description: self-interests causing depletion of a shared resource
242 results
by Steven Pinker · 13 Feb 2018 · 1,034pp · 241,773 words
are a distraction from the gargantuan challenge facing us. The problem is that carbon emissions are a classic public goods game, also known as a Tragedy of the Commons. People benefit from everyone else’s sacrifices and suffer from their own, so everyone has an incentive to be a free rider and let everyone
…
that economists call a negative externality (another name for the collective costs in a public goods game, or the damage to the commons in the Tragedy of the Commons). A carbon tax, which only governments can impose, “internalizes” the public costs, forcing people to factor the harm into every carbon-emitting decision they make
…
Galbraith, John Kenneth, 206 Galileo, 24 Galton, Francis, 399 Galtung, John, 41 game theory, 164, 386 See also Hobbesian trap (security dilemma); pacifist’s dilemma; Tragedy of the Commons Gandhi, Indira, 131 Gandhi, Mohandas, 405, 418. See also nonviolent resistance Gapminder (Web site), xviii, 52 Gates, Bill, 66, 67, 330, 481n16 gay rights. See
…
See also cognitive biases psychotherapy cognitive behavior therapy, 282 Feedback-Informed Treatment, 380 and media focus on negative news, 286–7 public goods game. See Tragedy of the Commons public health bioterror and international networks, 301 Ebola control, 307 Nazi Holocaust invoking, 399 revolution of, 64, 83 See also vaccines “Publius Decius Mus” (Michael
…
, Omar, 447 trade benefits of, 13, 84, 162, 198–9, 228 Trump and international, 334–5 Tragedy of the Belief Commons. See identity-protective cognition Tragedy of the Commons, 141 for beliefs, 358, 359, 376, 379 for carbon emissions, 141, 151, 153, 154 transgenic crops, 77–8, 331 transportation agriculture and food supply and
by Lawrence Lessig · 14 Jul 2001 · 494pp · 142,285 words
of a park, as in the Boston Common. If you've studied economics or political science, your mind will race to tragedy (as in “the tragedy of the commons"). Both senses are related to what I mean, but neither alone is enough.1 The Oxford English Dictionary (mankind's first large-scale collaborative open
…
it will be depleted by the consumption of all. This depletion of a rivalrous resource is the dynamic that biologist Garrett Hardin famously termed “the tragedy of the commons.”7 “Picture a pasture open to all,” Hardin writes, and consider the expected behavior of “herdsmen” who roam that pasture. Each herdsman must decide whether
…
. And, in turn, this blindness leads us to ignore changes to the norms and architecture of the Net that weaken this commons. There is a tragedy of the commons that we will identify here; it is the tragedy of losing the innovation commons that the Internet is, through the changes that are being rendered
…
. . . . [H]ere in the industry, all the projects that are “hot” are networks with built-in techniques of exclusion and prioritization.74 Here is a tragedy of the commons. If the commons is the innovation commons that the protocols of the Net embrace, e2e most important among them, then the tragedy of that commons
…
ends to discriminate, then the ends will restrict and discriminate regardless of the effect on others. Here, then, we have the beginnings of a classic “tragedy of the commons.”46 For if keeping the network as a commons provides a benefit to all, yet closing individual links in the network provides a benefit to
…
the Internet. Yet the architecture of the Internet . . . seriously misallocates scarce bandwidth. Because data cannot easily be prioritized, or billed, within the existing Internet protocols, tragedy of the commons appears frequently. High value communications are jammed in congested arteries with massive volumes of data of only marginal significance. Classically, the brain surgeon cannot read
…
how does her ability to use the Net determine whether the Net “seriously misallocates” resources? Hazlett offers no data to support the claim that the “tragedy of the commons appears frequently.” In fact, capacity has consistently outstripped demand.36 More significant, Hazlett ignores the advantages to innovation that I have identified throughout this book
…
Daldy [imprint], 1871), iii-iv (“There is a common of language to which both poetry and prose have the freest access.”). 7 Garrett Hardin, “The Tragedy of the Commons,” Science 162 (1968): 1243. The idea of congestion externalities of course predates Hardin. See Posner, “Economic Analysis of Law,” 32-34, citing Frank H. Knight
…
, ed. (San Francisco: ICS Press, 1992), part 2 (describing case studies). 10 Elinor Ostrom has been the most effective in demonstrating the “fallacy” of the “tragedy of the commons.” As she writes: What makes these models so dangerous—when they are used metaphorically as the foundation for policy—is that the constraints that are
…
with end-to-end, but simply that it provides a consistent protocol that could be implemented consistent with end-to-end. 53 Garrett Hardin, “The Tragedy of the Commons,” Science 162 (1968): 1243, 1244 (emphasis added). 54 National Research Council, 24-25. 55 As Faulhaber put it, “[T]he third view is that, as
by Steven Pinker · 14 Oct 2021 · 533pp · 125,495 words
in advance, tying him to the mast for his own good during the frenzy of an Ego Escalation Game. The Prisoner’s Dilemma and the Tragedy of the Commons Consider a familiar plot from Law and Order. A prosecutor detains partners in crime in separate cells, lacks the evidence to convict them, and offers
…
else pays for them and they are free riders—once a lighthouse is built, anyone can see it. In a poignant environmental version called the Tragedy of the Commons, every shepherd has an incentive to add one more sheep to his flock and graze it on the town commons, but when everyone fattens their
…
