understand: If you go drinking, it’s better to use M-Pesa because it’s safer. Maybe you get drunk and lose your money. If you find yourself unable to dial the number, it means that it

…

-calculative approach helps to explain the dynamic in the country, where mobile money is replacing cash but cards are not. Kenya, after ten years of M-Pesa development, helps us to understand the embedding of ‘financial devices’ in social structures, so that we can develop theories about how cash, payment cards and

…

licences in this new category to a variety of fintech, tech and telecoms companies and consortia. Among the successful bidders were the mobile operators Vodafone M-Pesa and Bharti Airtel, the technology companies Fino PayTech and Tech Mahindra, the Department of Posts, and Vijay Shekhar Sharma, the founder of m-commerce outfit

…

pioneer of accounting and financial analysis. Accounting History Review 21(3), 309–345. Omwansa, T., and N. Sullivan. 2012. Money, Real Quick: The Story of M-Pesa. London: Guardian Books. Pantaleone, W. 2014. Italy seizes 556,000 euros in fake coins minted in China. Daily Mail, 12 December. Peck, M. 2013. Ripple

The Wide Lens: What Successful Innovators See That Others Miss

by Ron Adner  · 1 Mar 2012  · 265pp  · 70,788 words

7 Changing the Game: Reconfiguring the Ecosystem to Work for You Main Case: Electric Cars CHAPTER 8 Sequencing Success: Winning the Connected Game Main Cases: M-PESA and Apple CHAPTER 9 Multiplying Your Odds of Success Better Place Epilogue Acknowledgments Notes Index PREFACE When I started working on innovation ecosystems over a

…

construction of a second ecosystem. I will illustrate these principles using examples of success in two industries. First, we will explore the way in which M-PESA, a Kenya-based pioneer of mobile payments, followed these principles to build a financial services ecosystem that was used by 65 percent of the Kenyan

…

the principle of ecosystem carryover to leverage elements and constellations from its old ecosystems to jump-start its construction of new ecosystems. M-PESA: Creating Mobile Banking Services for Unbanked Populations M-PESA is a joint venture between Vodafone and Safaricom, Kenya’s dominant mobile network operator. Piloted in 2005, and then relaunched in

…

27 percent had access to one—and those numbers were rapidly increasing. (By the end of 2010, 63 percent of Kenyans were mobile phone subscribers.) M-PESA sought to deliver a basic banking function to Kenya’s huge unbanked population, facilitating commerce and entrepreneurship by increasing access to capital while reducing transaction

…

costs—and to do it profitably. In 2005, M-PESA (M is for “mobile” and pesa is Swahili for “cash”) launched a pilot test of its proposition by partnering with a local microfinance institution,

…

of small business borrowers who would then assume a collective responsibility to pay back the money, provided the customer base for the pilot program while M-PESA provided the technology and delivered the mobile services. The idea was to offer a comprehensive financial service that would let users transfer money person to

…

person, deposit and withdraw cash through a Safaricom agent, and use M-PESA to receive and repay their micro-loans—all without the need for smartphones, 3G, or any other new technology development. The service worked in much

…

divergent cultures of telecom (forward-thinking, rapidly developing) and banking (conservative, slow to change), and lived in constant fear of being shut down by regulators. M-PESA’s exact role—as a money transfer service, but also as an entity that allowed customers to maintain a noninterest-bearing account balance—was murky

…

that the company was not formally regulated as a financial institution. Figure 8.1: Value blueprint of M-PESA’s 2005 pilot attempt. More problematic were the hurdles that arose as a consequence of M-PESA’s partnership with its microfinance partner. The involvement of Faulu Kenya meant that considerable complexity was added

…

accommodate its particular lending models, treasurer accounts, and accounting practices. Faulu Kenya, wary about the novelty of the M-PESA proposition, chose to retain its paper-based back-office procedures instead of adopting M-PESA’s real-time data entry system. This resulted in a complex reconciliation process between the two organizations, which

…

were moving at different speeds. According to Lonie: “The bottleneck in transferring the money M-PESA had collected in loan repayments to Faulu’s bank account was getting its books to a point where it could request the funds. To make

…

M-PESA more suitable for [microfinance institutions], we need to create data export files that can be easily uploaded in whatever format their existing software requires.”

…

The partnership between M-PESA and Faulu Kenya was a morass of interdependent processes that severely limited the success of the pilot. Reflecting on the challenges of the experiment, Lonie

…

need to find a way to simplify things before launching a national service for millions of customers.” Finding the Minimum Viable Ecosystem (MVE) The M-PESA team went back to the drawing board and, in April 2007, launched a new initiative that took what had been a complex endeavor and focused

…

only on its most basic elements. Rather than constructing the big picture all at once, M-PESA eliminated the key sources of coordination challenges—the banking component, which had introduced regulatory obstacles, and the micro-loan component, which had introduced the need

…

anywhere in the country. Kenya was already blanketed with kiosks where Safaricom agents sold airtime to mobile customers, and these same agents would facilitate the M-PESA money transfers, doling out the appropriate amount of cash to transfer recipients. And because no bank accounts were involved, the regulatory hurdles were much lower

…

. Figure 8.2: Value blueprint of M-PESA’s 2007 relaunch—the minimum viable ecosystem (MVE) of the money transfer offer. Of course, launching even just the money transfer service was not without

…

its challenges. M-PESA still faced obstacles, high among which was ensuring that the rural agents maintained a sufficient cash float. Since customers tended to make deposits in the

…

partnering challenges of the next stage of development. From Minimum Viable Ecosystem to Staged Expansion Having established a basic but demonstrably successful money transfer service, M-PESA began its staged expansion beyond its MVE, adding new partners to enhance the value of its core offer. It brought them on to its platform

…

whom was the subject of active and ultimately unproductive debate—it brought them there on its own terms. Figure 8.3: Value blueprint of M-PESA’s 2007 relaunch showing the initial minimum viable ecosystem (MVE) and subsequent expansion stages of the offer. Within the first year

…

partnership with PesaPoint, one of the largest ATM service providers in Kenya. As an alternative to the Safaricom agents, M-PESA customers could now choose the option “ATM withdrawal” from the M-PESA menu on their phone and receive an ATM authorization code for one-time use; no bank card required (expansion stage

…

2). And in 2009, M-PESA, in partnership with Western Union, introduced an international remittance service to enable money transfers from the United Kingdom (expansion stage 3). By July 2009,

…

two years after its initial launch, M-PESA had expanded its customer base to 7.3 million, with an agent network of over 12,000. Cumulative person-to-person transfers had amounted to

…

an impressive $2.7 billion (Kenya’s GDP in 2009 was $63 billion). These strong numbers meant M-PESA was in a good position to expand its offering to add more formal banking services and insurance. This time, with proven commercial success and a

…

history of reliable operation, the regulatory obstacle was much easier to cross. In the spring of 2010, M-PESA did just that. In conjunction with Safaricom, the firm teamed up with Equity Bank, Kenya’s biggest bank in terms of client base, to create

