description: false or misleading information that is spread deliberately to deceive and manipulate
581 results
by Thomas Rid
is, and what it is not. First, and most important, active measures are not spontaneous lies by politicians, but the methodical output of large bureaucracies. Disinformation was, and in many ways continues to be, the domain of intelligence agencies—professionally run, continually improved, and usually employed against foreign adversaries. Second,
…
all active measures contain an element of disinformation: content may be forged, sourcing doctored, the method of acquisition covert; influence agents and cutouts may pretend to be something they are not, and
…
foreign intelligence.19 On January 11, 1923, a remarkable institutional innovation saw the light of day:20 Artuzov created an office for dezinformatsiya, or disinformation.21 The sheer volume of deceptive material that passed through these intelligence channels was large enough to trigger bureaucratic innovation in Russian foreign intelligence. The
…
GPU reportedly coordinated with the Revolutionary Military Council, Russia’s highest military authority, to set up a special bureau to “prepare disinformation for Western military intelligence services.”22 The goal, according to a GPU participant, was “to deter military intervention by the Western powers.”23 The GPU
…
was shot by the Germans in 1943. The actions of the Trust, more than any other event in the 1920s, would shape the future of disinformation. It was spectacularly successful. Polish intelligence later declared that—“without exaggeration”—Operation Trust had inflicted “incalculable damage” on the Russian émigrés, undercutting their political
…
States who were lobbying hard against recognizing the Soviet Union. America’s highly visible, ideologically motivated opposition to Marxism was practically an open invitation for disinformation and forgery. With his statements against Amtorg, Woll was broadcasting the establishment’s readiness to be tricked. Then, on March 4, about six weeks
…
the opening of the GDR Party Congress.23 The political warfare planners at Berlin Operations Base were careful to manage expectations at CIA headquarters. The disinformation campaign that Marbach and his team were designing and implementing was counterintuitive, neither wide nor narrow, designed neither for mass influence nor targeting of
…
strange, threatening letters. Henriette Trémeaud, wife of the prefect of Strasbourg, circa 1957. She died in a terrorist attack that was designed to be a disinformation operation. (Photograph by Keystone-France / Gamma-Keystone via Getty Images) “French Oppressors!” one such leaflet was titled. The pamphlet was addressed to the authorities
…
that the Hauptverwaltung Aufklärung (HVA), the foreign intelligence branch of the Ministry of State Security—the Stasi—had already conducted active measures before 1957. But disinformation and “psychological warfare,” the defector said, had been officially announced within the HVA as a “major operational responsibility,” just as the cigar box bomb
…
weeks into his tenure. Department D pulled together various officers from different parts of the KGB’s vast First Chief Directorate to coordinate and direct disinformation operations. Shelepin’s most brilliant appointment was Ivan Ivanovich Agayants, a highly decorated career intelligence officer from Ganja (Gence) in Azerbaijan. Agayants was tall,
…
that sought to promote “division in the West.” Langley analysts pointed out that they observed “rather elaborate progressions in prolonged campaigns.”15 These anti-Western disinformation campaigns were aggressive, fast-paced, and used innovative methods that evolved quickly and in unexpected, frightening ways. One such measure exploited a military exercise known
…
for running espionage operations against the Christian Democrats in the Federal Republic. Heim, a Wehrmacht veteran, defected before the Stasi formed a specific unit for disinformation, but in his debriefings with West German security services, he was already able to detail what he called “intelligence work of corrosion,” or Zersetzungsarbeit.
…
, researchers, and specialists, usually not revealing their identity and purpose to these useful outsiders, although some were trusted agents. Not all were Russian. The disinformation division would commission these outside consultants, for a fee, to carry out research on issues of political, economic, historical, or cultural interest to the KGB
…
a detailed list of individual active measures, complete with specific objectives, targets, and assigned responsibilities, and are therefore an invaluable source for the historian of disinformation. Oral disinformation, as Ivanov outlined in his 1979 lecture, could be highly effective, even deadly, especially in developing countries. On November 20, 1979, a group of
…
had a deeper meaning. “After many years of practice and theoretical generalizations, the comrades from Service ‘A’ have brought some clarity to the concept of disinformation,” Ivanov explained, specifically on the “working methods that are widely used are exposing, compromising, and influencing governments, organizations, and individuals.” He cautioned against getting “
…
confidential ties, who will keep secret our involvement in these measures.” Ivanov explained that it was very important to understand the specific target of a disinformation operation. Diplomats were softer targets than intelligence officers, he said. “An intelligence officer will by default report data to the relevant agency, where serious
…
assessment. Service A had its own cipher clerks and two cipher machines to handle secure, encrypted communications, both outgoing and incoming, on disinformation in the making. The disinformation planners were supported by the KGB’s encryption service, which handed key material directly to Ivanov’s personal staff. Technology didn’t just
…
. New technologies created new forensic problems. Technology also created new targets. Not long after Ivanov’s presentation, his unit reportedly engaged in the first disinformation hack of a telecommunication system. In October 1981, a large Soviet nuclear-armed submarine ran aground near Sweden’s Karlskrona Naval Base, violating Swedish territorial
…
that AIDS conspiracy theories continued to fester at the far-left fringes of American civil rights activism, still, so far, without meaningful input from Soviet disinformation operators.18 American intelligence analysts, meanwhile, were investigating the reverse question: whether AIDS was a Soviet biological weapon. The CIA was aware that the
…
read and wrote, shared images and documents, socialized, consumed news, and spread rumors. The sprawling network, as became progressively clear, was practically optimized for disinformation, at least until the mid-2010s. Active measures operators two decades after Wagenbreth would frame his question differently: What would active measures be without the
…
culture of leaking when Schneier wrote these lines. The two-year period after the Snowden disclosures, in fact, was a short, modern golden age of disinformation. That period was characterized by the confluence of several developments that were, ultimately, all temporary afterglow effects of 1990s internet utopianism: the prevailing view,
…
agencies—both as a potential threat and as a potential cover for operations. CyberGuerrilla was a genuine Anonymous forum and preferred leak platform of Russian disinformation operators. (Internet Archive) “Anons,” as the activists called one another, ran social media accounts and blogs to foment unrest and advance the fight against
…
military personnel. Screenshots of the newly published cyb3rc site also appeared on Newsweek’s social media feed. CyberCaliphate bore all the hallmarks of a coordinated disinformation campaign: these actions were launched simultaneously, with consistent branding and language, and across various fronts and hacked social media sites, both publicly and as
…
forms of truth, of course, are exaggerations, ideals, clichés. This distinction is somewhat coarse and simplistic—nevertheless, it helps explain the logic of disinformation. The goal of disinformation is to engineer division by putting emotion over analysis, division over unity, conflict over consensus, the particular over the universal. For, after all,
…
—balloons launched, protesters counted, forgeries printed, packages mailed, letters received, press stories clipped, or downloads and shares and likes and page views logged. Some disinformers of old had long understood this problem: “I don’t think it’s possible to measure exactly, realistically, the impact of an active measure,” Bittman
…
in short, created a powerful illusion, an appealing mirage—the metrics created an opportunity for more, and more convincing, disinformation about disinformation. For willfully exaggerating the effects of disinformation means exaggerating the impact of disinformation. All this is bad news for future historians. Seminars, in-person discussions, and correspondence were always fleeting and rarely
…
transitioned into the SVR. The sweeping official history of Russian foreign intelligence acknowledges that over the past century the designations of the same operational activity—disinformation—came and went, from “operational games” to “active measures” to the blander, more recent “support measures.”13 Then came the rise of the internet,
…
leaked, compromising material of questionable provenance, and as publishers recycled unoriginal, repetitive content. The end effect was that a significant and large portion of the disinformation value-creation chain was outsourced to the victim society itself, to journalists, to activists, to freelance conspiracy theorists, and, to a lesser degree, to
…
by an unprecedented confluence of incentives that lead many victims—politicians, journalists, technologists, intelligence analysts, adversary operators, and most researchers—to highlight the potentials of disinformation over its limitations. Perhaps the most vivid illustration of this trend is the fantastic story of the Shadow Brokers—the devastating NSA leak with its
…
pp. 283–84. The other book was a Stasi memoir available only in German, Auftrag Irreführung, more on which below. 2. Lawrence (Ladislav) Bittman, former disinformation officer, state security, Prague, interview with Thomas Rid, March 25, 2017, Rockport, MA; audio at https://archive.org/details/bittman-ridt. See Richard Sandomir, “
…
33, 2014. 6. Less aggressive because the CIA mainly supported existing organizations and publications through covert funding, not by designing and delivering divisive and deceptive disinformation; see Hugh Wilford, The Mighty Wurlitzer: How the CIA Played America (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2008); see also Michael Warner’s review in
…
, 1930, p. 4. 28. Spivak, A Man in His Time, p. 164. 29. “Three Offer Proof Whalen Red Papers Were Forged Here.” 4. American Disinformation 1. George Kennan, “The Inauguration of Political Warfare,” Draft, April, 30, 1948, NARA release, https://web.archive.org/web/20150123010608/http://digitalarchive.wilsoncenter.org/document
…
Максимович Примаков, Очерки истории российской внешней разведки, Том 5, 1945–1965 годы (Москва: Международные отношения, 1997), p. 13. 2. Ladislav Bittman, The KGB and Soviet Disinformation: An Insider’s View (Washington, DC: Pergamon-Brassey’s, 1985), p. 39. 3. CIA, “The Soviet and Communist Bloc Defamation Campaign,” CIA-RDP67B00446R000500070009-1,
…
Times, June 28, 1978, p. BR4. 2. The sourcing on the Tupamaros’ motivation is not satisfactory, hence “reportedly.” See Fletcher Schoen and Christopher Lamb, “Deception, Disinformation, and Strategic Communications: How One Interagency Group Made a Major Difference,” Strategic Perspectives 11 (Washington, DC: National Defense University, 2012), p. 33. 3. Anna Mudry