can train them to avoid the fallacies outside the classroom.84 * * * • • • Rationality is a public good, and a public good sets the stage for a tragedy of the commons. In the Tragedy of the Rationality Commons, motivated reasoning for the benefit of oneself and one’s side produces an opportunity to free ride on
…
, 241–42, 243–44 Tooby, J., 169 Toplak, M. F., 356–57n67 trade and investment, international, 327 Tragedy of the Carbon Commons, 242–44, 328 Tragedy of the Commons, 242, 243–44, 315 Tragedy of the Rationality Commons, 298, 315–17 Trivers, Robert, 241 trolley problem, 97 Trump, Donald, 6, 60, 82–83, 88
by William Easterly · 1 Mar 2006
can also deal with property owned by the community, like common pastureland on which all can graze their cows. Common property is subject to the “tragedy of the commons” problem, in which each herdsman overgrazes the pasture because the costs are borne by the community rather than by the herdsman. (I want my cow
…
to eat the grass before your cow does.) However, if population density is low and land abundant, the tragedy of the commons does not arise, and community ownership works fine. Even when pressure on the land tightens up, informal community arrangements can still control overgrazing (say the
…
offered this account of how his village in Benin managed a common property resource, the fishing pond (overfishing is a classic example used for the tragedy of the commons), when he was growing up: To open the fishing season, elders performed ritual tests at Amlé, a lake fifteen kilometers from the village. If the
…
other issue lobbies of its demands on the scarce aid and administrative resources of agencies, each lobby overemphasizes its goals. This is analogous to the “tragedy of the commons” problem in which too many cows overgraze pastures held in common. To make things worse, each separate aid agency has felt the political pressure to
…
“frame-works” that do everything for the consumer. Consumers pay the cost of asking a product to meet additional goals, and so there is no “tragedy of the commons” excess demand for goals on any one product. Consumers face tradeoffs between alternative products, choosing the one that gives the highest satisfaction for the lowest
…
colonized high-technology exports IMF aid to takeoff in ten best per capita growth rates Thompson, Tommy Tibet tied aid titles to property Togo trachoma tragedy of the commons traps “poverty trap,” Trebbi, Francesco Trevelyan, Charles triads triple-drug cocktail Truman, Harry S. Tshisekedi, Étienne tuberculosis Tullock, Gordon Turkey Turkmenistan Tutsis Twain, Mark tyranny
by Roger Scruton · 30 Apr 2014 · 426pp · 118,913 words
an important part to play. Rational self-interest is subject to the well-known free rider and prisoner’s dilemma syndromes, and can avert ‘the tragedy of the commons’17 only in special circumstances. Social contract theorists, from Hobbes to Rawls, have attempted to overcome the problems of social choice, but always they come
…
that is the failure of collective rationality commented upon by Aristotle in the Politics and known, following an acclaimed article by Garrett Hardin, as ‘the tragedy of the commons’.151 Many of the earth’s resources are either unowned or owned in common by some particular community – the fish in a lake, the grazing
…
Common Fisheries Policy of the European Union. Yet it is precisely the wrong response, not the least because it fails to take seriously what the tragedy of the commons shows. Even if people were not greedy, but merely wishing to obtain enough to satisfy their needs, a common resource would run the risk of
…
to resist him. This is the reason for thinking that it is not state control, but property rights, that are the real solution to the tragedy of the commons. And once property rights are in place they lead of their own accord to a market, as people transfer their rights to those most eager
…
to acquire them and in return receive something preferable in exchange. The tragedy of the commons is not due to market failure, but to market absence. Hence there have been very few vulnerable resources that have not been managed, by those
…
Switzerland, by a democratic vote among members of a defined local community with exclusive rights to take the relevant decisions.160 Those solutions to the tragedy of the commons depend on the rational self-interest of essentially co-operative people. Much of the antipathy to market solutions has come from those who see markets
…
the same kind of countervailing pressures that are exerted by a market on competition among individuals, and if so, whether these pressures will prevent the tragedy of the commons. But they also challenge us to find other forms of negative feedback than those associated with ‘market forces’. Long before Ostrom put the study of
…
common advantage. Game theory, the theory of the market, the theories of preference orderings and social choice – all have addressed the question encapsulated in the tragedy of the commons. And those disciplines have finely illustrated the difficulties that impede co-ordination when we try to adjust our choices to the sparse information that we
…
of national property rights, which had been effective in conserving fish stocks in the North Sea and the English Channel, was destroyed, and a new tragedy of the commons created in its place. The result has been a major ecological disaster, with stocks in the North Sea continuing to decline at an alarming rate
…
of Swiss participatory democracy, in which the people are involved at every stage in planning their environment.333 Curzon Price shows in detail how the tragedy of the commons is enacted under the regime that operates in France, while it is avoided for the most part in Switzerland, as people come to agree among
…
, www.arab-hdr.org/publications/other/ahdr/ahdr2009e.pdf. 16 On the theory of ‘rent seeking’, see Chapters 3 and 4. 17 Garrett Hardin, ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’, Science, 162.1, 1968, pp. 243 –8. 18 Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan, 1651; John Rawls, A Theory of Justice, 1971, 2005. 19 Edmund Burke, Reflections on