…

M-Kesho (kesho is Swahili for “tomorrow”), a financial service that combines the benefits of a bank account with the convenience of M-PESA. M-PESA customers could now enjoy an interest-bearing bank account, as well as services such as micro-savings and micro-insurance, all of which could be

…

in the market, nobody has put together all these services to provide this kind of convenience to the customer.” By incorporating banking and microfinance services, M-PESA finally achieved the initial vision of the 2005 pilot program. Getting the value proposition right was not enough. Turning this vision into reality required a

…

a staged sequence (increasingly sophisticated money transfer). A Choice of Paths: Pilots vs. Footprints The M-PESA case offers a valuable contrast between two different approaches to building toward success. The path initially pursued by M-PESA in 2005, which was abandoned in the face of partner-induced complexity, exemplifies the traditional prototype

…

clear path to getting the system together at scale, ecosystem pilots languish and never get off the ground. Underlying the failure of the initial M-PESA pilot effort was a combination of co-innovation and adoption chain challenges that were inherent in the nature of the value proposition (the need for

…

an inconsistent view of the venture’s value blueprint and a disagreement about ecosystem leadership among all the partners. While there was consensus between the M-PESA and Faulu Kenya teams about the overall value proposition, there was no consensus on the specifics of how the different activities would actually come together

…

scale ecosystem deployment contrasting a traditional pilot demonstration followed by a phased rollout and a minimum viable ecosystem (MVE) rollout followed by a staged expansion. M-PESA’s 2007 money-transfer-only offer had all the characteristics of a perfect minimum viable footprint. It was simple, and therefore relatively straightforward to deploy

…

group of target consumers; and it was extendable, and therefore able to accommodate the addition of new elements. Having established itself in the market, M-PESA was able to use this MVE as a platform on which to sequentially mount additional elements for the expansion of the proposition. The hallmark of

…

progress in one stage feeds directly into progress in the next. By sequencing the construction of an ambitious ecosystem into a series of discrete stages, M-PESA was able to plot an incremental path to radical change. Ecosystem Carryover: How to Build Success upon Success Driving staged expansion from an MVE is

…

edition of The Wide Lens, this concept was referred to as “Minimum Viable Footprint.” 195 65 percent of the Kenyan population: “In Rural Kenya, M-Pesa Is Used as a Savings Account Tool,” Mobile Payment Magazine, March 3, 2011. 195 81 percent of Kenyans did not have access to a bank

…

account: “Enabling Mobile Money Transfer: The Central Bank of Kenya’s Treatment of M-Pesa,” Alliance for Financial Inclusion, case study, 2010, p. 2. 195 27 percent of its citizens owned mobile phones: Ibid., p. 92. 195 63 percent

…

too many challenges to mention”: Jaco Maritz, “Exclusive Interview: The Woman Behind M-PESA,” How We Made It in Africa, November 11, 2010, http://www.howwemadeitinafrica.com/exclusive-interview-the-woman-behind-m-pesa/5496/. 197 considerable complexity was added: Sarah Rotman, “M-PESA: A Very Simple and Secure Customer Proposition,” CGAP.org, November 5, 2008

…

198 “we would need to find a way to simplify things”: Ibid., p. 74. 200 expanded its customer base to 7.3 million: Michael Ouma, “M-Pesa Now Ventures Abroad to Tap into Diaspora Cash,” East African, October 19, 2009, http://www.theeastafrican.co.ke/business/-/2560/673512/-/5gaimnz/-/index.xhtml. 201

…

, automobile Avatar, 74 Aventis, 102–3 B Bag of Bones (King), 89 Baldwin, Don, 25 Ballmer, Steve, 212–13 Balsillie, Jim, 211 Banking, mobile. See M-PESA Barnes & Noble, Nook, 100 Barrett, Craig, 122 Battery-powered autos. See Better Place; Electric vehicles (EVs) Berelowitz, Dr. Michael, 109 Better Place, 179–90,

…

construction sequence, 193–223 Apple example, 207–23 ecosystem carryover, 194, 205–7, 213–21 efficiency of, 205 minimum viable ecosystem (MVE), 194, 198–205 M-PESA example, 195–205 staged expansion, 194, 199–205 See also individual stages Ecosystem for innovation building, sequence of. See Ecosystem construction sequence development/use, history

…

–9 limitations of product, 104–5, 107 pulmonary function test issue, 109–12 value blueprint, 105–8 F Facebook, 207 Fanning, Shawn, 144 Faulu Kenya, M-PESA relationship, 196–98, 203 FedEx, 206 Fellman, Dan, 71 FireWire, 145, 146 First movers. See Early movers Fithian, John, 72 Fluence Z.E., 184,

…

, 52–53 Mines, Christopher, 143 Minimum viable ecosystem (MVE), 198–205 effectiveness, logic of, 199, 203–5 goals of, 194, 202–5, 221–22 M-PESA, 198–205 versus traditional approach, 201–4 M-Kesho, 201 Mobile phones, 39–46 first cell phone, 39 first generation, 38–39 iPhone success, 210

…

–17 leading players, 40, 211, 214 Nokia 3G phone failure, 42–46, 52–53 payment system via. See M-PESA profits, source of, 186 3G capabilities, 40–42 2G technology, 39–40 Windows Phone OS, 52–53 Model T, 166, 184 Moore’s law,

…

150 Mossberg, Walt, 207 Motorola, 39, 214 Moviemaking, digital methods. See Digital cinema MP3 players. See Portable music players M-PESA, 195–205 customer base, expansion of, 199–201 initial system problems, 196–97, 199, 203 minimum viable ecosystem (MVE), 198–205 partnerships, 196, 200–201

…

Rio PMP300, 142 Rocket e-reader, 88 S SaeHan MPMan, 140–44 failure, reasons for, 142–44 features, 142 Safaricom, mobile banking joint venture. See M-PESA Samsung, 40, 207 Scaling, pilots, difficulty of, 202–3 Semiconductor lithography, 150–53 functions of, 150–51 goals of, 152 innovation ecosystem for, 151–53

…

early-mover advantage, 140–41 Sortais, Thierry, 17 Spectrum rights, 41, 42 Staged expansion, 199–205 goals of, 194 iPhone, 216–17 iPod, 208–10 M-PESA, 199–205 Stringer, Sir Howard, 90 Superabrasive grinding wheels, 59–61 benefits of, 59–60 costs versus benefits problem, 60–61 Suppliers supply chain, managing

…

functions of, 85, 87, 112–13 for inhalable insulin, 101–12 for iPad, 220 for iPhone, 217 for iPod, 210 map, example of, 87 for M-PESA, 197, 198, 200 necessity of, 84–85, 100, 112–14, 226–27 for Sony Reader, 91–95 as team-based effort, 113–14 updating,