…
Its Secrets,” Associated Press, August 23, 2016. 48. WikiSaudiLeaks, July 20, 2015, https://web.archive.org/web/20150810005744/http://www.wikisaleaks.com/. 49. Thomas Rid, “Disinformation: A Primer in Russian Active Measures and Influence Campaigns,” Testimony, United States Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, Washington, DC, March 30, 2017. 50. The leak
…
the reference by an obscure account, @LexingtonAl, archived at https://web.archive.org/web/20190923140434/https:/twitter.com/Mao_Ware/status/1097891011202875392. A Century of Disinformation 1. The full name is Bundesbehörde für die Unterlagen des Staatssicherheitsdienstes der ehemaligen Deutschen Demokratischen Republik. 2. Jens Gieseke, Die Stasi (Munich: Pantheon, 2011),
…
; recognizing; Service A and; skill set for; Soviet budget for; Stasi’s history with; as support measures; the Trust’s success inspiring; see also disinformation Active Measures of Eastern Intelligence Services report activism; see also Anonymous; peacewar Adenauer, Konrad “Adventures of Mr. Hudson in Russia” Adzhubei, Alexei AEDEPOT Afghanistan AFL
…
and; Schneier on; of Shadow Brokers; Snowden and; Ukraine and Russian-orchestrated; WikiLeaks and; see also Anonymous; hacking operations Dirección General de Inteligencia (DGI) disinformation: accurate information in; Artuzov and; Bittman on; Black Lives Matter movement and; data and; East and West divide on; election interference of 2016 and; emotion
…
Mark Hauptverwaltung Aufklärung (HVA); Active Measures of Eastern Intelligence Services report and; Arbeitskreis and; archival records of; DENVER operation and; Devil and His Dart and; disinformation focus of; effectiveness of; Fleissmann and; Generals for Peace and; Headquarters Germany and; Helms’s accusations against; Kampfverband für Unabhängiges Deutschland and; Die Neue Nachhut
…
All-German Affairs) Kalugin, Oleg Kämpfer, Der Kampfgruppe gegen Unmenschlichkeit (KgU); administrative harassment and; balloon distribution of; brochures of; CIA and; closure of; courage of; disinformation and; election interference of; Ford Foundation funding; forgery of; founding of; goals of; graffiti campaign of; hardware sabotage operations of; Hildebrandt’s removal from; operating
…
Agency nuclear disarmament nuclear war threats; see also neutron bomb Nuclear Weapons Freeze Campaign nuclear winter: Alexandrov and; CIA on; KGB and; scenarios of; self-disinformation and; TTAPS project and Nuland, Victoria O Obama, Barack Office of Strategic Services OGPU (Joint State Political Directorate) Olympic Games Operation GRAVEYARD Operations Plan (OPLAN
…
to; Johnson, R. L., leaking; nuclear war and; publication of; STORM operation and; target list of; Wendland’s suicide and Opperput, Edward #OpSaudi oral disinformation Organization Gehlen Orme, Stan Orwell, George Osborn, K. Barton O’Shaughnessy, Elim Ovchinnikov, Leonid P Paese Sera Pahl-Rugenstein Pakistan Panama Papers Pan-Pacific Worker
by Anu Bradford · 25 Sep 2023 · 898pp · 236,779 words
, it has also been a channel for exposing vast segments of society to different forms of harmful content. Internet sites often serve as platforms for disinformation, bullying, hatred, and repulsive content, undermining the safety and dignity of individuals while dividing societies and destabilizing democracies. Algorithms designed to tailor online content
…
other critics of the market-driven regulatory model can also point out how Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and other platforms have repeatedly failed to remove dangerous disinformation on topics ranging from the COVID-19 pandemic to democratic elections. And they can replay the images of the January 6, 2021, insurrection at
…
the US Capitol, which originated in a rampant social media–fueled disinformation campaign about a stolen election.31 Consequently, when looking strictly at innovation and economic growth, the American market-driven model can be praised for its
…
companies are navigating the Russian invasion of Ukraine, facing conflicting demands from Ukraine, Russia, the EU, and the US on how to handle the disinformation and propaganda on their platforms that are shaping the narrative about the war.63 US tech companies operating in China face a particularly difficult balancing
…
incident where Frances Haugen, a former Facebook product manager, leaked documents to Congress that raised questions about the company’s handling of hate speech and disinformation.137 These tech companies have advanced in their defense various narratives when lobbying Congress. For example, in 2022, they argued that more robust antitrust
…
of an unregulated marketplace. It is also increasingly doubtful whether the market-driven model is delivering on its promise to enhance democracy as hatred and disinformation are often replacing the civic debates that were supposed to thrive online. Instead of nurturing inclusive democracy, online engagement has often increased societal polarization.
…
engagement means more advertising revenue, giving the platforms the incentive to amplify it. The digital public space is also increasingly compromised by rampant disinformation, in particular as disinformation gets disseminated more than truth online. A 2018 study examining news stories that were shared in Twitter from 2006 to 2017 reveals how
…
electoral process. There is no more vivid illustration of this than the January 6 insurrection at the US Capitol following a rampant social media–fueled disinformation campaign about a stolen election. The unregulated digital economy is also rife with privacy scandals. This is exactly what happened in the infamous Cambridge
…
cyber operations. For example, the US government does not control social media and news outlets, making it easier for adversaries to infiltrate those outlets with disinformation operations. Such operations can be deployed to manipulate elections or otherwise undermine democratic institutions—as happened, for example, in 2016 when Russian hackers stole emails
…
of the European regulatory model. The EU has also developed regulatory instruments to preserve and strengthen democracy in the digital age, including by curtailing online disinformation and promoting a free and pluralistic media. The EU has further woven a commitment to fairness and redistribution into its regulatory model, as exemplified
…
freedom of expression is under threat when the platforms are permitted to moderate content. Yet the absence of such moderation practices would allow hate speech, disinformation, terrorist propaganda, and other harmful content to run rampant online. The line-drawing between permissible and impermissible speech is therefore complicated, and the key
…
a myriad of ways for technology to undermine democracy. Online communication channels have not only cultivated civic engagement; they have also facilitated the spread of disinformation, undermining public debate and the legitimacy of democratic elections.76 Apart from producing freedom and enhancing democracy, online platforms have also sowed discord and deepened
…
its belief in the role of regulation to preserve democratic processes, the EU has adopted a number of regulatory instruments, including measures aimed at countering disinformation and strengthening free and pluralistic media, both of which the EU sees as crucial for sustaining democratic discourse. Through these efforts, the EU is
…
elevating the preservation and strengthening of democracy as a central tenet of its rights-driven regulatory model. Fighting Disinformation and Other Harmful Content Online The European rights-driven regulatory agenda is anchored in the conviction that protecting citizens’ ability to express themselves freely online
…
is steadfast in its commitment to limit the dissemination of such information online. However, crafting a rights-preserving regulatory approach toward the removal of disinformation is complicated given the EU’s equally steadfast commitment to the freedom of expression online. The EU recognizes that freedom of expression is a fundamental
…
information sources and educating them to more critically evaluate the information they encounter online. As part of its regulatory efforts, the Commission developed a nonbinding Disinformation Code, which, in its updated 2022 version, has been signed by leading platforms including Google, Meta, Microsoft, TikTok, and Twitter.83 These companies voluntarily
…
decisions.”98 The plan also holds that “by providing the public with reliable information, independent media play an important role in the fight against disinformation and the manipulation of democratic debate.”99 This view provides a policy rationale for the EU to leverage regulation with the goal of enhancing the
…
EU has been too lenient in tolerating harmful content online. While such regulation has led tech companies to take down considerable amounts of hate speech, disinformation, and terrorist content in the name of dignity, safety, and democracy, this kind of speech remains rampant online. Major platforms such as Facebook, YouTube,
…
with content that is harmful, dangerous, and often illegal. Few can dispute that these platforms have become go-to destinations for the spread of disinformation and the manipulation of public opinion on critical issues ranging from global pandemics to vaccines, and from migration to democratic elections. The role of social
…
content moderation. Europeans remain concerned about the ways US tech companies are shaping the European public discourse, often for worse, by allowing hate speech and disinformation to run rampant on their platforms. As a result, the EU has adopted regulations aimed at restricting illegal and harmful content online. In response,
…
social media.126 Instead of censoring conservative views, the right-wing media in the US often features conservative propaganda, cultivates conspiracy theories, and disseminates disinformation in the news media.127 This suggests that US news outlets have engaged in the kind of propaganda that the US government’s internet freedom
…
agenda for years sought to tackle abroad. The online disinformation surrounding the stolen 2020 presidential election—propagated most prominently by President Trump himself—provides perhaps the starkest evidence of how the US government has leveraged
…
his 2021 remarks, Secretary of State Anthony Blinken stressed how the US was working to ensure that “the technology works for democracy, fighting back against disinformation, standing up for internet freedom, reducing the misuse of surveillance technology.”129 In April 2022, President Biden announced the establishment of the Bureau of
…
the Tanzanian human rights organization Fichua Tanzania and its founder.160 However, these deactivations catch only a fraction of the accounts that are deployed for disinformation or government propaganda. For example, Twitter reportedly deactivated only 11 percent of over 3,500 total accounts spreading pro-government propaganda worldwide.161 US platforms
…
cultural power, sparking significant concern among political leaders as these platforms continued to abuse their market power, infringe on user privacy, and circulate hate speech, disinformation, and other harmful content. In response, a countermovement to rein in these companies emerged, and foreign governments began to engage in efforts to repeal the
…
not simply produce freedom as the early American techno-optimist view had predicted—they also cultivated an online public square littered with hatred, violence, and disinformation. Societal harms associated with free speech online, as illustrated by many of the examples cited earlier in this chapter, cast doubt on the idea
…
has been, or is becoming, pertinent. The discussion reveals how the EU’s antitrust rules and content regulations, including norms covering online hate speech and disinformation, can similarly be externalized through the Brussels Effect, and how artificial intelligence (AI) is likely to be the next frontier of the EU’s