…
Peltzman was the first to hit on the idea. 150 Adams, op. cit. 151 See 1261b in Aristotle, The Politics, Oxford, 1994; Garrett Hardin, ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’, Science, 162, 13 December 1968, pp. 1243–8. Hardin’s original response to the tragedy was to call for government intervention to protect ‘public assets
…
A. C. Pigou, The Economics of Welfare, London, 1920, part 2. Pigou’s solution was accepted by Garrett Hardin, in his original response to ‘the tragedy of the commons’. Later he became more ‘Coasey’. 175 Coase’s Theorem is also insensitive to the so-called ‘endowment effect’, according to which the receipt of property
…
York, Oxford University Press, 2009. Hansen, James, Storms of My Grandchildren: The Truth About the Coming Climate Catastrophe, New York, Bloomsbury, 2009. Hardin, Garret, ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’, Science, 162, 13 December 1968, pp. 1243–8. Harvey, Graham, The Killing of the Countryside, London, Jonathan Cape, 1997. Hayek, Friedrich A., Individualism and Economic
…
, ref2n, ref3 Tooby, John, ref1 tort law, ref1, ref2, ref3, ref4 Town and Country Planning Association, ref1 Trade-Related Intellectual Property Rights, ref1 tradition, ref1 tragedy of the commons, ref1, ref2, ref3 transition towns, ref1 transnational government, ref1, ref2 treaties, ref1f, ref2, ref3, ref4, ref5 Treaty of Rome, ref1 Trevelyan, G. M., ref1, ref2
by Steven Pinker · 24 Sep 2012 · 1,351pp · 385,579 words
reckoned in the lives of soldiers. The War of Attrition is one of those paradoxical scenarios in game theory (like the Prisoner’s Dilemma, the Tragedy of the Commons, and the Dollar Auction) in which a set of rational actors pursuing their interests end up worse off than if they had put their heads
…
be women around. They just want someone else to raise them. Female infanticide is a kind of social parasitism, a free rider problem, a genealogical tragedy of the commons.129 Free rider problems arise when no one owns a common resource, in this case, the pool of potential brides. In a free market in
…
. The tragedy is that contributions will dwindle to zero and everyone ends up worse off. (The biologist Garrett Hardin proposed an identical scenario called the Tragedy of the Commons. Each farmer cannot resist grazing his own cow on the town commons, stripping it bare to everyone’s loss. Pollution, overfishing, and carbon emissions are
…
: Axelrod, 1984/2006. 188. Indirect reciprocity: Nowak, 2006; Nowak & Sigmund, 1998. 189. Public Goods game: Fehr & Gächter, 2000; Herrmann, Thöni, & Gächter, 2008a; Ridley, 1997. 190. Tragedy of the Commons: Hardin, 1968. 191. Effectiveness of deterrence in economic games: Fehr & Gächter, 2000; Herrmann, Thöni, & Gächter, 2008b; McCullough, 2008; McCullough et al., 2010; Ridley, 1997. 192
…
Society & History, 18, 297–320. Hanlon, G. 2007. Human nature in rural Tuscany: An early modern history. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Hardin, G. 1968. The tragedy of the commons. Science, 162, 1243–48. Hare, R. D. 1993. Without conscience: The disturbing world of the psychopaths around us. New York: Guilford Press. Harff, B. 2003
…
of and gentle commerce Cool Hand Luke (film) Cooney, Mark cooperation in commerce evolution of and intelligence norms of in Prisoner’s Dilemma games and Tragedy of the Commons coordination games corporal punishment: of children and torture Correlates of War Project Cosmides, Leda cosmopolitanism and democracy and end of Cold War vs. genocidal ideologies
…
gambling, and violence game theory; see also coordination games; Dictator game; Escalation game; Pacifist’s Dilemma; positive-sum games; Prisoner’s Dilemma; Public Goods game; Tragedy of the Commons; Trust game; Ultimatum game; War of Attrition game; zero-sum games Gandhi, Indira Gandhi, Mohandas K. Gandhi, Rajmohan Gangs of New York (film) Garrard, Graeme
…
executions totalitarianism and genocide see also autocracy; dictatorships; theocracy total war Townshend, Pete Toynbee, Arnold, A Study of History trade, international trafficking, see human trafficking Tragedy of the Commons Tremblay, Richard tribalism tribes: archaeological sites and community elders group dominance horse tribes kinship in and sorcery violence between and witchcraft see also hunter-gatherers
by Bruce Schneier · 14 Feb 2012 · 503pp · 131,064 words
its members forsake their own interests when they run counter to society's interest. Societal dilemmas have many names in the literature: collective action problem, Tragedy of the Commons, free-rider problem, arms race. We'll use them all. Part II fully develops my model. Trust is essential for society to function, and societal
…
analysis, they'll end up collapsing the fishing stocks and ruining the industry for everyone. This is called a Tragedy of the Commons, and was first described by the ecologist Garrett Hardin in 1968.6 A Tragedy of the Commons occurs whenever a group shares a limited resource: not just fisheries, but grazing lands, water rights, time on
…
the trade-off for himself, but when an unorganized group together owns the forest there's no one to limit the harvest, and a Tragedy of the Commons can result. A Tragedy of the Commons is more complicated than a two-person Prisoner's Dilemma, because the other fishers aren't making this decision collectively. Instead, each individual
…
or future fishing stocks. But at some point, either the waters will get crowded enough or the fishers will get technologically advanced enough that the Tragedy of the Commons dilemma will occur. The disconnect between Alice's individual actions and the effect of the group's actions as a whole makes societal dilemmas even
…
or defection won't change that. All she's really deciding is whether to seize or forgo the short-term benefits of defecting. Societal Dilemma: Tragedy of the Commons. Society: Some group of people, either a society of interest or a society of circumstance. Group interest: That the common resource not run out, and