…

(VPF), 72–73, 76 Vision and co-innovation, 50–51 value proposition as, 85 VISTA electronic record system, 131 Vodafone, mobile banking joint venture. See M-PESA W Wachter, Dr. Robert, 119 Wal-Mart, RFID chips, 133 Weed, Larry, 120 Whitney, William C., 165–66 Wide-lens perspective components of, 7,

The Next Factory of the World: How Chinese Investment Is Reshaping Africa

by Irene Yuan Sun  · 16 Oct 2017  · 239pp  · 62,311 words

imperfect systems can produce world-class brilliance. To illustrate the point, let’s look at the clearest case of African success in innovation—mobile payments. M-Pesa is the Kenyan mobile payments platform, and it is unquestionably the most successful system of its kind in the world. Using

…

M-Pesa on their cell phones, Kenyans can send one another money, pay for a wide range of goods and services, and conduct a variety of banking transactions. Because of M-Pesa, mobile payments are much more commonplace in Kenya than in America

…

—in Kenya, even the smallest street vendors are likely to accept M-Pesa. In total, Kenya has 19 million M-Pesa users, who represent about 70 percent of its adult population.14

…

More than 40 percent of Kenya’s GDP is transacted through M-Pesa, and the number of M-Pesa transactions in Kenya alone outnumbers the number of Western Union transactions in the whole world.15 Despite the number of powerhouse companies like Google and

…

that have touted their own online payment systems, one out of every two people who send money over a mobile phone is a Kenyan using M-Pesa—an astonishing proportion when one considers that Kenya represents 0.0006 percent of the world’s population.16 How did Kenyans figure out something that

…

has eluded the rest of the world? There are two prevailing narratives typically told about M-Pesa’s origins. One is the Disney version that many Kenyans would like to believe: a scrappy young Kenyan inventor noticed a need and figured out

…

how to fill it through sheer ingenuity. Several lawsuits have been brought by Kenyans who claim to have invented M-Pesa, and perhaps because Kenyans would like to believe that M-Pesa was their doing, the story lives on, even if no one is certain who actually invented it. Dr. Shem Ochuodho

…

somewhere between a Disney film and a depressing documentary. Sure, Vodacom had a promising idea, but it was not viable in its original form; and M-Pesa would not have taken off to become a global sensation if a variety of Kenyan actors and institutions had not pulled and pushed and reshaped

…

the innovative behavior of individual Kenyan business owners, the imprint of Kenyan institutions made the difference between M-Pesa’s success and failure. When I spoke to Michael Joseph, Safaricom’s CEO at the time of M-Pesa’s rollout, he was unequivocal about how critical the Kenyan government’s role had been. Literally

…

around the world had been reluctant to support mobile payment systems, and initially, it appeared that Kenya would be no exception. At the time of M-Pesa’s pilot, the Central Bank of Kenya had an acting governor who balked at making such a controversial decision. The whole bureaucracy stalled on the

…

M-Pesa question, but one man was determined to make it move: Dr. Bitange Ndemo, the permanent secretary in the Ministry of Information and Communication. Because he

…

the president gave his go-ahead, and the rest is history. When Dr. Ndemo told me this story, I was taken aback. This was before M-Pesa’s rollout—how could he be sure that the system was a good one? What if consumers lost money, and livelihoods were destroyed? “Innovation precedes

…

,” he insisted. “We must allow ourselves to learn from our mistakes.” Along with Dr. Ndemo, others in Kenya’s bureaucracy acted with courage. Critically, during M-Pesa’s early days, the Central Bank of Kenya determined that Safaricom was not acting like a bank and decided not to subject

…

M-Pesa to banking regulations. This was not laziness—the central bank in fact held a long legal review before arriving at its decision—but rather, an

…

ability to report every transaction.23 When I spoke to Njuguna Ndung’u, the governor of the Central Bank of Kenya at the time of M-Pesa’s launch, he summarized his approach as basically “allowing the market to work … develop the market but make sure that you assess the risk and

…

emerging vulnerabilities.”24 And crucially, Safaricom was able to use another Kenyan institution that not even the United States has: national ID cards. This allowed M-Pesa to register users and prevent money laundering with a minimum of fuss. But beyond customer safety, the Kenyan regulators declined to require the same level

…

of safeguards for M-Pesa that banks have. Mukhisa Kituyi, the Kenyan who currently serves as secretary-general of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, says, “At the

…

familiar—waiting and seeing, being willing to experiment, making up the regulations as you go along—that’s because it is. The real story of M-Pesa is not only about individual innovation, not only about firm-level innovation, but also about institutional innovation. It is the result of all those levels

…

every turn. No single Kenyan could have imagined at the outset what M-Pesa would become; history shows that Vodacom’s original idea is not the one that allowed M-Pesa to take off; and Kenyan regulators certainly could not have created M-Pesa by themselves. It is the bootstrapped product of their interacting, which changed

…

.worldbank.org/handle/10986/4197. 11. Ibid. 12. John Xue, interview by author by phone, February 21, 2016. 13. Ibid. 14. M-Pesa has 19 million users in Kenya. Lilian Ochieng, “M-Pesa Reports 27 pc Jump in Global Users to 25 Million,” Daily Nation, April 27, 2016, http://www.nation.co.ke/business

…

/M-Pesa-reports-27-pc-jump-in-global-users-to-25-million/996-3178018-5ykpjpz/index.html. Kenya’s population in 2015 was 45.9 million, of

…

://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ke.html. 15. Claudia McKay and Rafe Mazer, “10 Myths About M-PESA: 2014 Update,” CGAP, October 1, 2014, http://www.cgap.org/blog/10-myths-about-m-pesa-2014-update; and Tonny K. Omwansa and Nicholas P. Sullivan, Money, Real Quick: The Story of

…

M-PESA (London: Guardian Books, 2012). 16. Ibid. Kenya population of 46 million from the World Bank (2015), http://data.worldbank.org/country

…

7.3 billion from the US Census Bureau, https://www.census.gov/popclock/world. 17. https://bizextras.wordpress.com/2011/05/23/so-who-invented-m-pesa/. 18. Omwansa and Sullivan, Money, Real Quick. 19. Ibid. 20. Michael Joseph, interview by author, Cambridge, MA, April 14, 2016. 21. Bitange Ndemo, interview by

…

, 35, 38 Kanono, Mpho Agatha, 102–105 Katzenstein, Peter, 147–148 Kenya, 11, 109–112 demographics, 190n14 industrialization in, 8 local ownership in, 119–120 M-Pesa in, 142–146, 190n14 pharmaceutical industry, 157 railroad project in, 175–177 worker skills training in, 129–134, 148–150 Kenya Association of Manufacturers, 120

…

, 153 Millennium Villages, 136 mindset, 136 Modern Times, 100–101 Mohapi, Chris, 114–115, 119 Mothabeng, Thabiso, 116–117 Mountain Textile Screening Company, 116–117 M-Pesa, 142–146, 190n14 Multi Fibre Arrangement (MFA), 63–64 Nairobi National Park, 175–177 Namibia, 3–4, 151–153 National Youth Service, Kenya, 133 Ndemo