…
-driven model for inspiration in regulating their digital economies. Content Moderation The EU’s regulation of online content through its codes on hate speech and disinformation, discussed earlier in Chapter 3, is shaping the global policies of tech companies such as Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube. When it comes to hate
…
where online content poses an “imminent and serious threat” to democratic, political, and policymaking processes, or public goods,117 whereas the EU Code bans disinformation, which “may cause public harm.”118 In explaining the departure from the EU standard, the ACCC noted that a lower threshold might be appropriate in
…
the EU, “in which multiple countries have already experienced harms including social media interference, and campaigns of disinformation and malinformation from external countries seeking to affect domestic political processes.”119 The Australian Communication and Media Authority will oversee the implementation of the Code
…
is also rethinking the US model’s traditionally inviolable commitment to free speech. Internet users are growing more concerned about harmful content online, including rife disinformation, terrorist propaganda, and foreign interference with elections. In recent years, the public has also become vehemently opposed to the misogyny and racism running rampant
…
the European model are increasingly seen as necessary building blocks of a more equitable and human-centric digital economy. Each additional privacy scandal and online disinformation campaign further vindicates the European model while revealing the limits of the American model. Even the US itself is now growing aware of the
…
the country’s own democratic institutions and wreaking havoc around the world. Many of the deeply disturbing examples described in this book—be it the disinformation-fueled US Capitol insurrection, the encouragement of illegal sex trafficking in the infamous Backpage case, or the hate speech–fueled genocide in Myanmar—have
…
in internet platforms as the guardians and amplifiers of democracy. Now this illusion has been shattered. The digital public space is frequently compromised by rampant disinformation, which interferes with elections and destabilizes democracies. America had a rude awakening on January 6, 2021, when President Trump’s loyalists stormed the US
…
handful of tech giants is hardly a reflection of economic freedom as conceived by early techno-libertarians. Similarly, recent scandals, including those revealing how online disinformation campaigns can undermine democratic elections, have shown that strong democracy does not necessarily flow from an unregulated digital marketplace. Consequently, a more regulated digital economy
…
Behind China’s Twitter Campaign, a Murky Supporting Chorus, N.Y. Times (June 8, 2020), https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/08/technology/china-twitter-disinformation.html. 74.Zhao Lijian (@zlj517), Twitter (Mar. 12, 2020), https://twitter.com/zlj517/status/1238111898828066823?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1238111898828066823%7Ctwgr%5E
…
Social Media Companies Censor Conservatives (2021), https://bhr.stern.nyu.edu/bias-report-release-page. 127.Yochai Benkler, Robert Fairs, & Hal Roberts, Network Propaganda: Manipulation, Disinformation, and Radicalization in American Politics 354 (2018). 128.Freedom House, Freedom on the Net (2021), https://freedomhouse.org/country/united-states/freedom-net/2021. 129
…
/eu-referendum-analysis-2016/section-7-social-media/impact-of-social-media-on-the-outcome-of-the-eu-referendum/. 138.Digital, Culture, Media & Sport Committee, Disinformation and “Fake News”: Final Report, 2017–2019, HC 1791, § 6 (UK), https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmcumeds/1791/1791.pdf. 139.Aurelien
…
Plan, 350–51 AI Ethics Framework, 350–51 anti-censorship principles, 267–68 antitrust regulation, 343–44, 345 Clean Network, 321 Code of Practice on Disinformation and Misinformation, 341–42 content moderation, 341–42 digital trade agreements, 322 news industry regulation, 351–52, 383 nonregulation principle, 266–68 Privacy Act,
…
299–300 Europe. see also specific countries by name 5G networks, 301 Apple’s revenue, 261 Chinese influence in, 301 digital single market, 129–30 disinformation campaigns, 280–81 internet freedom initiatives, 272–73 national tax regimes, 142–43 search engine market, 260–61 smart cities, 296–97 European Battery Alliance
…
Haley, Nikki, 213–14 Halifax International Security Forum, 388–89 hard tech, 96–97 hardware companies, 73. see also specific companies by name harmful activity disinformation campaigns, 277–78, 280–81 fake news, 281–82 online content, 119–21, 141 protections against, 113–15 sanctions against, 134, 197–99 terrorist
…
compliance with EU laws and regulations, 163, 324–25 content moderation, 341 data centers, 154 data privacy policy, 324, 330 data transfer battles, 222–23 Disinformation Code, 120 European headquarters, 142–43 global influence, 133–34, 259–60, 261–62 global revenue, 154, 261–62 government battles, 13–14, 222
…
303 content controls, 180–81 cyberattacks, 134 data localization requirements, 330–31 demands on Meta, 338 digital authoritarianism, 135, 308–13 Digital Divide projects, 268 disinformation campaigns, 120–21 Federal Security Service, 312–13 hate speech law, 140–41 and international code of conduct for information security, 303 internet sovereignty, 309
…
of the European Union, 110, 118 Trip Advisor, 358 Truex, Rody, 197 Trump, Donald America First policy, 213 complaints against EU antitrust policy, 245 disinformation propagation, 277–78 efforts to ban Chinese tech companies, 102–3, 166–68 efforts to discipline social media companies, 49–50 efforts to restrict entry
by Ronald J. Deibert · 14 Aug 2020
. The “gee whiz” factor has given way to a kind of dreadful ennui. Your daily news feeds fill with stories about data breaches, privacy infringements, disinformation, spying, and manipulation of political events. Social media executives have been dragged before congressional and parliamentary hearings to face the glare of the cameras and
…
designed to handle sensitive communications. In spite of efforts by social media platforms to remove misleading information and point their users to credible health sources, disinformation was everywhere, sometimes consumed with terrible effects. People perished drinking poisonous cocktails shared over social media (and endorsed by Donald Trump himself) in a desperate
…
institutions over others (both positively and negatively). Seen through this lens, social media do not generate practices, ideas, and institutions de novo. The spread of disinformation in the public realm is not something Facebook or Twitter alone is responsible for. The practice of deliberately spreading false information is as old as
…
humanity itself.20 However, social media’s algorithms create conditions ripe for its propagation today, and as a consequence, disinformation practices are proliferating, becoming more elaborate, backed up with more resources, and thus potentially have more damaging effects than would be the case in the
…
around any major news event, the circulation of information about the coronavirus on social media was flooded with conspiracy theories, misinformation (false or inaccurate information), disinformation (deliberately propagated false information), racist memes, chat censorship and surveillance, and even viruses of another kind.82 Official news, alerts, and health tips from groups
…
than thirty incidents of arson and vandalism as anti-5G activists set fire to base stations and cell towers and harassed telecommunications technicians.87 Alarmingly, disinformation spread through social media contributed directly to mob violence and armed clashes with police in Ukraine.88 An email designed to appear as though it
…
official government-related health information.92 Gradually, each of the platforms introduced measures to point users to credible health information, flag unverified information, and remove disinformation — but in an uncoordinated fashion and with questionable results.93 The platforms’ intrinsic bias towards speed and volume of posts made the measures inherently ineffective
…
caused massive devastation to property and wildlife, and even loss of life. But the crisis also provided an opportunity for climate change denialists to propagate disinformation, and for misinformed speculation to swarm and compete for people’s precious attention.97 Conspiracy theories circulated across social media, claiming bushfires were deliberately lit
…
it comes to capitalizing on the System 1 effects of social media. As a consequence, we are seeing an explosion of social media–enabled PR, disinformation, “psy-ops,” and “influence” operations — some open, commercial, and seemingly above board, but many others inhabiting a subterranean underworld of illicit acts, “dark money,” and
…
were executed as part of clandestine regime change and other military and intelligence programs throughout the Third World. As happens today, commercial and nation-state disinformation campaigns periodically overlapped. In the 1940s, the United Fruit Company hired Edward Bernays, who later used his public relations expertise to help foment a coup
…
in Guatemala after the election of a president who was unfavourable to the company. Bernays helped mount a multi-pronged disinformation campaign designed to discredit the democratically elected president, Jacobo Árbenz, as a communist puppet and to motivate U.S. lawmakers and thought leaders to support
…
of a few whistleblowers. But countless other companies like it roll on, following variations on the same successful model. BuzzFeed News, which has studied online disinformation campaigns extensively, discovered that “since 2011, at least 27 online information operations have been partially or wholly attributed to PR or marketing firms.169 Of
…
censorship technologies) tried to prevent their citizens from accessing undesirable content. Now, thanks to social media, an environment of information abundance, and the opportunities for disinformation, these regimes are following a strategy that author and journalist Peter Pomerantsev, in his book This Is Not Propaganda, calls “censorship through noise.”171 If
…
you can’t beat them, join in and flood them. Of course any discussion of disinformation is not complete without mention of Russia. In Russian, “dezinformatsiya” refers to the manipulation of information in the service of propagation of falsehoods. It has
…
staying within the bounds of decency or the rule of law (and not necessarily in the sense of being tidier or more effective either). Russian disinformation is undertaken by organized criminal groups acting as proxies alongside independently operating, overlapping, and sometimes competing spy agencies and security services, all of which work
…
. But they enjoy it nonetheless, spending as much as ten hours per day online. Meanwhile, dozens of sketchy PR companies have sprouted up, openly advertising disinformation services barely disguised as benign-sounding “identity management” or “issue framing.” Political campaigns routinely make use of these consulting services, which in turn pay college
…
any topic she desired trend on Twitter in the Philippines. Her loyalists are paid in cash, cellphones, and other gifts. The rabid social media–fuelled disinformation wars are degrading the political environment in the Philippines, but since virtually everyone in a position of power has bought into it, there is little
…
for celebrities. Trolls for liberal opposition politicians and the government. Trolls trolling trolls.” The Post report, which profiled numerous companies that paid trolls to spread disinformation, also warned that what was happening in the Philippines would likely find its way abroad. “The same young, educated, English-speaking workforce that made the