…
. Group norm: Cooperate and share that resource within its sustainability limits.. Corresponding defection: Take as much of that shared resource as you can. In a Tragedy of the Commons, people acting in their self-interest harm the group interest. There's another type of societal dilemma, where people can receive the benefit of those
…
two prisoners, or the merchant and customer, can't trust each other, they both end up defecting. The larger societal dilemmas—the arms race, the Tragedy of the Commons, and the free-rider problem—are similarly unsolvable. Defecting is the only course that makes logical sense, even though the end result will be disastrous
…
. However, once the group size grows larger and the social ties between people weaken, reputation alone doesn't cut it. Commenting on Hardin's original Tragedy of the Commons paper, psychologist Julian Edney wrote that “the upper limit for a simple, self-contained, sustaining, well-functioning commons may be as low as 150 people
…
big step for the development of society, and it allowed larger and more complex social groupings—like cities. Garrett Hardin, who created the phrase “the Tragedy of the Commons,” later wished he'd called it “the tragedy of the unmanaged commons.” The point of his paper was not that defectors will inevitably ruin things
…
glass eels—immature eels that are a delicacy in Japan and Europe—started rising, more people began to fish for them. The result was a Tragedy of the Commons: illegal overfishing and poaching in England, France, and the northeastern U.S. resulted in reduced yields, which resulted in higher prices. This resulted in even
…
psychologist to ever win a Nobel Prize, and he won it in economics. (7) Many of the criticisms of Hardin's original paper on the Tragedy of the Commons pointed out that, in the real world,systems of regulation were commonly established by users of commons. (8) Douglas Hofstadter calls this “superrationality.” He assumes
…
Commons,” Nature, 340:91–3. David Feeny, Fikret Berkes, Bonnie J. McCay, and James M. Acheson (1990), “The Tragedy of the Commons: Twenty-Two Years Later,” Human Ecology, 18:1–19. Carl J. Dahlman (1992), “The Tragedy of the Commons that Wasn't: On Technical Solutions to the Institutions Game,” Population & Environment, 12:285–96. Elinor Ostrom, Joanna
…
(1981), “The Evolution of Cooperation,” Science, 211:1390–6. Robert Axelrod (1984), The Evolution of Cooperation, Basic Books. open grazing pasture Garrett Hardin (1968), “The Tragedy of the Commons,” Science, 162:1243–8. Chapter 6 predictably irrational Dan Ariely (2008), Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape our Decisions, Harper Perennial. Cuban Missile Crisis
by Jared Diamond · 2 Jan 2008 · 801pp · 242,104 words
levels between years or decades; that it’s difficult to get people to agree on exercising restraint in harvesting a shared resource (the so-called tragedy of the commons, to be discussed in later chapters); and that the complexity of ecosystems often makes the consequences of some human-caused perturbation virtually impossible to predict
…
to the extent that government regulations, laws, and public attitudes permit. One particular form of clashes of interest has become well known under the name “tragedy of the commons,” in turn closely related to the conflicts termed “the prisoner’s dilemma” and “the logic of collective action.” Consider a situation in which many consumers
…
, and the individual owners may find it even harder than a government’s coast guard or police to exclude intruders. The remaining solution to the tragedy of the commons is for the consumers to recognize their common interests and to design, obey, and enforce prudent harvesting quotas themselves. That is likely to happen only
…
and Pacific Oceans, peak catches were attained in the year 1989 and have declined since then. The main reasons behind all these failures are the tragedy of the commons, discussed in the preceding chapter, which makes it difficult for consumers exploiting a shared renewable resource to reach agreement despite their shared interest in doing
…
. If wild fish stocks were managed appropriately, the stock levels could be maintained, and they could be harvested perpetually. Unfortunately, the problem known as the tragedy of the commons (Chapter 14) has regularly undone efforts to manage fisheries sustainably, and the great majority of valuable fisheries already either have collapsed or are in steep
…
irrigation in recent times, did reach agreement to subordinate their individual rights to group interests. They thereby succeeded in managing shared resources and avoiding the tragedy of the commons that has befallen so many other groups. The government of China restricted the traditional freedom of individual reproductive choice, rather than let population problems spiral
…
that of McGovern et al., whose model should be consulted by anyone interested in pursuing this puzzle. Elinor Ostrom and her colleagues have studied the tragedy of the commons (alias common-pool resources), using both comparative surveys and experimental games to identify the conditions under which consumers are most likely to recognize their common
…
, the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962, and America’s adoption of the Marshall Plan in 1947. Garrett Hardin’s classic and often-cited article “The tragedy of the commons” appeared in Science 162:1243-1248 (1968). Mancur Olson applies the metaphor of stationary bandits and roving bandits to Chinese warlords and other extractive agents
…
, Allen Bolle Report (1970) borax mining Borneo, illegal logging in Bosch, Juan bottom-up environmental management Australia Inuits New Guinea Southwestern U.S. Tikopia and tragedy of the commons Bougainville copper mine BP (British Petroleum) Buffalo Creek, West Virginia Burundi: genocide in independence of business, see big business Cahokia, collapse of Canada: Franklin Expedition