The Future of Money: How the Digital Revolution Is Transforming Currencies and Finance

by Eswar S. Prasad  · 27 Sep 2021  · 661pp  · 185,701 words

provides a gateway through which more innovative financial products can reach large populations in relatively poor countries. M-PESA In 2007, Kenya’s largest mobile phone operator, Safaricom, introduced a simple but revolutionary concept. M-PESA is a mobile banking service that enables users to store and transfer money through their mobile phones. M

…

2017 less than a fifth of the population had access to the internet, while about 85 percent had mobile phone subscriptions. Unlike traditional bank accounts, M-PESA accounts can be opened without the minimum deposits that are sometimes beyond the financial capacity of poor households that lead a hand-to-mouth existence

…

. Users of a Safaricom SIM card who want to register for M-PESA have to do so with a valid government ID such as the Kenyan national identification card or a passport. This helps to combat fraud and

…

that each transaction is marked with the identification of the transacting parties. Users with no bank accounts can access the numerous M-PESA outlets distributed across the country. Cash collected from M-PESA is deposited in accounts held by Safaricom, which serve as checking accounts and are insured for up to one hundred thousand

…

Kenyan shillings (about $925 in May 2021) by the government’s Deposit Protection Fund. To complete a transaction using M-PESA, the two parties must exchange their phone numbers, which serve as account numbers. After settlement, both parties receive an immediate SMS notification with their names

…

of funds deposited or withdrawn from the user’s account. The mobile receipts help promote transparency and build confidence in the system. The adoption of M-PESA has meant that shopkeepers, farmers, cab drivers, and their customers no longer need to carry around or transact in cash. This has reduced vulnerability to

…

endure long lines and hours-long waits to pay their electricity and water bills, can now make these payments easily and at their convenience using M-PESA. In a country with fewer than three thousand ATMs for a population of about fifty million, this innovation has proved crucial to providing financial products

…

by other payment systems such as credit cards. In 2016, it was estimated that in 96 percent of Kenyan households at least one individual used M-PESA, and the financial inclusion ratio (the share of the population with access to the formal financial system) rose from 27 percent in 2006 to 83

…

percent in 2019. M-PESA has, in effect, provided a template for the adoption of mobile money in other developing countries where a large percentage of the population has little

…

or no access to traditional banking. For all its virtues and the enormous difference it has made to Kenyan households and businesses, M-PESA is not a magic bullet that can by itself dramatically improve financial outcomes for Kenyan families. Kenya’s central bank governor Patrick Njoroge has pointed

…

out that simply maintaining a digital bank account is not in itself sufficient to give households access to the full range of financial services. M-PESA provides a pathway to basic banking services, but access to credit remains limited. Njoroge noted that “many Kenyans have formal accounts in various forms, but

…

transactions and access simple financial products using personal handheld devices. Second, payment has become a form of identity. The phone number connected to a specific M-PESA account, for example, uniquely identifies an individual for the purpose of conducting a broad range of financial transactions. Third, mobile money provides a channel for

…

the easy transfer of social payments to households as well as household payments for government services with less exposure to corruption. M-PESA kiosk in Nairobi, Kenya Mobile money has also provided a route for cross-border remittances and payments for commercial transactions. This is typically a costly

…

is laudable, there are other ways to promote financial inclusion, including through private sector initiatives. As we saw in Chapter 3, mobile money such as M-PESA has had great success. Given the latent demand for financial services, it is therefore worth considering what factors, including government regulations and technological barriers, might

…

Kenya, see https://datahelpdesk.worldbank.org/knowledgebase/articles/906519-world-bank-country-and-lending-groups. M-PESA For more information on M-PESA, see https://www.safaricom.co.ke/personal/m-pesa and https://www.vodafone.com/what-we-do/services/m-pesa. The World Bank estimates that 17.8 percent of Kenya’s population had internet access

…

Jack (2016) for an analysis of the effects of mobile money on poverty. This is also the source for the figure on the usage of M-PESA among Kenyan households. The Bottom Line on Mobile Money One example of mobile money allegedly fueling illicit activities comes from Zimbabwe. In May 2020, the

The Age of Cryptocurrency: How Bitcoin and Digital Money Are Challenging the Global Economic Order

by Paul Vigna and Michael J. Casey  · 27 Jan 2015  · 457pp  · 128,838 words

, i.e., text messages. All one needs to do is open a wallet with 37Coins. It’s similar to a popular service called M-Pesa in Kenya, but where M-Pesa is run by a telecommunications company, Safaricom, and is built on top of the traditional banking infrastructure, 37Coins works off the decentralized bitcoin

…

microfinance and telecommunications has inspired people’s imaginations over how to address some of these problems. In particular, the excitement revolves around one key product: M-Pesa. M-Pesa (the M is for “mobile,” and “pesa” is Swahili for “money”) started out as an experiment by Kenya’s biggest telecom company, Safaricom. Because many

…

Vodafone, which owns 40 percent of Safaricom, has rolled out the product in Tanzania, South Africa, Mozambique, Egypt, Fiji, India, and even Romania. To use M-Pesa, people sign up for an account and get an e-wallet on their phone. To add money to it, they go to their local Safaricom

…

equivalent amount of “e-float.” This money isn’t actually held in the form of Kenyan shillings but as a separate claim on the overall M-Pesa e-float, all of which is backed by deposits in the banks with which Safaricom has accounts. Users can then send money to other

…

M-Pesa account holders, buy airtime, or pay bills. To withdraw money, users go to the agent and put in for a withdrawal. As long as they

…

have an equivalent amount of e-float in their account, the agent will hand them over the cash right there and then. M-Pesa had a few things going for it. For one thing, Safaricom already had a massive infrastructure in place, not just the telecommunications equipment, but those

…

thousands of agents. M-Pesa was also lucky enough to escape government regulation early on. Lastly, a different form of politics may have played a part. After the country’s

…

the entire country was thrust into a crisis. With the nation’s institutions essentially frozen, people realized there was one way to move money effectively: M-Pesa. For example, one relief group, Concern Worldwide, prevented by violence and cost from getting aid to the region’s remote Kerio Valley, found a solution

…

in M-Pesa. They sent representatives into the valley and set people up with accounts, giving some families phones and solar chargers. Since the nearest agent was some

…

brought these remote villages technology that would prove useful beyond the crisis, and the crisis itself showed M-Pesa’s true worth to its customers, who’ve been steadfastly loyal ever since. An M-Pesa stand (© Tom Spender) M-Pesa has proven to be a lifesaver in other unusual ways, too. On its Web site, Vodafone

…

hospital and can’t afford to travel to one, an organization called Comprehensive Community Based Rehabilitation sent patients money via M-Pesa to cover their travel expenses. But here’s the rub: M-Pesa is not a frictionless system, and in some ways its drawbacks mirror those we’ve outlined in chapter 4: what