…
North Africa — the same dynamics are playing themselves out, with a spice of local flavour and entrepreneurial variation. In Indonesia, low-level military personnel coordinate disinformation campaigns that include dozens of websites and social media accounts whose operators are paid a fee by the military, and whose posts routinely heap praise
…
tell whether they originate in Taiwan or in China, and whether they are the work of private provocateurs or of state agents.” In India, racist disinformation on WhatsApp groups and other social media platforms has incited mass outbreaks of ethnic violence and public lynchings, including the horrific “Delhi Riots” of February
…
payrolls.182 They have built entire organizations, think tanks, and other front organizations to generate scientific-looking but implausible reports, which are then seeded into disinformation campaigns and targeted advertisements meant to disorient and distract audiences from the real science of climate change.183 The consequences for global public safety are
…
to say the companies are sitting idle. They are feeling the pressure to react, and have taken several noteworthy steps to combat the plague of disinformation, including shutting down inauthentic accounts by the thousands, hiring more personnel to screen posts and investigate malpractice on their platforms, “down-ranking” clearly false information
…
before it gets better, as malicious actors are now using altered images and videos, called “deep fakes,” as well as large WhatsApp groups, to spread disinformation virally.196 These techniques are far more difficult for the platforms to combat and will almost certainly become a staple of discrediting and blackmail campaigns
…
. Under the reign of prime minister Narendra Modi and his Hindu nationalist right-wing party, the BJP, the country has rapidly descended into authoritarianism.282 Disinformation and misinformation run rampant through social media, sparking frequent outbreaks of mob violence and ethnic animosity — the most recent of which was horrific sectarian violence
…
end-to-end encrypted, making it more difficult for the platform to moderate content, are especially prone to these spikes of panic- or violence-inducing disinformation. Like those in many other countries, Indian authorities have rolled out technologically enhanced surveillance and other information controls. Upon arrival at the airport, I (along
…
or for worse. Detachment and retreat also ignore or at least slight the many positive uses of digital technologies, social media included. In spite of disinformation and overreaching surveillance, social media have proven highly useful for many problems. They have helped families, communities, and co-workers connect during the COVID crisis
…
’s no practical reason why not. Consider WhatsApp, whose platform’s “group chat” function was widely associated with inflaming ethnic animosity, inciting violence, and spreading disinformation around the world. Since its messages are end-to-end encrypted, which limits the platform’s ability to screen actual content, WhatsApp took steps to
…
, they all eventually decided to carry highly visible pointers to credible scientific content about the crisis at the top of their feeds, and actively removed disinformation when discovered (they even issued a rare joint statement in March 2020 saying they would elevate “authoritative content”).443 But as you might expect when
…
scramble to get inside our heads. Knopf. Chapter Two: Toxic Addiction Machines Commonplace around any major news event: For a discussion of the meanings of disinformation, misinformation, propaganda, etc., see Jack, C. (2017). Lexicon of lies: Terms for problematic information. Data & Society Research Institute. Retrieved from https://datasociety.net/library/lexicon
…
-of-lies/; Derakhshan, H., & Wardle, C. (2017). Information disorder: definitions. AA. VV., Understanding and addressing the disinformation ecosystem, 5-12. The WHO went so far as to label COVID-19 an “infodemic”: World Health Organization. (2020, February 2). Novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV
…
, N. Middle East Twitter bots and the covid-19 infodemic. Retrieved from http://workshop-proceedings.icwsm.org/pdf/2020_17.pdf Russian propaganda outlets spread disinformation: Breland, A. (2020, February 3). Russian media outlets are blaming the coronavirus on the United States. Retrieved from https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2020/02
…
/russian-disinformation-coronavirus/ Widely accepted throughout Chinese society: Gilbert, D. (2020, April 6). The Chinese government has convinced its citizens that the U.S. Army brought coronavirus
…
YouTube radicalized Brazil. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/11/world/americas/youtube-brazil.html An opportunity for climate change denialists to propagate disinformation: Ryan, H., & Wilson, C. (2020, January 22). As Australia burned, climate change denialism got a boost on Facebook. Retrieved from https://www.buzzfeed.com/hannahryan
…
. (2019). This is not propaganda: Adventures in the war against reality. Hachette UK. “Professional, organized lying”: Rid, T. (2020). Active measures: The secret history of disinformation and political warfare. Farrar, Straus and Giroux. Rid combines his detailed historical analysis with some interesting observations about how democracies are particularly susceptible to active
…
measures. “Disinformation operations, in essence, erode the very foundation of open societies—not only for the victim but also for the perpetrator. When vast, secretive bureaucracies engage
…
of public administration at home. A society’s approach to active measures is a litmus test for its republican institutions. For liberal democracies in particular, disinformation represents a double threat: being at the receiving end of active measures will undermine democratic institutions—and giving in to the temptation to design and
…
deploy them will have the same result. It is impossible to excel at disinformation and at democracy at the same time.” (p. 11) “Third-generation” techniques: Deibert, R., & Rohozinski, R. (2010). Control and subversion in Russian cyberspace. In R
…
), 243–250; Freelon, D., Bossetta, M., Wells, C., Lukito, J., Xia, Y., & Adams, K. (2020). Black trolls matter: Racial and ideological asymmetries in social media disinformation. Social Science Computer Review. https://doi.org/10.1177/0894439320914853 Take the Philippines, which is a good case study: Alba, D. (2019, March 19). Facebook
…
the Philippines. Retrieved from https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/daveyalba/facebook-removes-inauthentic-engagement-philippines-nic; Ong, J. C., & Cabanes, J. (2018). Architects of networked disinformation: Behind the scenes of troll accounts and fake news production in the Philippines. Newton Tech4Dev Network. https://doi.org/10.7275/2cq4-5396 The Philippines
…
-may-be-coming-to-a-website-near-you/2019/07/25/c5d42ee2-5c53-11e9-98d4-844088d135f2_story.html In Indonesia, low-level military personnel coordinate disinformation campaigns: Allard, T., & Stubbs, J. (2020, January 7). Indonesian army wields internet ‘news’ as a weapon in Papua. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/article
…
. (2016, August 29). A powerful Russian weapon: The spread of false stories. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/29/world/europe/russia-sweden-disinformation.html “A plurality of unreality … encourages the listener to doubt everything”: Zuckerman, E. (2019). QAnon and the emergence of the unreal. Journal of Design and
…
attacks on democracy. Berkman Klein Center Research Publication 2018-7. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3273111. Social media remain polluted by misinformation and disinformation: Lewis, P. (2018). “Fiction is outperforming reality”: How YouTube’s algorithm distorts truth. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/feb/02/how-youtubes
…
, 170 Human Rights Watch, 165 Hungary, 193 ibm X-Force, 84 imsi catchers (cell site simulators), 190–191 India, 202–210 China and, 203–204 disinformation in, 127, 202–203 e-waste in, 242–246 pollution in, 206–208 Indonesia, 127, 225 information overload, 106–109, 129 InfoWars, 88–89 Innis
by Sheera Frenkel and Cecilia Kang · 12 Jul 2021 · 372pp · 100,947 words
or otherwise objectionable content on Facebook’s properties,” the attorneys general alleged in their complaint. Even when faced with major impropriety such as Russia’s disinformation campaign and the data privacy scandal involving Cambridge Analytica, users didn’t leave the site because there were few alternatives, the regulators maintained. As James
…
by politicians and pundits howling about censorship and miscasting content moderation as the demise of free speech online,” in the words of Renée DiResta, a disinformation researcher at Stanford’s Internet Observatory. “There is no right to algorithmic amplification. In fact, that’s the very problem that needs fixing.”10 It
…
by hackers collecting intelligence about key figures in the U.S. elections. It explained that Russians had created fake Facebook accounts and pages to spread disinformation and false news. It provided a history of Russia’s military intelligence agency, or GRU, and an overview of its capabilities. It suggested that Russia
…
a platform for both active and passive information operations.” The threat was only increasing, the report made clear: “We expect that our challenge with organized disinformation campaigns will only increase in 2017.” No one else spoke as Zuckerberg and Sandberg drilled their chief security officer. Why had they been kept in
…
—working under what was known as an XFN, or “cross-functional,” group—continued to search for Russian interference and broadened their scope to look for disinformation campaigns affecting other countries. The security team had already found that governments were actively using the platform to promote their own political agendas. In a
…
produced by the XFN team, Stamos included flags from nations such as Turkey and Indonesia as examples of governments that had used Facebook to run disinformation campaigns to sway public opinion and elections in their countries or those in nearby states. Facebook needed to go on the offensive. It should no
…
who was privy to the discussions. “They saw Stamos as alarmist. He hadn’t uncovered any big Russian interference, and what he was suggesting with disinformation seemed hypothetical. They also knew that if they took it to Sheryl and the company announced a big re-org, it could draw more scrutiny
…
so big.” While over the years some Facebook employees had speculated that the IRA was focused on spreading disinformation in the United States, no one had thought to go looking for a professional disinformation campaign run by the organization. The security team had not believed the IRA audacious or powerful enough to
…
figures he’d provided were immediately torn apart by academics and independent researchers who had long been studying Russia’s presence online. In San Francisco, disinformation researcher Renée DiResta reviewed the Facebook blog post from her apartment overlooking the bay. Almost immediately, she began texting researchers and amateur
…
disinformation sleuths she had developed relationships with over the last two years. The number of people actively studying disinformation in the United States could be listed in one breath. DiResta, like the others, had chanced
…
may seem like it’s not a huge amount, but at the same time, that’s millions of people seeing or liking or passing on disinformation, and that can be influential,” Schiff pointed out after reading the blog post earlier that day. Greg Mauer, Facebook’s designated lobbyist for House Republicans