…
of and marine habitats and Marine Stewardship Council and mining in Montana and non-native species overfishing perverse subsidies in protein provided in sustainable and tragedy of the commons by trawling and water quality and whirling disease Flenley, John Florida, native species of Food and Drug Administration (FDA) food distribution food taboos Ford, Henry
…
analogies in irrational behavior in landscape amnesia in logic of collective action psychological denial in rational behavior in short-term focus in success in in tragedy of the commons unsuccessful solutions in groupthink Haakonsson, King Haakon of Norway habitat destruction Habyarimana, General Haiti: agriculture of border of Dominican Republic and cooperation between Dominican Republic
…
collapse Tokugawa era, see Japan Tonga top-down environmental management China Dominican Republic Inca Empire Tokugawa-era Japan and tragedy of the commons Totman, Conrad toxic chemicals toxic wastes, in mining industry trade, friendly partners in tragedy of the commons tree ring studies (dendrochronology) trouble spots (map) Trout Unlimited Trujillo, Rafael Tuamotu Archipelago Tuchman, Barbara turf cutting Tutsi
by Shawn Lawrence Otto · 10 Oct 2011 · 692pp · 127,032 words
freedom relate to regulation and the commons—the common property of humankind. These questions are central to the relationship between science and democracy itself. THE TRAGEDY OF THE COMMONS In December of 1968, a little-known University of California Santa Barbara biologist named Garrett Hardin published a paper in Science that would change the
…
way we look at economics. The core dilemma it identified, which came to be called “the tragedy of the commons” after the paper’s title, lies at the heart of the unresolved environmental challenges of the twentieth century, among them climate change, ocean acidification, overfishing
…
that believes in the freedom of the commons. Freedom in a commons brings ruin to all.” FREEDOM VERSUS TYRANNY The simple dilemma that drives the tragedy of the commons is writ large in the greatest political argument of our time: the clash between individualism and collectivism. In the political realm this first became a
…
a limited planet, today’s herdsmen—nation-states, supranational corporations, and individuals—all have powerful economic incentives to pursue their rational self-interests until the tragedy of the commons occurs on a global scale. This is the nature of a boom or a bubble, but the assumption of limitless growth is what our economic
…
affords the opportunity through regulation to govern the engine before it races to ruin. Understanding this relationship, teasing out the logical fallacy that underlies the tragedy of the commons, ties into the fundamental relationship between economics, democracy, and knowledge gained from science. Finding ways to create more freedom and more wealth that allow for
…
, it does provide some useful ways for thinking about the interplay between wealth and the environment. What makes it interesting is that it turns the tragedy of the commons on its head, functioning in reverse. Like science, wealth affords freedom by expanding the power of choice. Insurance is a commons, a shared pasture, if
…
the United States for exercising leadership and providing that fair and equitable regulation, that sheriff, and freeing them from the Wild West tyranny of the tragedy of the commons. We don’t lack ability; we lack leadership. The assumption that other economies will not follow the United States’ lead is incorrect. Much of the
…
. Electronic Classics Series. Hazleton, PA: Pennsylvania State University, n.d. www2.hn.psu.edu/faculty/jmanis/adam-smith/Wealth-Nations.pdf. 3. Hardin, G. The Tragedy of the Commons. Science 1968;162(3859):1243–1248. www.sciencemag.org/content/162/3859/1243.full. 4. Rand, A. The Virtue of Selfishness. New York: Signet, 1964
…
. The Crime of Galileo: Indictment and Abjuration of 1633. Internet Modern History Sourcebook, January 1999. www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/1630galileo.html. Hardin, G. The Tragedy of the Commons. Science 1968;162(3859):1243–1248. www.sciencemag.org/content/162/3859/1243.full. Harman, O. Cyril Dean Darlington: The Man Who “Invented” the Chromosome
…
, 258, 265 opportunity cost and, 257 science and, 187, 255–56 SEEP challenges and, 187 self-interest and, 250, 260 sustainability and, environmental, 258, 261 tragedy of the commons and, 247–51, 268 tyranny on the commons and, 253–55 Ecosystem services, 258, 265 Ecosystem, value on, 259 Education Bloom’s view of, 127
…
, 245 Thimerosal, 152–53 Thompson, Mi ke, 19 Tocqueville, Alexis de, 57–59, 294, 315–16 Tolerance, 53, 59, 137–38 Tortolero, Susan, 275–76 Tragedy of the commons, 247–51, 268 “Transgressing the Boundaries” hoax, 129–31 Tree-ring density measurements, 199 Truth Conservatives and, 131 erosion of telling, 134 knowledge and, 49
by Juli Berwald · 4 Apr 2022 · 495pp · 114,451 words
University of California at Berkeley named Garrett Hardin gave a talk to the American Association for the Advancement of Science with the catchy title “The Tragedy of the Commons.” Drawing from an essay published a century earlier, in 1866, Hardin described a grassy pasture on which herders could happily graze their cows. This mind
…
calculation. The pasture became overgrazed and all the cows went hungry. Hardin concluded, “Freedom in the commons brings ruin to all.” The parable of the Tragedy of the Commons is obviously not just about some herders and a pasture, but about any shared resource and humanity’s apparent inability not to overexploit it. Trapping
…
, carbon dioxide. Everyone shares the cost of discharging wastes into the common space. It’s cheaper for individuals to pollute. When Hardin wrote about the Tragedy of the Commons, power plants were spewing sulfates and nitrates into the air, causing acid rain. Cancer-causing chemicals like DDT were being dumped into rivers and soils