…

a trip there takes longer and leaves less time to do actual business. Then there’s the question of how to import funds into the M-Pesa system from overseas. It is not borderless. Its mobile, phone-linked system offers an easier “on-ramp” for remittances than other countries’ more traditional financial

…

of Queens, New York, who was then working as a consultant in Kenya, with an idea: How about combining M-Pesa with a digital currency? It would offer all the advantages of M-Pesa, but would make the costs to users even cheaper for those who import money into that system from abroad, because

…

company is building its own bitcoin-trading platform. She could have raised more. “We took thirty meetings in two weeks, talking about linking bitcoin and M-Pesa, and we saw eyes light up,” she said. Investors understood this was a simple and potentially powerful way to undercut and take market share from

…

, there were forty, and they were doing coding and coming up with their own apps. “People are responding, people are excited about it,” she says. M-Pesa, now combined with a nascent bitcoin community, is proving to be Kenya’s on-ramp to a broader technology revolution, as mobile money and the

…

that developing nations are going to “leapfrog” decades of development thanks to cheap, distributed, decentralized technology—the reality on the ground resists easy solutions. What M-Pesa has achieved, and what BitPesa promises, matter because they are effective tools for promoting economic activity, and thus development. This is why the stories coming

…

from giant e-marketplace Alibaba. And let’s not forget that the phone-as-money idea had its genesis in Kenya, with the wildly successful M-Pesa, now branching out into Eastern European markets. Then there are the dramatic changes seen in the old technology of card payments. Square’s portable card

…

interconnections whose fault lines were revealed six years ago but never fixed, many analysts assume another is inevitable. There’s also a payments-technology precedent: M-Pesa in Kenya, which you will recall got its big break during that country’s 2007 political crisis, when people found they could use it to

…

are only the official flows”: Dilip Ratha, interviewed by Paul Vigna, May 22, 2014. To use M-Pesa, people sign up: Frederik Eijkman, Jake Kendall, and Ignacio Mas, “Bridges to Cash: The Retail End of M-Pesa,” Savings and Development, http://aisberg.unibg.it/bitstream/10446/27458/1/EIJKMAN%202-2010.pdf. one relief

…

history of three characteristics of trust and value of Money: The Unauthorized Biography (Martin) Money & Tech MoneyGram Moore’s law mortgages Mosaic Mt. Gox Mozilla M-Pesa MPEx Murck, Patrick Murphy, Gareth Musk, Elon mystery of capital Nairobi Nakamoto, Dorian Nakamoto, Satoshi disappearance of Finney and search for Szabo and Napster Nash

The Currency Cold War: Cash and Cryptography, Hash Rates and Hegemony

by David G. W. Birch  · 14 Apr 2020  · 247pp  · 60,543 words

, some observers were questioning whether an alternative to bank-led payment infrastructures would ever get off the ground. This perspective changed with the arrival of M-Pesa. M-Pesa M-Pesa is so important that its origins and trajectory need to be recorded and reported from many perspectives. Back in 2003, Safaricom was the market-leading

…

loans in Africa more efficient, so it submitted a proposal to the UK Department for International Development (DFID) for matching funding. This was granted, and M-Pesa was born. The pilot launched in 2005, and within a year the scheme had two million subscribers and was handling $1.5 million per day

…

began to use it. They started depositing cash (employing it as a kind of ‘night safe’) as well as settling transactions and paying wages via M-Pesa. Soon, hundreds of businesses were accepting it as payment. In summary, a non-bank payment system founded on new technology rather than legacy infrastructure had

…

card customers. A key lesson that I took from this project was that a bank-led solution would not have triggered the innovation revolution that M-Pesa did. A key element of its success is that it was born of TELCO culture and conceived as an infrastructure on which others could build

…

the twenty-first century. This year, there will be some three billion mobile money transactions in Kenya. Not all of them will be sent through M-Pesa, but almost all of them will. Let us recap. Moving from a form of digital money that is held in the accounts of financial institutions

…

(solved) authentication problem and the (solved) authenticity problem. These are at the crux of the matter and provide the architectural foundation of e-cash schemes. M-Pesa was e-money that used tamper-resistant hardware to authenticate access to accounts holding the data that represents value. PayPal was e-money that used

…

of these options, to central banks or to anyone else. The idea of a central bank running something like M-Pesa but for citizens is hardly far-fetched. There are tens of millions of M-Pesa users in Kenya, and Facebook can manage well over a couple of billion accounts, so I am sure

…

would be able to do this), but they could use their existing systems to manage it. If we take the lessons from the success of M-Pesa and PayPal, as well as the failure of DigiCash and Mondex, on board (see chapter 1), then we have a good starting point for the

…

but hard to give them terminals. It is easy to create e-coins but hard to persuade shops to take them. A decade after Mondex, M-Pesa opted to use neither cards nor terminals; instead, it used mobile phones to vault a non-bank through a regulatory gap to create something that

…

transformed the lives of millions. Note that both Mondex and M-Pesa used cryptography with hardware at its core to protect the integrity of the system. In the case of Mondex, this was the now-familiar smart

…

card that chip-and-PIN has propelled into every pocket. In the case of M-Pesa, this was the SIM card (which is actually the same thing) that GSMA has propelled into every phone in every pocket. Mondex was decentralized

…

, M-Pesa was centralized; both were managed by a central authority, and in both cases the electronic value in the chips was issued against a 100% reserve

…

ECB phrase, not mine) retail payments sector. When looking at the options for cash replacement and reflecting on experiences with population-scale schemes such as M-Pesa in Kenya, I come to the following conclusions. It seems to me that providing a good API on top of the system and allowing innovators

…

global financial system to hold and transfer value, but I remain unconvinced. There are plenty of ways to hold and transfer electronic value (e.g. M-Pesa) without using bank accounts. Generally speaking, people around the world are excluded because of regulation (e.g. KYC), so if we want to do something

…

book The Social Life of Money, utopias – from Plato’s Republic to Star Trek – do not usually seem to include money at all, never mind M-Pesa or Bitcoin. Anyhow, the story that interested me has a ‘guy falls asleep under hypnosis, wakes up a century later to find a model society

…

no-frills nature of the accounts’ (Economist 2018). Given that a centralized system has the lowest cost, all signs seem to point towards something like M-Pesa, but a version run by the government, rather than something built using federated databases or decentralized shared ledgers. The World Economic Forum notes that one

…

currency denominated and interest-bearing access to its balance sheet. The cheapest alternative to running such a system would be a fully centralized architecture like M-Pesa. To some observers, simply giving anyone and everyone an account at the central bank is the cheapest and simplest way forward. Supporters of that approach

…

call it Brit-Pesa), we would not use either the smart cards of the Mondex days or the basic SIM toolkit and SMS technology of M-Pesa. We would use smartphones, chatbots, AI, fingerprints, voice recognition and all that jazz (the biometrics, blockchains and bots we discussed in chapter 2). I do