…
why we’re so focused on addressing it going forward.” Facebook’s security team felt like they were under attack. They had found a Russian disinformation campaign that no one, including the U.S. government, had predicted or thought to look for. But instead of being thanked, they were being mocked
…
of ways in August. During the remainder of the time Stamos spent at Facebook, he didn’t speak with Sandberg or Zuckerberg about the Russian disinformation campaign or his departure. There was no company-wide good-bye party. Instead, he gathered with the closest members of his erstwhile security team and
…
, at the annual dinner he hosted each year, George Soros delivered a speech in which he expressed deep concern about the role of propaganda and disinformation campaigns on social media in the U.S. elections. A Hungarian-born Jewish refugee and survivor of the Holocaust, Soros laid partial blame on Facebook
…
extended beyond the Cambridge Analytica scandal. Lawmakers fired off questions about the harmful addiction of the technology, the deceptive terms of service, and the election disinformation. They asked Facebook to share internal data about how it was working to protect users and whether it was in compliance with global privacy laws
…
. And they brought up how, in the Southeast Asian nation of Myanmar, the spread of disinformation was playing out in the most visceral example of the platform’s harms to date. Genocide was taking place on Facebook in real time. On
…
hire “dozens more” Burmese speakers and would work more closely with civil society groups to take down the accounts of local leaders who were spreading disinformation and calling for violence. (At the time, the platform had only five Burmese speakers to patrol content for Myanmar’s eighteen million Facebook users. None
…
other experts were seeing in Myanmar was far more dangerous than a one-off remark or an isolated Facebook post. Myanmar was consumed by a disinformation campaign against the Rohingya, and it was taking place on Facebook. In the month following the call, a handful of Facebook employees started an informal
…
lingered in the hallway outside the conference room. “He can’t be serious,” one said loudly. “That’s just not possible.” The root of the disinformation problem, of course, lay in the technology. Facebook was designed to throw gas on the fire of any speech that invoked an emotion, even if
…
villages. Officials at Facebook had recently removed thousands of Facebook accounts and pages secretly run by the Burmese military that were flooded with hate speech, disinformation, and racist tropes. The posts included photos of bombings or corpses the user had identified as images of innocent people killed in attacks by the
…
been forced to defend Facebook to their friends, family, and angry employees. Most of them had had little to do with the controversies over election disinformation and Cambridge Analytica, and several of them were struggling with their private frustrations with Zuckerberg and Sandberg. Held two or three times a year, M
…
on this visit, she dispensed with a staff meeting to prepare to testify before the Senate Intelligence Committee, which was overseeing an investigation into Russian disinformation campaigns on Facebook and other social media platforms. The stakes couldn’t have been higher. In the aftermath of Zuckerberg’s reprimand for her handling
…
accounts aimed at influencing Americans ahead of the midterms, as well as a campaign of hundreds17 of Iranian and Russian accounts and pages engaged in disinformation efforts on behalf of their governments across parts of Europe and the Middle East. “To see the way that the company has mobilized to make
…
to Hughes by name. He didn’t address any of the arguments raised by Hughes, such as the abuse of consumer privacy, the threat of disinformation to democracy, and Zuckerberg’s too-powerful control. Instead, he warned of any intervention to dismantle Facebook’s power. “If what you care about is
…
. Many of his arguments echoed Fabi’s concern about the potential for criminal activity. Private groups were also harder to police for the spread of disinformation, he pointed out: Facebook was setting the stage for conspiracy theorists, hate groups, and terrorists to organize and to spread their messages under a cloak
…
and Democratic lawmakers in charge of the Commerce and Intelligence Committees in both chambers. The legislators grilled Sandberg about privacy abuses and efforts to prevent disinformation during the 2020 elections and demanded signs of progress.1 It was a trying period for Sandberg. Her work responsibilities were crushing: friends said she
…
down fake foreign accounts, the hiring of thousands of content moderators, and the implementation of AI and other technologies to quickly track and take down disinformation. She assured Pelosi that Facebook would not fight regulations. She pointed to Zuckerberg’s op-ed in the Washington Post in April that called for
…
the following day in a slow-motion debate. Sandberg said she thought there was a good argument to take the video down under rules against disinformation, but she left it at that. Kaplan and Republican lobbyists encouraged Zuckerberg’s “maximum openness” position on speech and stressed that it was important to
…
up something that they know is false,” she declared in a San Francisco public radio interview. Facebook, she added, was contributing to the problem of disinformation on its site. “I think they have proven—by not taking down something they know is false—that they were willing enablers of the Russian
…
at the downtown restaurant Ris DC. Over grilled salmon and roasted brussels sprouts, Zuckerberg updated them on foreign accounts Facebook had taken down for spreading disinformation. But employees on the West Coast viewed Kaplan’s tactics as deeply cynical; Trump wasn’t just another politician. They wanted Facebook to draw a
…
referenced my father,” Martin Luther King Jr.’s daughter Bernice King tweeted. “I’d like to help Facebook better understand the challenges #MLK faced from disinformation campaigns launched by politicians. These campaigns created an atmosphere for his assassination.” Zuckerberg hadn’t been involved in the company’s civil rights work. When
…
Vanita Gupta, who had been pushing him for changes on the platform to combat disinformation, asked him during a phone conversation days before the Georgetown speech if he had civil rights experts on staff, he responded that he had hired
…
upcoming election. In July 2020, Zuckerberg confided to Vanita Gupta of the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights that he worried about polarization and disinformation and the effect of Trump’s use of the platform. “I’m really afraid for our democracy,” he told her in a phone call. Trump
…
Facebook’s position on free expression was abusing the privilege. Zuckerberg asked Gupta, who had been frustrated with him for dragging his feet on election disinformation, for help in strengthening policy enforcement ahead of November. He said he would be personally involved: “I am feeling a great sense of urgency.” Part
…
Color of Change insisted that the company at least follow Twitter’s lead in policing Trump’s account for speech that incited violence and spread disinformation about mail-in voting. Zuckerberg fielded most of the questions. He defended Facebook’s efforts, saying the platform’s AI was now able to detect
…
Stanford, where he had formed an Election Integrity Team that included academics, researchers, and other experts, he helped publish regular reports about foreign countries running disinformation networks on Facebook’s platform and established a grading system for how Facebook, as well as other social media companies, was preparing for the elections
…
Sense Media, 89–91, 232, 261, 275–276 Conaway, Mike, 143, 144 Congress, of U.S. House Judiciary Committee, 153, 241, 297 interest in Russian disinformation, 127–128, 133–134, 139–145 January 6, 2021 storming of U.S. Capitol Building and, 286–292 Zuckerberg’s testimony before, 150–151, 153
…
hate speech and, 83–86 Silicon Valley’s support of H. Clinton, 243–244 social media and, 15 Zuckerberg after, 113–116 see also Russian disinformation, on Facebook platform election of 2020 Facebook’s fact-checking policy, 249–252 January 6, 2021 storming of U.S. Capitol Building, 286–292, 294
…
Robinson, Rashad, 249, 251, 276–277 Rose, Dan, 44, 45, 46, 51 Rosen, Guy, 195, 260, 285 Rosensweig, Dan, 43–44 Rubio, Marco, 161 Russian disinformation, on Facebook platform, 3, 282 Congressional interest in, 127–128, 133–134, 139–145 Facebook board of director’s interest in, 134–137 Facebook employees
…
–200 as protective of her image, 4 reaction to emotional contagion research, 183 response to criticisms of Facebook, 156–157 responsible growth and, 86 Russian disinformation investigation and, 118–119, 120, 121, 122–123, 126, 127–128, 134, 136, 139, 143–144, 147, 196–197 Schrage and, 87–88, 89–92
…
, 142–144 Schissler, Matt, 171–173, 177–182 Schmidt, Eric, 42, 44, 46, 62, 192, 207 Schrage, Elliot Definers Public Affairs and, 216–217 Russian disinformation and, 119, 123, 125–126, 134–135 Sandberg and, 87–88, 89–92 Schumer and, 66–67, 88 Trump’s 2015 anti-Muslim rhetoric and
…
, 65, 66 Sperling, Gene, 248 Stamos, Alex background before Facebook, 101–103 election of 2020 and, 283–284 investigation and report on Russian meddling and disinformation, 97, 100, 103–107, 116, 117–127, 130, 132, 145–147 2015 report on security of user’s information, 7–11 2018 Facebook reorganization and
…
, 89, 91, 232, 261, 275–276 Stop the Hate for Profit, 275 “Stop the Steal” groups, 288, 292 Stretch, Colin Cambridge Analytica and, 150 Russian disinformation and, 97, 100, 107, 119–120, 125, 135, 144–145, 146, 147 Students Against Facebook News Feed, 34, 35 Sullivan, Joe, 103–104 Summers, Lawrence
…
–75, 252–261, 263, 269, 281 goals of global expansion and end of economic inequality, 173–177 Goldberg’s death and, 79 hate speech and disinformation issues, 11, 193, 204–208, 275–277 hearing regarding Libra and, 256–257 Kaplan and Kavanaugh hearings and, 201–202 Kaplan’s organization of dinners
…
of Facebook in 2018 and, 193–194 responsible growth and, 86 reversing of promises made when acquiring Instagram and WhatsApp, 2, 194, 227–229 Russian disinformation investigation and, 117, 118–119, 120, 121, 126, 134, 136–137, 139, 142, 147, 196, 204 Sandberg’s hiring and, 43–47 testimony before Congress
by Peter Pomerantsev · 29 Jul 2019 · 240pp · 74,182 words
and shape it into sensible Conclusions and Recommendations for neatly formatted reports and PowerPoint presentations, which diagnose and propose ways of remedying the flood of disinformation, ‘fake news’, ‘information war’ and the ‘war on information’. Remedying what, however? The neat little bullet points of my reports assume that there really is
…
of stifling you, flipping the ideals of freedom of speech to crush dissent, while always leaving enough anonymity to be able to claim deniability? The Disinformation Architecture Consider the Philippines. In 1977, as my parents were experiencing the pleasures of the KGB, the Philippines was ruled by Colonel Ferdinand Marcos, a
…
of ‘Imperial Manila’ and the prim Catholic Church establishment. But P’s account of digital influence does echo some academic studies. In ‘Architects of Networked Disinformation’, Dr Jonathan Corpus Ong of the University of Massachusetts and Dr Jason Cabañes of Leeds University spent twelve months interviewing the protagonists of what Ong
…
called Manila’s ‘disinformation architecture’, which was made use of by every party in the country.3 At the top were what he described as the ‘chief architects’ of
…