…
to recognize CO2 in this same way, creating a legacy that will haunt our children. The future of the coral reefs requires reckoning with the Tragedy of the Commons. The major problems for coral—carbon dioxide pollution causing warming, fertilizer and sewage runoff causing disease, coastal development causing sedimentation, illegal fishing—all result from
…
focusing eastward toward the Atlantic still supported the paradigm that the sea’s resources were in a category all their own, not subject to the Tragedy of the Commons. But Hawaiian fisheries ecologist H. Scott Gordon, looking at the Pacific, proposed that the seas might have limits, writing that “the plight of fishermen and
…
.” * * * — After my conversation with Lizzie, I thought a lot about the implications of traditional marine tenure. If there were places that managed to skirt the Tragedy of the Commons through systems like sasi in Indonesia and no-take MPAs, what does that mean for the validity of Garrett Hardin’s idea? Is the
…
Tragedy of the Commons a fundamental truth of humankind, or is it flawed? Flawed, was the answer articulated in the 1980s by Elinor Ostrom, the first—and until 2019
…
. The competing demands of farmers, builders, and residents were draining it dry. Observing the water wars and pumping races gave Lin critical insight into the Tragedy of the Commons. Remember the herders grazing in Garrett Hardin’s field? Lin recognized that for Hardin’s logic to work, he had to impose unnatural rules on
…
the aisle seat with great conviction. The flight attendant looked at me helplessly. The travel fates had pitted me against someone with the Garrett Hardin Tragedy of the Commons philosophy. She’d gotten to the seat first, and so she took it. “Fine,” I said, collapsing into the aisle seat. I shot the woman
…
fifty-first reef? The philosophical conundrum posed by the 50 Reefs project isn’t new. In 1974, Garrett Hardin—that same thinker who coined the Tragedy of the Commons—published an essay titled “Living on a Lifeboat,” which frames “lifeboat ethics” like this: Suppose you are in a lifeboat that contains fifty people, although
…
reef. * * * — When Nobel Prize–winning economist Lin Ostrom looked around the world for examples of management plans that defied Garrett Hardin’s notion of the Tragedy of the Commons, she discovered that they all shared certain traits. Those that succeeded were not entirely private and also not entirely controlled by a central government. A
…
going to solve problems a lot quicker.” This kind of work of building connection is the ultimate flaw Lin Ostrom discovered in Garrett Hardin’s Tragedy of the Commons: By speaking to one another and working together, we can find ways to serve all our goals. Just as the coral and the algae have
…
, https://forceblueteam.org/news/100-yards-of-hope-team-outplants-1100-corals/. GO TO NOTE REFERENCE IN TEXT Chapter 16. The Tragedy of Scale “The Tragedy of the Commons”: Originally given as an address to the Pacific Division of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, then republished as Garrett Hardin, “The
…
Tragedy of the Commons,” Science 162, no. 3859 (1968): 1243–48, https://science.sciencemag.org/content/162/3859/1243.full. GO TO NOTE REFERENCE IN TEXT California’s sardines:
…
pandemic, 262 methane compared with, 247 Montreal Protocol on, 300n9 and ocean acidification, 50–53 and Paris Climate Accords, 288, 322n284 reduction efforts, 14 and Tragedy of the Commons model, 116 Caribbean and coral bleaching, 62, 64, 65 and evolution of corals, 93–94 reef damage in, 5–6, 94, 218–19 and tourism
…
protection value, 7, 103–4, 228, 241 and land restoration model, 185 total value estimates, 7 tourism value, 181–86, 203–4, 238, 313n141 and Tragedy of the Commons model, 115–17, 120, 230, 243 See also aquarium trade El Niño events, 19, 63–64, 65, 70, 117 Elbow Reef, 190 Eldridge, Alice, 146
…
benefits of reefs, 7, 11, 184, 285 and marine protected areas, 118–21 and Pacific island traditional practices, 117–18 sustainability practices, 182–83 and Tragedy of the Commons model, 115–17, 120, 230, 243 and Waterkeeper Alliance, 99–100 See also bleaching of corals; climate change and global warming Erdmann, Mark, 139 erosion
…
efforts, 289 impact of coral harvests, 162 international enforcement efforts, 288 and Red List fish species, 182 and sasi system, 117–18, 120, 140 and Tragedy of the Commons model, 120–21 and Tuna Blueprint study, 134–35 and Vibrant Oceans Initiative, 231 flood protection from coral reefs, 7, 11, 104, 126, 171, 218
…
, 87, 182, 225 and satellite imagery, 233 and scope of threats to corals, 7, 15, 26, 162, 187, 289 and social justice issues, 267 and Tragedy of the Commons model, 115–17 and Waterkeeper Alliance, 99–100 polycentric governance, 243 polyps, 37 Popular Science, 223 Porites coral, 143 Port of Miami, 99–100 poverty
…
Tonga, 162 Tortugas Laboratory, 55–56, 59 tourism, 85–86, 181–86, 203–4, 238, 313n141 toxins, 37, 160–61 Traditional Owners, 261–62, 272 Tragedy of the Commons, 115–17, 120, 230, 243 transatlantic flight, 13 Tres Palmas Marine Reserve, 190 Tropical Forest Conservation Act, 237–38 Trujillo, Rafael, 203 Trump, Donald, 290
by Howard Rheingold · 24 Dec 2011
by Mehrsa Baradaran · 7 May 2024 · 470pp · 158,007 words
by Andy Oram · 26 Feb 2001 · 673pp · 164,804 words
by Paul A. Offit M.D. · 28 Dec 2010 · 377pp · 89,000 words
by Jared Diamond · 25 Apr 2011 · 753pp · 233,306 words
by Clay Shirky · 28 Feb 2008 · 313pp · 95,077 words
by Peter Barnes · 29 Sep 2006 · 207pp · 52,716 words
by David Brin · 1 Jan 1998 · 205pp · 18,208 words
by Deirdre N. McCloskey · 15 Nov 2011 · 1,205pp · 308,891 words
by Jeremy Rifkin · 31 Mar 2014 · 565pp · 151,129 words
by Jeremy Rifkin · 31 Dec 2009 · 879pp · 233,093 words
by Richard Davies · 4 Sep 2019 · 412pp · 128,042 words
by Rutger Bregman · 1 Jun 2020 · 578pp · 131,346 words