…

kind of transactional system: pseudonymity is an obvious way to do this efficiently within a democratic framework. Thus, while we could envisage digital fiat as M-Pesa run by the central bank or a sort of government PayPal, there are arguments in favour of using newer and more radical meta-technology architecture

…

modern age and create MacPesa: this would be a digital money system rather like Kenya’s M-Pesa (as discussed in the earlier case study), with a few crucial enhancements to take advantage of new technology. M-Pesa is an amazing success, but it is not perfect. In recent times, it has gone down

…

send money. These failures cost the economy a significant amount (billions of shillings), which is not surprising when you remember that M-Pesa moves billions of Kenyan shillings every day. So, when M-Pesa drops out, it leaves customers hanging, it leaves agents losing revenue and it leaves the banks unable to transact. It

…

is now a vital piece of national infrastructure, just as MacPesa would be. I have indicated that the M-Pesa system goes down from time to time; so, what if there were no system in the middle to go down anymore? What if the TELCOs

…

’s lack of intermediaries and settlement. Remember, he was writing this before there was a Google or a Netscape, let alone a PayPal or an M-Pesa. In his vision, you send me an IBM dollar and I put it in my wallet. Instead of bank accounts in conventional fiat currency, companies

…

it adopt some form of digital cash that can be passed directly from person to person, like Bitcoin, or some form of e-money, like M-Pesa, using hardware rather than proof of work to prevent double-spending? This is what was being tested in Uruguay, where the central bank ran a

Your Computer Is on Fire

by Thomas S. Mullaney, Benjamin Peters, Mar Hicks and Kavita Philip  · 9 Mar 2021  · 661pp  · 156,009 words

.6 Meanwhile, banking systems long reliant upon state-governed infrastructures are rapidly being displaced on the African continent by the cellphone-based money transfer system M-Pesa—the largest mobile-money business in the world.7 And bringing us full circle, many of the cellphones upon which this multibillion-dollar economy runs

…

countries; here I focus on its role in South Africa, where it helped anti-apartheid activists communicate with counterparts both inside and outside the country. M-Pesa, a mobile money system first rolled out in Kenya in 2007, is already used by the majority of Kenyans; it is fast emerging as a

…

of the world via email. For many African users, FidoNet was the only alternative. This “poor man’s internet” served them, however briefly, as infrastructure. M-Pesa M-Pesa is a cellphone-based mobile money system, first rolled out in Kenya in 2007 by mobile phone operator Safaricom. (“Pesa” means “money” in Swahili.) When

…

clients sign up for M-Pesa, they receive a new SIM card containing the M-Pesa software. Clients “load” money onto their phones by handing over cash to one of the 160,000+ authorized

…

M-Pesa agents. Friends, relatives, or employers can also load money to the client’s phone. Clients can use the money to buy airtime or to pay

…

bills at hundreds of enterprises. To date, however, clients have used M-Pesa principally for “remittances,” the common practice of wage-earning workers sending money to family or friends elsewhere. M-Pesa offers a safe, secure method of storing money in an environment where many workers are migrants supporting

…

family members in remote areas and robbery is common, especially when traveling. Businesses now use M-Pesa for mass payments such as payrolls—not only a major convenience but also a far more secure method than cash disbursements. The service charges small

…

fees (maximum $1–3 US dollars) for sending money or collecting withdrawals from an agent. Safaricom earns more on large business transactions. M-Pesa has enjoyed enormous success in Kenya. By 2011, just four years after it was launched, over thirteen million users—representing some 70 percent of all

…

percent of the country’s $55 billion GDP passed through the system.35 By the end of 2018 M-Pesa subscribers in Kenya numbered 25.5 million—half the country’s total population. While M-Pesa originally focused on domestic transfers among Kenyans, Safaricom and part-owner Vodacom (South Africa) have since expanded the

…

business to seven other African countries. M-Pesa also operates in Romania and Afghanistan, as well as in India, one of the world’s largest markets for such services. Given that international remittances

…

billion global business, prospects seem very bright for a low-cost, user-friendly mobile money system that can operate on even the simplest cellphones. The M-Pesa project began in 2003 with a handful of individuals at London-based Vodafone, as a response to the United Nations’ Millennium Development Goals. Supported in

…

, unconnected, often semi-literate, and who faced routine challenges to their physical and financial security.”36 Since M-Pesa would have to run on any cellphone, no matter how basic, the hardware platform chosen for M-Pesa was the lowly SIM card itself. The software platform was the SIM Application Toolkit, a GSM (Global

…

caused breakdowns in this process and required businesses to rework their own methods, causing them to clamor for a genuine API. A 2012 assessment of M-Pesa noted that the eventual API performed poorly, but also that a mini-industry of software developers and integrators has started to specialize in

…

M-Pesa platform integration. . . . These bridge builders fall into two broad categories: 1) those that are strengthening M-Pesa’s connections with financial institutions for the delivery of financial products, and 2) those that are strengthening

…

M-Pesa’s ability to interoperate with other mobile and online payment systems. The lack of a functional M-Pesa API is hindering bridge-building, but several companies have devised tools for new financial functions and online payments

…

nonetheless.37 This trajectory reflects the typical platform pattern of development. Once established, the core component, namely the M-Pesa software, acquired a number of developers building complementary components. Other developers built better interfaces between the core and the complementary components, leading to

…

M-Pesa-based financial services such as pension schemes, medical savings plans, and insurance offerings. This “mobile money ecosystem” is a kind of parallel universe to traditional

…

banking.38 Indeed, today a Google search on M-Pesa categorizes it simply as a “bank.” Is the short-cycle temporality of platforms and second-order systems the future of infrastructure

…

? M-Pesa went from drawing board to multibillion-dollar business in less than ten years. More importantly for my argument, M-Pesa rapidly acquired the status of fundamental infrastructure for the majority of Kenyan adults, serving as a

…

and second-order systems—imagined, created, and provided by private-sector firms—the future of infrastructure? Will the swift takeoff of quasi-infrastructures such as M-Pesa be matched by equally swift displacement, as happened to FidoNet when internet protocols swept away its raison d’être? To me, history suggests an affirmative

…

Emerging Platform: From Money Transfer System to Mobile Money Ecosystem,” Innovations 6, no. 4 (2012): 51. 35. Eric Wainaina, “42% of Kenya GDP Transacted on M-Pesa and 9 Takeaways from Safaricom Results,” Techweez: Technology News & Reviews (May 7, 2015), http://www.techweez.com/2015/05/07/ten-takeaways-safaricom-2015-results

…

/. 36. Nick Hughes and Susie Lonie, “M-Pesa: Mobile Money for the ‘Unbanked,’” Innovations 2 (2007); Sibel Kusimba, Gabriel Kunyu, and Elizabeth Gross, “Social Networks of Mobile Money in Kenya,” in Money at

…

). 41. Milford Bateman, Maren Duvendack, and Nicholas Loubere, “Is Fin-Tech the New Panacea for Poverty Alleviation and Local Development? Contesting Suri and Jack’s M-Pesa Findings Published in Science,” Review of African Political Economy (2019); Kusimba, Kunyu, and Gross, “Social Networks of Mobile Money in Kenya.” 42. Anne Helmond, “The