you’re found out,’ they would tell Ong. They were proud they had made it to the top of their profession from modest beginnings. ‘The disinformation architect’, concludes Ong, ‘denies responsibility or commitment to the broader public by narrating a personal project of self-empowerment instead.’ Below the architects came the
…
‘influencers’, online comedians who, in between posting the latest jokes, made fun of opposing politicians for a fee. Down in the slums of the disinformation architecture were what Ong called the ‘community-level fake account operators’: call centres full of people working twenty-four-hour shifts, paid by the hour
…
crew from the English-language version of the Qatari TV channel Al Jazeera, who were following Maria around to document her battle with Duterte and disinformation. The Al Jazeera crew asked whether they could film me interviewing Maria, and as they crouched in the corner with their huge cameras I felt
…
trolls direct instructions on what to post under which articles printed in mainstream Russian publications. The farm was working in rhythm with the whole government disinformation complex. No one had time to read the articles, but they knew exactly what to post. The trolls were told to spread confusion about who
…
://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0017234. 3 Ong, Jonathan Corpus and Jason Vincent A. Cabañes, ‘Architects of Networked Disinformation’, University of Leeds (2018); https://newtontechfordev.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/ARCHITECTS-OF-NETWORKED-DISINFORMATION-FULL-REPORT.pdf. 4 Amnesty International, ‘Detained Duterte Critic Must Be Freed Immediately’ (23 February 2018); https
…
of the Internet Research Agency’ (Austin, TX: New Knowledge, 2018); https://disinformationreport.blob.core.windows.net/disinformation-report/NewKnowledge-Disinformation-Report-Whitepaper.pdf. 17 Monaco, Nicholas and Carly Nyst, ‘State-Sponsored Trolling: How Governments Are Deploying Disinformation as Part of Broader Digital Harassment Campaigns’ (Palo Alto, CA: Institute for the Future, 2018); http
…
. She told herself she would somehow stay above the fray; she was for democracy and human rights, sure, but she wouldn’t get dragged into disinformation, wouldn’t get her hands dirty. Tetyana’s shift was in the morning. She was usually based in Kiev, but today she happened to be
…
they recorded the names of taxi drivers who wanted Severodonetsk annexed. The separatists’ portals were in a panic, and Babar felt he was winning the disinformation war. He wanted them to doubt everything and lose their bearings – to do to them what the Kremlin was doing to Ukraine. Now he needed
…
traded in for some deal with Moscow. He kept on calling his contacts, explaining to them that he’d done all the preparatory work – the disinformation campaign, building up the alliance of different groups … In May the separatists took power in Severodonetsk. The local administration welcomed them, took down the Ukrainian
…
his own version of a one-man information war had failed. In a sense he’d tried to reverse-engineer the Russian approach: first spread disinformation to confuse the enemy, then use irregular forces, gangsters and mercenaries to hold a town. But the Ukrainians were still too slow to cotton on
…
the reliability of sources, to use a reverse image search to verify pictures were from where they claimed to be from. Hadn’t he used disinformation himself when he ‘nightmared’ the separatists with his fake rumours? How did he square that with promoting media literacy campaigns? Babar smiled. ‘I believe in
…
disinformation for the other side and media literacy for my side.’ * Information vigilante groups were sprouting in Ukraine, and I wanted to know what it was
…
Socialism across the world; state that the Objective, Scientific Progress of History was still inevitable … Even when it peddled what the KGB called ‘active measures’ – disinformation campaigns that claimed, for instance, that the US had invented AIDS as a weapon – it would do so with a Soviet seriousness, including interviews with
…
one point of view – and not one necessarily based on its factuality. So if you were to watch one video full of inaccurate, often downright disinformative content, the algorithm would keep feeding you similar material. YouTube didn’t want to be the judge of what is true, but it wanted its
…
early twenties but is trying to preserve his home on camera before what’s left disappears, whether from continuous bombardment or under the deluge of disinformation. ‘They say we are all terrorists. I need to show the world what we are really like.’ At first Mary Ana hadn’t taken the
…
disinformation about Syria very seriously. Then she began to look further and saw that it was everywhere. When she punched ‘White Helmets’ into YouTube and found
…
one can see instigated live, online, in full view, it’s hard not to feel Mary Ana’s worst fears are coming true. And is disinformation then just the excuse we use to let ourselves off the hook – ‘We didn’t do anything because we were confused by a bot farm
…
/28834069.html. Lomsadze, Giorgi, ‘Does the US Have a Secret Germ Warfare Lab on Russia’s Doorstep?’, Coda Story, 19 April 2018; https://codastory.com/disinformation/information-war/does-the-us-have-a-secret-germ-warfare-lab-on-russias-doorstep/. See also EU Versus Disinfo website, which tracks
…
disinformation and has an archive of stories: https://euvsdisinfo.eu. For example, https://euvsdisinfo.eu/report/ukraine-asked-the-united-states-to-spread-the-ebola-virus/;
…
a world where spectacle had pushed out sense, which left gut feeling as the only means of finding one’s way through the fog of disinformation. I returned to London because, in the words of my naive self, I wanted to live in a world where ‘words have meaning’, where every
…
Oakes rhetorically, ‘when you give people what they want?’ His former colleague Nix made a similar argument when testifying to the UK Parliamentary Committee on Disinformation and ‘Fake News’, which I had been brought into as one of many ‘specialist advisers’. ‘We are trying to make sure that voters receive messages
…
’, but then found the meaning of those words was morphing to denote any content that someone didn’t like. They tried instead to differentiate between ‘disinformation’ (content designed to mislead) and ‘misinformation’ (content that misleads by accident). But many of the most pernicious campaigns I’d seen didn’t necessarily use
…
‘disinformation’. And even if ‘disinformation’ is identified, would, or indeed should, that make it illegal necessarily? What if one were to refocus ‘disinformation’ from content to behaviour: bots, cyborgs and trolls that purposefully disguise their identity to confuse
…
escapees didn’t feel they found ‘reality’ or stable ground elsewhere. There were Chinese anti-regime sites, but many of them indulged in their own disinformation. And the West barely represented a place driven by informed factuality. And so they carried on further and found themselves in a process of always
…
they turned and said, in unison, ‘I’m Superman.’ The other boy answered, ‘And I’m Batman.’ Notes 1 Committee for Culture, Media and Sport, ‘Disinformation and “Fake News”’, 18 February 2019; https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmcumeds/1791/179102.htm. Gyldensted, Cathrine, From Mirrors to Movers: Five Elements
…
of Economics, studying twenty-first century information manipulation and how to fix it. An author and TV producer, he is a widely cited expert on disinformation and media, and writes for publications including Granta, The Atlantic and the Financial Times. His first book, Nothing is True and Everything is Possible, won
by Maria Ressa · 19 Oct 2022
platforms, the world’s new information gatekeepers, those activities created more engagement and brought in more money. The goals of the gatekeepers and the disinformation operatives aligned. That was the first time we became aware of information warfare tactics that would soon be deployed around the world, from Duterte to
…
February 24, 2022, using the same techniques and the same metanarratives he had seeded to annex Crimea, Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine itself. This is how disinformation, bottom up and top down, can manufacture a whole new reality. Less than three months later, the Philippines fell into the abyss. May 9,
…
as toxins, bacteria, and viruses to use as weapons of mass destruction. White House press secretary Marlin Fitzwater began calling Peter “a conduit for Iraqi disinformation.” Those in power have always attempted to control the narrative, especially during wartime. That was true even before social media. Peter would make mistakes later
…
was seeing in Indonesia was something I had seen in the Philippines and someday would see in countries around the world as the power of disinformation began to devastate the minds, and transform the behavior, of often less educated people or those less familiar with the internet. Education determines the
…
Monterey, California.21 In tracking terrorists, we saw that al-Qaeda and Jemaah Islamiyah (JI) in Southeast Asia and Australia operated the same way as disinformation networks someday would: they hijacked disparate groups, trained and funded them, and infected them with the jihadi ideology that targeted both the “near enemy,”
…
later: Facebook’s cybersecurity and intelligence experts, including former employees of the US National Security Council, would come to the same conclusion about how online disinformation networks that spread through Facebook regenerated after years of takedowns: “The threat became more dispersed and harder to track down.”23 By 2003, I had
…
before the great propaganda wars began in 2016, “happy” was overwhelmingly the most prevalent emotion in five years among our users.18 Over time, disinformation networks would exploit the greed of Facebook and YouTube and we would see in real time how behavior changed, with information operations artificially inflating the
…
took off, some shady companies that sold Twitter likes and followers had offices in the Philippines.18 Political marketing by now had evolved into “networked disinformation.” When Filipino politicians began to experiment with social media, many outsourced their operations to advertising and PR strategists who pulled together a spectrum of content
…
gave shape to the disparate elements already in the Philippines that operated in a gray area of law and ethics.19 Supply met demand, and disinformation became big business. The Philippines was also a fraud hub. By 2019, it was the global leader of online attacks,20 both automated and
…
services to political candidates and corporations. In 2016, Rappler began tracking people who shifted the discourse as Sam did and all of the networks of disinformation. Our research arm wanted to understand the phenomenon. We were one of the few media organizations doing so in the world, which was another
…
States in the 1990s—mostly by computer companies like IBM and Microsoft targeting their competitors—known as “fear, uncertainty, and doubt,” or FUD. The disinformation campaign spread negative information and lies to fuel fear. The conversation we mapped online reminded us of the Communist strategy “Surround the city from the
…
and larger powers using the surreptitious tactics of a rebel group. Anyone who stood up to the lies spreading over pro-Duterte and pro-Marcos disinformation networks was gaslit, or told they were crazy. What the bad guys were doing, they ascribed to the good guys. The same process was
…
they behaved. We at Rappler began to think about how we could create a database to monitor our information ecosystem—a kind of Interpol for disinformation networks. We needed to build technology to understand the technology. We started automating data collection to see what kinds of content were spreading and
…