by David Easley and Jon Kleinberg · 15 Nov 2010 · 1,535pp · 337,071 words
by Lamorna Ash · 1 Apr 2020 · 319pp · 108,797 words
by Toby Ord · 24 Mar 2020 · 513pp · 152,381 words
by Dan Ariely · 3 Apr 2013 · 898pp · 266,274 words
by Kate Raworth · 22 Mar 2017 · 403pp · 111,119 words
by Guy Standing · 13 Jul 2016 · 443pp · 98,113 words
by Robert M. Sapolsky · 1 May 2017 · 1,261pp · 294,715 words
by Francis Fukuyama · 11 Apr 2011 · 740pp · 217,139 words
by Tim Jackson · 8 Dec 2016 · 573pp · 115,489 words
by Söderberg, Johan; Söderberg, Johan;
by Ian Urbina · 19 Aug 2019
by Robert A. Sirico · 20 May 2012 · 267pp · 70,250 words
by Meredith. Angwin · 18 Oct 2020 · 376pp · 101,759 words
by Jeffrey Sachs · 1 Jan 2008 · 421pp · 125,417 words
by Stuart Russell and Peter Norvig · 14 Jul 2019 · 2,466pp · 668,761 words
by Duncan J. Watts · 1 Feb 2003 · 379pp · 113,656 words
by Matt Ridley · 17 May 2010 · 462pp · 150,129 words
by Robert H. Frank · 3 Sep 2011
by Jaron Lanier · 6 May 2013 · 510pp · 120,048 words
by Linda McQuaig · 30 Aug 2019 · 263pp · 79,016 words
by Michael A. Heller and James Salzman · 2 Mar 2021 · 332pp · 100,245 words
by Otto Scharmer and Katrin Kaufer · 14 Apr 2013 · 351pp · 93,982 words
by Chris Smaje · 14 Aug 2020 · 375pp · 105,586 words
by Diane Coyle · 14 Jan 2020 · 384pp · 108,414 words
by Andreas M. Antonopoulos · 28 Aug 2016 · 200pp · 47,378 words
by Richard Rhodes · 28 May 2018 · 653pp · 155,847 words
by Dieter Helm · 7 Mar 2019 · 348pp · 102,438 words
by Azeem Azhar · 6 Sep 2021 · 447pp · 111,991 words
by Cass R. Sunstein · 6 Mar 2018 · 434pp · 117,327 words
by Richard E. Nisbett · 17 Aug 2015 · 397pp · 109,631 words
by Alice Schroeder · 1 Sep 2008 · 1,336pp · 415,037 words
by Meadows. Donella and Diana Wright · 3 Dec 2008 · 243pp · 66,908 words
by Richard Susskind and Daniel Susskind · 24 Aug 2015 · 742pp · 137,937 words
by Fred Pearce · 28 May 2012 · 379pp · 114,807 words
by Rachel Botsman and Roo Rogers · 2 Jan 2010 · 411pp · 80,925 words
by Simon Fairlie · 14 Jun 2010 · 614pp · 176,458 words
by Paul Vigna and Michael J. Casey · 27 Feb 2018 · 348pp · 97,277 words
by Michele Boldrin and David K. Levine · 6 Jul 2008 · 607pp · 133,452 words
by Gabriel Weinberg and Lauren McCann · 17 Jun 2019
by Elinor Ostrom · 29 Nov 1990
by Sonia Shah
by Derek S. Hoff · 30 May 2012
by Ian Goldin and Mike Mariathasan · 15 Mar 2014 · 414pp · 101,285 words
by Stuart Russell · 7 Oct 2019 · 416pp · 112,268 words
by Simon Winchester · 19 Jan 2021 · 486pp · 139,713 words
by Marc J Dunkelman · 17 Feb 2025 · 454pp · 134,799 words
by Greta Thunberg · 14 Feb 2023 · 651pp · 162,060 words
by Mark Lynas · 1 Apr 2008 · 364pp · 101,193 words
by Charles Leadbeater · 9 Dec 2010 · 313pp · 84,312 words
by Alex Prud'Homme · 6 Jun 2011 · 692pp · 167,950 words
by Paul Collier · 10 May 2010 · 288pp · 76,343 words
by Kim Stanley Robinson · 5 Oct 2020 · 583pp · 182,990 words
by Nandan Nilekani · 25 Nov 2008 · 777pp · 186,993 words
by Vijay Joshi · 21 Feb 2017
by Brian Christian and Tom Griffiths · 4 Apr 2016 · 523pp · 143,139 words
by Rana Foroohar · 16 May 2016 · 515pp · 132,295 words
by Jeremy Lent · 22 May 2017 · 789pp · 207,744 words
by Joe Quirk and Patri Friedman · 21 Mar 2017 · 441pp · 113,244 words
by Daniel C. Dennett · 15 Jan 1995 · 846pp · 232,630 words
by Michael Shellenberger · 28 Jun 2020
by Tom Vanderbilt · 28 Jul 2008 · 512pp · 165,704 words
by Jonathan Aldred · 5 Jun 2019 · 453pp · 111,010 words
by Charles de Ganahl Koch · 14 Sep 2015 · 261pp · 74,471 words
by Aaron Dignan · 1 Feb 2019 · 309pp · 81,975 words
by Shane Parrish · 22 Nov 2019 · 147pp · 39,910 words
by Brett Christophers · 6 Nov 2018
by Matt Ridley · 14 Aug 1993 · 474pp · 136,787 words
by Jeanna Smialek · 27 Feb 2023 · 601pp · 135,202 words
by Leigh Phillips and Michal Rozworski · 5 Mar 2019 · 202pp · 62,901 words
by David A. Sinclair and Matthew D. Laplante · 9 Sep 2019
by Jonathan Rauch · 21 Jun 2021 · 446pp · 109,157 words
by Astra Taylor · 4 Mar 2014 · 283pp · 85,824 words
by Parag Khanna · 18 Apr 2016 · 497pp · 144,283 words
by Robin Chase · 14 May 2015 · 330pp · 91,805 words
by Mark Lynas · 3 Oct 2011 · 369pp · 98,776 words
by Nadia Eghbal · 3 Aug 2020 · 1,136pp · 73,489 words
by Daniel Crosby · 15 Feb 2018 · 249pp · 77,342 words
by Duff McDonald · 24 Apr 2017 · 827pp · 239,762 words
by David Harvey · 3 Apr 2012 · 206pp · 9,776 words
by Noam Chomsky
by William R. Easterly · 1 Aug 2002 · 355pp · 63 words
by Eric Posner and E. Weyl · 14 May 2018 · 463pp · 105,197 words
by Ronald Bailey · 20 Jul 2015 · 417pp · 109,367 words
by Robert H. Frank, Philip J. Cook · 2 May 2011
by Douglas Rushkoff · 1 Mar 2016 · 366pp · 94,209 words
by Melanie Mitchell · 31 Mar 2009 · 524pp · 120,182 words
by Mark Casson · 14 Jul 2009 · 556pp · 46,885 words
by Unknown · 20 Sep 2008 · 246pp · 116 words
by Donovan Hohn · 1 Jan 2010 · 473pp · 154,182 words
by Guy Shrubsole · 1 May 2019 · 505pp · 133,661 words
by Andrew McAfee · 30 Sep 2019 · 372pp · 94,153 words
by David McRaney · 20 Sep 2011 · 270pp · 83,506 words
by Malcolm Harris · 14 Feb 2023 · 864pp · 272,918 words
by Kelly Weinersmith and Zach Weinersmith · 6 Nov 2023 · 490pp · 132,502 words
by Justin E. H. Smith · 22 Mar 2022 · 198pp · 59,351 words
by Robert H. Frank · 15 Jan 1999 · 416pp · 112,159 words
by Rupert Darwall · 2 Oct 2017 · 451pp · 115,720 words
by Angus Deaton · 15 Mar 2013 · 374pp · 114,660 words
by Donella H. Meadows, Jørgen Randers and Dennis L. Meadows · 15 Apr 2004 · 357pp · 100,718 words
by Jamie Bartlett · 12 Jun 2017 · 390pp · 109,870 words
by Steve Stewart-Williams · 12 Sep 2018 · 1,132pp · 156,379 words
by Eula Biss · 15 Jan 2020 · 199pp · 61,648 words
by Cal Newport · 2 Mar 2021 · 350pp · 90,898 words
by George Marshall · 18 Aug 2014 · 298pp · 85,386 words
by Nicholas Carr · 28 Jan 2025 · 231pp · 85,135 words
by Joanna Walsh · 22 Sep 2025 · 255pp · 80,203 words
by Phil Lapsley · 5 Feb 2013 · 744pp · 142,748 words
by Joseph E. Stiglitz · 10 Jun 2012 · 580pp · 168,476 words