…

–58, 62, 66, 122 CDC (Center for Disease Control), 20 CDU (Christian Democratic Union), 170 Cellular phones (cell), 7, 306, 317, 332, 365, 378 and M-PESA, 7, 322, 326–328, 333 Safaricom, 326–328, 333 SIM card, 326–328 Chex Quest, 237 Child pornography, 6, 117–125, 127–130 limit case

…

, 111 Facebook, 330 internet, 329–330 and language, 180, 186–187, 191 typographic, 226–227 India accent bias, 188–190 Britain and, 148 caste, 299 M-Pesa, 327 Muslim women, 298 women, 162, 256, 288, 297, 306 prime minister of, 298, 330 rising superpower, 153 Scheduled Castes, 299 Scheduled Tribes, 299 Skill

…

Monty Python, 233–234 Monty Python & the Quest for the Holy Grail, 234 Moore, Germaine, 117–120, 128–129 Moore’s Law, 57 Mozilla, 191 M-Pesa, 7, 322, 326–328, 333 MS-DOS, 323 Mubarak, Hosni, 84 MUC Draughts, 246 Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD), 300 Musical Instrument Digital Interfaces, 353

The Innovation Paradox: Developing-Country Capabilities and the Unrealized Promise of Technological Catch-Up

by Xavier Cirera and William Francis Maloney  · 14 Jun 2017  · 373pp  · 109,964 words

Digital Bank: Strategies for Launching or Becoming a Digital Bank

by Chris Skinner  · 27 Aug 2013  · 329pp  · 95,309 words

The Industries of the Future

by Alec Ross  · 2 Feb 2016  · 364pp  · 99,897 words

The History of Money

by David McWilliams  · 330pp  · 110,174 words

The End of Money: Counterfeiters, Preachers, Techies, Dreamers--And the Coming Cashless Society

by David Wolman  · 14 Feb 2012  · 275pp  · 77,017 words

Bitcoin: The Future of Money?

by Dominic Frisby  · 1 Nov 2014  · 233pp  · 66,446 words

We-Think: Mass Innovation, Not Mass Production

by Charles Leadbeater  · 9 Dec 2010  · 313pp  · 84,312 words

The Future Is Faster Than You Think: How Converging Technologies Are Transforming Business, Industries, and Our Lives

by Peter H. Diamandis and Steven Kotler  · 28 Jan 2020  · 501pp  · 114,888 words

Pax Technica: How the Internet of Things May Set Us Free or Lock Us Up

by Philip N. Howard  · 27 Apr 2015  · 322pp  · 84,752 words

The Pay Off: How Changing the Way We Pay Changes Everything

by Gottfried Leibbrandt and Natasha de Teran  · 14 Jul 2021  · 326pp  · 91,532 words

Poor Economics: A Radical Rethinking of the Way to Fight Global Poverty

by Abhijit Banerjee and Esther Duflo  · 25 Apr 2011  · 370pp  · 112,602 words

No Such Thing as a Free Gift: The Gates Foundation and the Price of Philanthropy

by Linsey McGoey  · 14 Apr 2015  · 324pp  · 93,606 words

The Emperor's New Road: How China's New Silk Road Is Remaking the World

by Jonathan Hillman  · 28 Sep 2020  · 388pp  · 99,023 words

Doughnut Economics: Seven Ways to Think Like a 21st-Century Economist

by Kate Raworth  · 22 Mar 2017  · 403pp  · 111,119 words

Geek Heresy: Rescuing Social Change From the Cult of Technology

by Kentaro Toyama  · 25 May 2015  · 494pp  · 116,739 words

Cities Are Good for You: The Genius of the Metropolis

by Leo Hollis  · 31 Mar 2013  · 385pp  · 118,314 words

The Truth Machine: The Blockchain and the Future of Everything

by Paul Vigna and Michael J. Casey  · 27 Feb 2018  · 348pp  · 97,277 words

Breakout Nations: In Pursuit of the Next Economic Miracles

by Ruchir Sharma  · 8 Apr 2012  · 411pp  · 114,717 words

The Bitcoin Guidebook: How to Obtain, Invest, and Spend the World's First Decentralized Cryptocurrency

by Ian Demartino  · 2 Feb 2016  · 296pp  · 86,610 words

The Great Surge: The Ascent of the Developing World

by Steven Radelet  · 10 Nov 2015  · 437pp  · 115,594 words

Adventures in the Anthropocene: A Journey to the Heart of the Planet We Made

by Gaia Vince  · 19 Oct 2014  · 505pp  · 147,916 words

Blitzscaling: The Lightning-Fast Path to Building Massively Valuable Companies

by Reid Hoffman and Chris Yeh  · 14 Apr 2018  · 286pp  · 87,401 words

How the Other Half Banks: Exclusion, Exploitation, and the Threat to Democracy

by Mehrsa Baradaran  · 5 Oct 2015  · 424pp  · 121,425 words

No Ordinary Disruption: The Four Global Forces Breaking All the Trends

by Richard Dobbs and James Manyika  · 12 May 2015  · 389pp  · 87,758 words

Lonely Planet Kenya

by Lonely Planet

Frugal Innovation: How to Do Better With Less

by Jaideep Prabhu Navi Radjou  · 15 Feb 2015  · 400pp  · 88,647 words

The Evolution of Everything: How New Ideas Emerge

by Matt Ridley  · 395pp  · 116,675 words

Smart Cities: Big Data, Civic Hackers, and the Quest for a New Utopia

by Anthony M. Townsend  · 29 Sep 2013  · 464pp  · 127,283 words

Give People Money

by Annie Lowrey  · 10 Jul 2018  · 242pp  · 73,728 words

The One Device: The Secret History of the iPhone

by Brian Merchant  · 19 Jun 2017  · 416pp  · 129,308 words

Rebooting India: Realizing a Billion Aspirations

by Nandan Nilekani  · 4 Feb 2016  · 332pp  · 100,601 words

Augmented: Life in the Smart Lane

by Brett King  · 5 May 2016  · 385pp  · 111,113 words

Cloudmoney: Cash, Cards, Crypto, and the War for Our Wallets

by Brett Scott  · 4 Jul 2022  · 308pp  · 85,850 words

Money in the Metaverse: Digital Assets, Online Identities, Spatial Computing and Why Virtual Worlds Mean Real Business

by David G. W. Birch and Victoria Richardson  · 28 Apr 2024  · 249pp  · 74,201 words