reach. We became better at this in the coming years, deciding that radical transparency, including publishing full geeky maps of the accounts taking part in disinformation networks, was the way to go: give as much information as the most detail-oriented reader might want. We continued our investigation of the
…
network was connected to the core manpower of the Duterte campaign. In August 2021, I discovered that the URL of one of the three key disinformation websites, newstrendph.com, had disappeared. In its place was a Chinese online betting site, linked to a controversial Duterte initiative, the Philippine Offshore Gaming
…
.46 This is partly why the company has consistently allowed politicians to lie, why it hid the truth, then blunted its announcement, about Russian disinformation and information operations, and why it allowed extremist groups to grow and seed metanarratives that led to its wake-up call: the violence on Capitol
…
Facebook says and does: first, that more information is better; second, that faster information is better; third, that the bad—lies, hate speech, conspiracy theories, disinformation, targeted attacks, information operations—should be tolerated in service of Facebook’s larger goals. All three ideas are great for Facebook because they mean that
…
only if there is something of a level playing field, not what Facebook algorithms created. The company’s choices gave a bullhorn to hate speech, disinformation, and conspiracy theories—emotive content that keeps you on site and scrolling, bringing in more revenues for the platform. If Facebook had taken its
…
in the comments where we saw a lot of astroturfing happen. Typically, Mark Zuckerberg didn’t take the comments into account when he claimed that disinformation composed only 1 percent of the site. The attacks on my own Facebook page also increased. I tried to respond, but my feed was
…
to embrace my fear and change what I could. We gathered data, monitoring the evolution of tactics as well as the growth and messaging of disinformation networks. Then we published stories that forecasted what might happen in other democratic countries.33 We knew we were wading into dangerous waters. By
…
and overwhelm a truth teller and change the public narrative. More than anything else at that time, the report captured the scope of the global disinformation crisis. It was to be released in August 2017, but it kept getting delayed. In October, Camille and I had lunch at Chelsea Market
…
Zuckerberg announced that Facebook would be overhauling its news feed.14 The changes would be a puny response to the growing public outcry over the disinformation it had allowed to run rampant. It would now be prioritizing what friends and family shared15 over content from publishers and brands (even the
…
facts reached fewer people. And if there are no facts to counter the lies that make their way to family and friends from information operations, disinformation spreads further exponentially. Facebook’s decision to deprioritize news18 was an absurd way to address issues of “fake news.” It claimed that it wanted
…
somewhat, maintained order and stability around the world. That hit me in June, when the Atlantic Council gathered fifteen of us in Berlin to study disinformation and its impact on power. Among the other participants were Madeleine Albright, former US secretary of state; Carl Bildt, former prime minister of Sweden;
…
268 people arrested. Those protests were different because the people behind them were decentralized: organized on social media—largely Facebook, according to my interviews—where disinformation was misleading and fueling past grievances, many of which might have been legitimate but now had been amplified to the point of encouraging violence. When
…
Mark Zuckerberg, was their youth. But I had learned to trust their supervisor, who was a former FBI investigator. Gemma Mendoza, who heads our disinformation research, was joining me to take the Facebook team through the tactics and methodology of the attack networks we had discovered. It was my second
…
point, Beth suddenly entered the room. Somewhat surprised, I stopped and introduced her to the Facebook team. “Hey, Beth, meet the new team working on disinformation networks at Facebook,” I said. “Guys, this is one of the founders of Rappler, Beth Frondoso.” “Maria, don’t turn around,” Beth said tersely.
…
to enforce its own policies and remove posts inciting violence; to ban ads that seek to delegitimize election results; and to take measures to prevent disinformation and misinformation about the election results. It was a sign of the times that within twenty-four hours, Facebook acted on all of them. It
…
with Facebook, hoping against hope that it would act. In the instances when Facebook did act, it often made the problem and the spread of disinformation worse. One example was shutting down the API, the application programming interface, that enabled third parties to gather data. The move was intended to
…
Step two was to use natural language processing, using computers to process large amounts of text to pull out the consistent messages of networks of disinformation. Doing that led us to step three, which was identifying the websites and other digital assets associated with those networks, including those profiting off
…
and fuel information operations. These government propaganda efforts are often aided and abetted by foreign actors. In December 2018, Rappler Research found links to Russian disinformation networks23 from the Facebook page of the Daily Sentry in the Philippines, which had quickly become the most powerful account attacking Rappler. Facebook would take
…
digital funnel to public hubs. NTF-ELCAC, on the other hand, uses a red-tagging network built on state accounts as well as its disinformation network. The end result was that the stories about the activists targeted and killed tended to stay within the bubble of progressive groups and the
…
government agencies—using tried and tested methods in the drug war and evolving after three Facebook takedowns in 2018 and 2019—can be at amplifying disinformation and abuse. This was the second wave of the Duterte administration’s use of violence and fear, the creation of an enabling environment for
…
team, working with our core managers, found the solution in our investigative journalism: the very same processes we had developed to track networks of disinformation online became the foundation of a data- and tech-based business model that grew by 12,000 percent from 2018 to 2019, helping power our
…
down on the lie,24 a lesson many people, including Donald Trump and Mark Zuckerberg, have learned is easily facilitated by social media. His disinformation network also hijacked popular pages and news groups with copied-and-pasted comments that slowly chipped away at the legacy of the Aquino family, long
…
views, matching social media’s impact on behavior in other parts of the world.26 The Marcos networks worked hand in hand with the Duterte disinformation and propaganda networks, using common themes to achieve their common goals. By 2018, the center of the Philippines’ Facebook information ecosystem was dominated by
…
down by Facebook for “coordinated inauthentic behavior.”27 One of the fastest-growing sites on Facebook that year was Daily Sentry; its links to Russian disinformation were exposed by Rappler28 (it was, not coincidentally, Rappler’s top attacker) before it was taken down. In 2020, Facebook would also take down
…
a common defense of facts. Competition stopped that in the Philippines, to our collective detriment, allowing news organizations to be sidelined by the Duterte-Marcos disinformation networks that had turned information operations into information warfare. The goal is to try to pull our collective digital footprints together. This idea started with
…
amplification, which would help all of us rise together, ensuring greater distribution of the fact-checks. Layer three is composed of at least seven disinformation research groups that take the data, make sense of it, and release a weekly report that tells us how the public sphere is being manipulated
…
facts. More than 140 groups from media, civil society, the Church, academe, business, and lawyers banded together—a whole-of-society approach to fighting disinformation and ensuring the integrity of our elections. Even though it took nearly three months to organize, it was exciting because we were no longer just
…
the ousting of the Marcos dictatorship, Leni Robredo’s campaign rallies began to draw massive crowds. Both Ukraine and Robredo had long been targets of disinformation, but in the following weeks, collective action by real people began to turn the tide, creating cracks of hope and light. Vladimir Putin had
…
to hundreds of thousands of people in city after city, igniting a spirit of volunteerism that our country had never seen before.40 To fight disinformation, they began to go door to door. Those developments made March a month of action. Our #FactsFirstPH pyramid grew in parallel with Robredo’s
…
for the companies and instead force them to make changes to their business model, such as ending algorithmic amplification that threatens fundamental rights and spreads disinformation and hate, including in cases where the risks originate outside EU borders. 5.Urgently propose legislation to ban surveillance advertising, recognizing this practice is fundamentally
…
journalists’ safety, media sustainability and democratic guarantees in the digital space in the forthcoming European Media Freedom Act. 8.Protect media freedom by cutting off disinformation upstream. This means there should be no special exemptions or carve-outs for any organization or individual in any new technology or media legislation. With
…
globalized information flows, this would give a blank check to those governments and non-state actors who produce industrial scale disinformation to harm democracies and polarize societies everywhere. 9.Challenge the extraordinary lobbying machinery, the astroturfing campaigns and recruitment revolving door between big tech companies and
…
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/01/27/technology/social-media-bots.html. 19.Jonathan Corpus Ong and Jason Vincent A. Cabañes, “Architects of Networked Disinformation: Behind the Scenes of Troll Accounts and Fake News Production in the Philippines,” Newton Tech4Dev Network, February 5, 2018, http://newtontechfordev.com/wp-content/uploads
…
/2018/02/ARCHITECTS-OF-NETWORKED-DISINFORMATION-FULL-REPORT.pdf. 20.Glen Arrowsmith, “Arkose Labs Presents the Q3 Fraud and Abuse Report,” Arkose Labs, September 18, 2019, https://www.arkoselabs.com/
by Roger McNamee · 1 Jan 2019 · 382pp · 105,819 words
2018051479 (ebook) | ISBN 9780525561361 (ebook) | ISBN 9780525561354 (hardcover) | ISBN 9781984877895 (export) Subjects: LCSH: Facebook (Electronic resource)—Social aspects. | Online social networks—Political aspects—United States. | Disinformation—United States. | Propaganda—Technological innovations. | Zuckerberg, Mark, 1984– —Influence. | United States—Politics and government. Classification: LCC HM743.F33 (ebook) | LCC HM743.F33 M347 2019 (print
…
. When content is coming from like-minded family, friends, or Groups, we tend to relax our vigilance, which is one of the reasons why disinformation spreads so effectively on Facebook. Giving users what they want sounds like a great idea, but it has at least one unfortunate by-product: filter
…
not create preference bubbles, but it is the ideal incubator for them. The algorithms ensure that users who like one piece of disinformation will be fed more disinformation. Fed enough disinformation, users will eventually wind up first in a filter bubble and then in a preference bubble. If you are a bad actor
…
them. Research suggests that people who accept one conspiracy theory have a high likelihood of accepting a second one. The same is true of inflammatory disinformation. None of this was known to me when I joined forces with Tristan. In combination with the events I had observed in 2016, Tristan’