by Pierre Desrochers and Hiroko Shimizu · 29 May 2012 · 329pp · 85,471 words
by John Cassidy · 10 Nov 2009 · 545pp · 137,789 words
by Stewart Brand · 1 Jan 1999 · 194pp · 49,310 words
by Mark Skousen · 22 Dec 2006 · 330pp · 77,729 words
by Richard H. Thaler and Cass R. Sunstein · 7 Apr 2008 · 304pp · 22,886 words
by Kelly McGonigal · 1 Dec 2011 · 354pp · 91,875 words
by Douglas Rushkoff · 21 Mar 2013 · 323pp · 95,939 words
by Matthew Carmona, Tim Heath, Steve Tiesdell and Taner Oc · 15 Feb 2010 · 1,233pp · 239,800 words
by Edward Slingerland · 31 May 2021
by Xiaowei Wang · 12 Oct 2020 · 196pp · 61,981 words
by Ed West · 19 Mar 2020 · 530pp · 147,851 words
by Mary L. Gray and Siddharth Suri · 6 May 2019 · 346pp · 97,330 words
by Nicklas Brendborg · 17 Jan 2023 · 222pp · 68,595 words
by Jonathan Zittrain · 27 May 2009 · 629pp · 142,393 words
by Maurice E. Stucke and Ariel Ezrachi · 14 May 2020 · 511pp · 132,682 words
by Stewart Brand · 15 Mar 2009 · 422pp · 113,525 words
by Alice Ross · 19 Nov 2020 · 197pp · 53,831 words
by Charles Eisenstein · 11 Jul 2011 · 448pp · 142,946 words
by Robert Wright · 1 Jan 1994 · 604pp · 161,455 words
by Yochai Benkler · 8 Aug 2011 · 187pp · 62,861 words
by Wolfgang Streeck · 1 Jan 2013 · 353pp · 81,436 words
by Julia Angwin · 25 Feb 2014 · 422pp · 104,457 words
by Peter D. Norton · 15 Jan 2008 · 409pp · 145,128 words
by Steven Drobny · 18 Mar 2010 · 537pp · 144,318 words
by Peter Gutmann
by Mckenzie Funk · 22 Jan 2014 · 337pp · 101,281 words
by Thomas W. Malone · 14 May 2018 · 344pp · 104,077 words
by Nicholas A. Christakis · 26 Mar 2019
by Robert Wright · 28 Dec 2010
by Jake Bittle · 21 Feb 2023 · 296pp · 118,126 words
by Sebastian Junger · 30 Sep 1999
by Brink Lindsey · 12 Oct 2017 · 288pp · 64,771 words
by Nassim Nicholas Taleb · 20 Feb 2018 · 306pp · 82,765 words
by John Lanchester · 5 Oct 2014 · 261pp · 86,905 words
by Laurence C. Smith · 22 Sep 2010 · 421pp · 120,332 words
by Steve Krug · 2 Jan 2000 · 170pp · 42,196 words
by Joseph E. Stiglitz · 16 Sep 2006
by Nicholas Shaxson · 10 Oct 2018 · 482pp · 149,351 words
by Richard Dawkins · 1 Jan 1982 · 506pp · 152,049 words
by Bill McKibben · 15 Apr 2019
by Nick Harkaway · 18 Oct 2017 · 778pp · 239,744 words
by Noam Chomsky
by Philip Coggan · 6 Feb 2020 · 524pp · 155,947 words
by Peter Singer and Jim Mason · 1 May 2006 · 400pp · 129,320 words
by Diane Coyle · 29 Oct 1998 · 49,604 words
by Michael Jacobs and Mariana Mazzucato · 31 Jul 2016 · 370pp · 102,823 words
by Nicholas Shaxson · 20 Mar 2007
by Elly Blue · 29 Nov 2014 · 221pp · 68,880 words
by Chris Anderson · 1 Oct 2012 · 238pp · 73,824 words
by Steve Krug · 1 Jan 2000 · 170pp · 45,121 words
by Steven D. Levitt and Stephen J. Dubner · 11 Apr 2005 · 339pp · 95,988 words
by Andrew Lih · 5 Jul 2010 · 398pp · 86,023 words
by Michal Zalewski · 26 Nov 2011 · 570pp · 115,722 words
by Scott E. Page · 27 Nov 2018 · 543pp · 153,550 words
by James E. Lovelock · 1 Jan 2009 · 239pp · 68,598 words
by Andrew Heintzman, Evan Solomon and Eric Schlosser · 2 Feb 2009 · 323pp · 89,795 words
by Howard Rheingold · 10 Mar 2020
by David Graeber and David Wengrow · 18 Oct 2021
by Charles Conn and Robert McLean · 6 Mar 2019
by Clay Shirky · 9 Jun 2010 · 236pp · 66,081 words
by Dr. Craig Malkin · 6 Jul 2015 · 259pp · 67,261 words
by Diane Coyle · 21 Feb 2011 · 523pp · 111,615 words
by Joel Spolsky · 25 Jun 2008 · 292pp · 81,699 words
by Steven Levy · 25 Feb 2020 · 706pp · 202,591 words
by Tim O'Reilly · 9 Oct 2017 · 561pp · 157,589 words
by Duncan J. Watts · 28 Mar 2011 · 327pp · 103,336 words
by Jane McGonigal · 20 Jan 2011 · 470pp · 128,328 words
by Katharina Pistor · 27 May 2019 · 316pp · 117,228 words
by Leslie Berlin · 9 Jun 2005
by Christian Wolmar · 19 May 2016 · 79pp · 24,875 words
by Robert Skidelsky · 3 Mar 2020 · 290pp · 76,216 words
by David Harvey · 2 Jan 1995 · 318pp · 85,824 words
by Brad Stone · 10 May 2021 · 569pp · 156,139 words
by David Hale and Lyric Hughes Hale · 23 May 2011 · 397pp · 112,034 words
by Kim Stanley Robinson · 23 Oct 1992 · 660pp · 213,945 words
by Kim Stanley Robinson · 23 Oct 1993 · 746pp · 239,969 words
by Dan Ariely · 27 Jun 2012 · 258pp · 73,109 words
by Martin Ford · 4 May 2015 · 484pp · 104,873 words
by Muhammad Yunus · 25 Sep 2017 · 278pp · 74,880 words
by Sally Adee · 27 Feb 2023 · 329pp · 101,233 words
by Edward O. Thorp · 15 Nov 2016 · 505pp · 142,118 words
by Kim Stanley Robinson · 22 May 2012 · 561pp · 167,631 words
by Leigh Gallagher · 26 Jun 2013 · 296pp · 76,284 words
by Juliet Schor, William Attwood-Charles and Mehmet Cansoy · 15 Mar 2020 · 296pp · 83,254 words
by John Walker
by Marshall Brain · 6 Apr 2015 · 215pp · 56,215 words
by Jonathan Taplin · 17 Apr 2017 · 222pp · 70,132 words
by Simon McCarthy-Jones · 12 Apr 2021
by Martin Kleppmann · 17 Apr 2017
by Jim Waldo · 193pp · 31,998 words
by Tom Chivers · 12 Jun 2019 · 289pp · 92,714 words
by Martin Kleppmann · 16 Mar 2017 · 1,237pp · 227,370 words
by Jacob Lund Fisker · 30 Sep 2010 · 346pp · 102,625 words
by Jamie Susskind · 3 Sep 2018 · 533pp
by Norbert Haring, Norbert H. Ring and Niall Douglas · 30 Sep 2012 · 261pp · 103,244 words
by Roger Scruton · 16 Nov 2017 · 190pp · 56,531 words
by Nassim Nicholas Taleb · 1 Jan 2001 · 111pp · 1 words
by Jeff Atwood · 3 Jul 2012 · 270pp · 64,235 words
by Carne Ross · 25 Apr 2007 · 212pp · 68,690 words
by William Poundstone · 5 Feb 2008
by Nick Bostrom · 3 Jun 2014 · 574pp · 164,509 words
by Jonathan Haidt · 13 Mar 2012 · 539pp · 139,378 words
by Dalton Conley · 27 Dec 2008 · 204pp · 67,922 words
by Nadia Eghbal · 139pp · 35,022 words
by David Pilling · 30 Jan 2018 · 264pp · 76,643 words
by Adrian Hon · 14 Sep 2022 · 371pp · 107,141 words
by Douglas Rushkoff · 7 Sep 2022 · 205pp · 61,903 words
by Michael Lewis · 2 Oct 2011 · 180pp · 61,340 words
by Lucas Chancel · 15 Jan 2020 · 191pp · 51,242 words
by Dan Conway · 8 Sep 2019 · 218pp · 68,648 words
by Scott Patterson · 11 Jun 2012 · 356pp · 105,533 words