Taming the Sun: Innovations to Harness Solar Energy and Power the Planet

by Varun Sivaram  · 2 Mar 2018  · 469pp  · 132,438 words

Whole Earth Discipline: An Ecopragmatist Manifesto

by Stewart Brand  · 15 Mar 2009  · 422pp  · 113,525 words

Blockchain: Blueprint for a New Economy

by Melanie Swan  · 22 Jan 2014  · 271pp  · 52,814 words

Dead Aid: Why Aid Is Not Working and How There Is a Better Way for Africa

by Dambisa Moyo  · 17 Mar 2009  · 225pp  · 61,388 words

Profiting Without Producing: How Finance Exploits Us All

by Costas Lapavitsas  · 14 Aug 2013  · 554pp  · 158,687 words

House of Huawei: The Secret History of China's Most Powerful Company

by Eva Dou  · 14 Jan 2025  · 394pp  · 110,159 words

The Social Life of Money

by Nigel Dodd  · 14 May 2014  · 700pp  · 201,953 words

The Smartphone Society

by Nicole Aschoff

Attack of the 50 Foot Blockchain: Bitcoin, Blockchain, Ethereum & Smart Contracts

by David Gerard  · 23 Jul 2017  · 309pp  · 54,839 words

User Friendly: How the Hidden Rules of Design Are Changing the Way We Live, Work & Play

by Cliff Kuang and Robert Fabricant  · 7 Nov 2019

Power and Progress: Our Thousand-Year Struggle Over Technology and Prosperity

by Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson  · 15 May 2023  · 619pp  · 177,548 words

The Virgin Way: Everything I Know About Leadership

by Richard Branson  · 8 Sep 2014  · 315pp  · 99,065 words

The Unbanking of America: How the New Middle Class Survives

by Lisa Servon  · 10 Jan 2017  · 279pp  · 76,796 words

Code Dependent: Living in the Shadow of AI

by Madhumita Murgia  · 20 Mar 2024  · 336pp  · 91,806 words

The Switch: How Solar, Storage and New Tech Means Cheap Power for All

by Chris Goodall  · 6 Jul 2016  · 271pp  · 79,367 words

Fully Automated Luxury Communism

by Aaron Bastani  · 10 Jun 2019  · 280pp  · 74,559 words

Blockchain Revolution: How the Technology Behind Bitcoin Is Changing Money, Business, and the World

by Don Tapscott and Alex Tapscott  · 9 May 2016  · 515pp  · 126,820 words

Radical Technologies: The Design of Everyday Life

by Adam Greenfield  · 29 May 2017  · 410pp  · 119,823 words

Portfolios of the poor: how the world's poor live on $2 a day

by Daryl Collins, Jonathan Morduch and Stuart Rutherford  · 15 Jan 2009  · 296pp  · 87,299 words

Fixed: Why Personal Finance is Broken and How to Make it Work for Everyone

by John Y. Campbell and Tarun Ramadorai  · 25 Jul 2025

The Inevitable: Understanding the 12 Technological Forces That Will Shape Our Future

by Kevin Kelly  · 6 Jun 2016  · 371pp  · 108,317 words

Platform Scale: How an Emerging Business Model Helps Startups Build Large Empires With Minimum Investment

by Sangeet Paul Choudary  · 14 Sep 2015  · 302pp  · 73,581 words

Brilliant, Crazy, Cocky: How the Top 1% of Entrepreneurs Profit From Global Chaos

by Sarah Lacy  · 6 Jan 2011  · 269pp  · 77,876 words

Dual Transformation: How to Reposition Today's Business While Creating the Future

by Scott D. Anthony and Mark W. Johnson  · 27 Mar 2017  · 293pp  · 78,439 words

More: The 10,000-Year Rise of the World Economy

by Philip Coggan  · 6 Feb 2020  · 524pp  · 155,947 words

Digital Empires: The Global Battle to Regulate Technology

by Anu Bradford  · 25 Sep 2023  · 898pp  · 236,779 words

Seven Crashes: The Economic Crises That Shaped Globalization

by Harold James  · 15 Jan 2023  · 469pp  · 137,880 words

Doing Good Better: How Effective Altruism Can Help You Make a Difference

by William MacAskill  · 27 Jul 2015  · 293pp  · 81,183 words

The Blockchain Alternative: Rethinking Macroeconomic Policy and Economic Theory

by Kariappa Bheemaiah  · 26 Feb 2017  · 492pp  · 118,882 words

The New Harvest: Agricultural Innovation in Africa

by Calestous Juma  · 27 May 2017

The Long History of the Future: Why Tomorrow's Technology Still Isn't Here

by Nicole Kobie  · 3 Jul 2024  · 348pp  · 119,358 words

Other People's Money: Masters of the Universe or Servants of the People?

by John Kay  · 2 Sep 2015  · 478pp  · 126,416 words

Culture & Empire: Digital Revolution

by Pieter Hintjens  · 11 Mar 2013  · 349pp  · 114,038 words

Seriously Curious: The Facts and Figures That Turn Our World Upside Down

by Tom Standage  · 27 Nov 2018  · 215pp  · 59,188 words

Digital Transformation at Scale: Why the Strategy Is Delivery

by Andrew Greenway,Ben Terrett,Mike Bracken,Tom Loosemore  · 18 Jun 2018

Fair Shot: Rethinking Inequality and How We Earn

by Chris Hughes  · 20 Feb 2018  · 173pp  · 53,564 words

Green Swans: The Coming Boom in Regenerative Capitalism

by John Elkington  · 6 Apr 2020  · 384pp  · 93,754 words

The Driver in the Driverless Car: How Our Technology Choices Will Create the Future

by Vivek Wadhwa and Alex Salkever  · 2 Apr 2017  · 181pp  · 52,147 words

Money: The True Story of a Made-Up Thing

by Jacob Goldstein  · 14 Aug 2020  · 199pp  · 64,272 words

The Tyranny of Experts: Economists, Dictators, and the Forgotten Rights of the Poor

by William Easterly  · 4 Mar 2014  · 483pp  · 134,377 words

MegaThreats: Ten Dangerous Trends That Imperil Our Future, and How to Survive Them

by Nouriel Roubini  · 17 Oct 2022  · 328pp  · 96,678 words

Everything for Everyone: The Radical Tradition That Is Shaping the Next Economy

by Nathan Schneider  · 10 Sep 2018  · 326pp  · 91,559 words

Future Crimes: Everything Is Connected, Everyone Is Vulnerable and What We Can Do About It

by Marc Goodman  · 24 Feb 2015  · 677pp  · 206,548 words

Cybersecurity: What Everyone Needs to Know

by P. W. Singer and Allan Friedman  · 3 Jan 2014  · 587pp  · 117,894 words

Digital Gold: Bitcoin and the Inside Story of the Misfits and Millionaires Trying to Reinvent Money

by Nathaniel Popper  · 18 May 2015  · 387pp  · 112,868 words

Future Files: A Brief History of the Next 50 Years

by Richard Watson  · 1 Jan 2008

This Is Service Design Doing: Applying Service Design Thinking in the Real World: A Practitioners' Handbook

by Marc Stickdorn, Markus Edgar Hormess, Adam Lawrence and Jakob Schneider  · 12 Jan 2018  · 704pp  · 182,312 words