…
many billion people have the critics connected?—much less to reconsider the way they do business. As a result, when confronted with evidence that disinformation and fake news spread over Facebook influenced the Brexit referendum in the United Kingdom and a presidential election in the United States, Facebook took steps
…
is that family, friends, and Groups are the foundational elements of filter and preference bubbles. Whether by design or by accident, they share the very disinformation and fake news that Facebook would like to suppress. * * * — AS TRISTAN DESCRIBES IT, and Fogg teaches it, there are ten tools that platforms use
…
each reflecting the unique architecture and culture of the platform. The interplay of platforms also favors bad actors. They can incubate pranks, conspiracy theories, and disinformation in fringe sites like 4chan, 8chan, and Reddit, which are home to some of the most extreme voices on the internet, jump to Twitter to
…
were committed to polarizing Americans over social media. What else had the Russians done? What if Russia had run an entire campaign of discord and disinformation over social media? What would the goals have been of a Russian social media campaign? We hypothesized that the campaign must have started no
…
seemed likely to us that the Russian interference would have been most effective during the Republican primary. The Russians had been inflaming Groups and spreading disinformation about polarizing topics for more than a year when the candidates began running for president. All but one of the seventeen candidates ran on
…
There are millions of Groups on Facebook, for just about every organization, personality, politician, brand, sport, philosophy, and idea. The ones built around extreme ideas—disinformation, fake news, conspiracy theories, hate speech—become filter bubbles, reinforcing the shared value, intensifying emotional attachments to it. Thanks to Groups and filter bubbles, inflammatory
…
on how conspiracy theories spread over the internet. In her day job, as director of research at New Knowledge, Renée helps companies protect themselves from disinformation, character assassination, and smear attacks, the kind of tactics the Russians used in 2016. New Knowledge also created Hamilton 68, the public dashboard that
…
tracks Russian disinformation on Twitter. Sponsored by the German Marshall Fund and introduced on August 2, 2017, Hamilton 68 enables anyone to track what pro-Kremlin Twitter accounts
…
the Capitol. The conversation turned to our hypotheses and what they implied for future elections. Renée characterized techniques the Russians may have used to spread disinformation on social media. The Russians’ job was made easier by the thriving communities of libertarians and contrarians on the internet. They almost certainly focused on
…
stories in play at any time, a handful of which attract enough support to go viral. For the Russians, any time a piece of disinformation gained traction, they would seed one or more websites with a document that appeared to be a legitimate news story about the topic. Then they
…
share it. Recipients assume the story has been vetted by members of a shared political framework, so they share it, too. In this way, disinformation and conspiracy theories can gain traction quickly. The Russians used this technique to interfere in the 2016 election. They also organized events. A particularly well
…
vote for Clinton in 2016 may reflect to some degree the effectiveness of the Russian interference. How many of those stayed away because of Russian disinformation about Clinton’s email server, the Clinton Foundation, Pizzagate, and other issues? CNN reported that the Russians ran a number of Facebook Groups targeting
…
Media companies must work with them on their terms. Yet the internet monopolies do not acknowledge responsibility for the content on their site, which allows disinformation to flourish. Active users lose the ability to separate fact from fiction, making them vulnerable to manipulation. Soros emphasized the potential threat to democracy of
…
Facebook’s decision in May 2016 to replace human curators with algorithms proved to be a disaster. Far-right voices gamed the algorithm effectively, and disinformation dominated Trending Stories, just in time to amplify the Clinton email server story. Whether or not the changes to News Feed were another attempt to
…
Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter by name and underscored the ease with which the Russians had exploited the architecture and algorithms of social platforms to spread disinformation and suppress votes. The story landed like a bombshell. As a bonus, the world got a peek into Facebook’s culture, thanks to a
…
user data in that country. Even when news reports dealt with another tech platform—as was the case when journalists revealed that Russian bots promoted disinformation on Twitter in the wake of the school shooting in Parkland, Florida—Facebook’s reputation took a hit. Finally, a virtual-reality shooting game
…
from social media. Science magazine published a study conducted by professors at MIT of every controversial story in English on Twitter. It revealed that disinformation and fake news are shared 70 percent more often than factual stories and spread roughly six times faster. The study noted that bots share facts
…
and disinformation roughly equally, suggesting that it is humans who prefer to share falsehoods. No one claimed that the problem might be confined to Twitter. The
…
side of social networks may be systemic, driven by design choices that favor some of the worst aspects of human behavior. As if on cue, disinformation spread by Infowars about bombing suspects in Austin, Texas, reached the top of the charts on YouTube. YouTube responded to this failure in moderation
…
by trying to pass the buck to Wikipedia, which it claimed would debunk disinformation. When I checked with Katherine Maher, the executive director of Wikipedia, that day, I learned that YouTube had made the announcement without first speaking
…
, they had little, if any, exposure to journalism and no preparation for social media. Their citizens did not have filters for the kind of disinformation shared on internet platforms. An idea that sounded worthy to people in the US, Free Basics has been more dangerous than I suspect its creators
…
well as a new initiative to anticipate interference rather than waiting for users to report it. While the announcement included a new program to target disinformation, the change to News Feed in January that reduced the weight of journalistic sources almost certainly made at least one aspect of preventing interference—
…
child pornography, Facebook has avoided judging the content on its site. This policy had the effect of enabling high-engagement content like conspiracy theories and disinformation to flourish, with significant benefits to profitability. A hypothesis emerged that Apple’s announcement—which had preceded the other two by a matter of hours
…
Dorsey, at a Congressional hearing. One might reasonably conclude that the internet platforms do not want to damage their business models by banning conspiracy theories, disinformation, and hate speech, unless it becomes politically impossible not to. Later in August, The New York Times reported that Facebook deleted more than 652 fake
…
advantage of that trust to surveil our every action online, to monetize personal data. In the process they have fostered hate speech, conspiracy theories, and disinformation, and enabled interference in elections. They have artificially inflated their profits by shirking civic responsibility. The platforms have damaged public health, undermined democracy, violated user
…
speech, in part because of constraints imposed by other corporate priorities. We have asked the platforms politely to fix their problems with hate speech and disinformation. Now is the time for stronger measures. I will go into this in depth in chapter 13. Eighth, the culture, business model, and practices
…
who to trust, or acting in their own interest. Bad actors have had a field day exploiting Google and Facebook, leveraging user trust to spread disinformation and hate speech, to suppress voting, and to polarize citizens in many countries. They will continue to do so until we, in our role
…
users and their friends but then magnified by algorithms to promote engagement. In the same vein, Facebook’s algorithms promote extreme messages over neutral ones, disinformation over information, conspiracy theories over facts. Every user has a unique News Feed and potentially a unique set of “facts.” Like-minded people can
…
mistakes. And then there is the impact of Truman Shows and filter bubbles, the primary consequence of which seems to be polarization. As amplifiers of disinformation and hate speech, Facebook, Google, and Twitter have effectively abridged the rights of the peaceful to benefit the angry. The persecution of the Rohingya
…
security consultant for the FBI, framed it this way in an email to me: “Many will project the past onto the future, expecting Russian disinformation to again seek to influence US elections. The Kremlin, rather than being the dominant social media manipulator globally, will be one of many seeking to
…
data to crush competitors. Google’s most glaring problems are in YouTube, which offers a triple-header of harm: the Kids channel, the promotion of disinformation, and the recruiting/training of extremists. For whatever reason, Google has not been able to fix any of these problems. Were it not for
…
to discourage new filter bubbles, what could it do about the ones that already exist? What can Facebook do about the fact that humans prefer disinformation to information? What can it do about the sorry state of civics education? It cannot solve all these problems, but it can reduce their
…
. Technology will continue to evolve, as will the tactics used by bad actors to exploit it. In particular, I worry about the spread of disinformation videos, including deep fakes. I worry about voter suppression of millennials over Instagram. The concern is magnified by the widespread misperception among users that Instagram
…
our democratic processes instead of undermining them. Revealing the sponsors for political ads was an important first step, and Facebook took it. Facebook then removed disinformation pages that appear to have been sponsored by Russia and Iran. It hired security experts. But so far Facebook has resisted fundamental change. The
…
company must do heavy lifting at the algorithm level to ensure that disinformation and fake news do not dominate the information sphere as they did in 2016. It owes the world its best effort to prioritize facts over
…
dividends in the future. I would spin off YouTube to shareholders, as that would create a more powerful incentive to reduce the threat from disinformation and extremism. Google does not seem to understand that the primary reason its users and policy makers are not up in arms is because Facebook
…
safe. Smartphones and internet platforms are designed to grab your attention and hold it. Facebook, YouTube, and other platforms are filled with conspiracy theories, disinformation, and fake news disguised as fact. Facebook and YouTube profit from outrage, and their algorithms are good at promoting it. Even if the outrage triggers
…
will test buyers’ trust in Facebook. In the two months before the midterms, Facebook ramped up its efforts to limit the impact of foreign interference, disinformation, and other forms of subterfuge. The company opened a “war room” to demonstrate its commitment and introduced tools to protect political campaigns and their
…
countries, 179–80, 233 Diamond, Larry, 243 Diana, Elisabeth, 231–32 Digital Equipment, 46, 152 DiResta, Renée, 92–93, 121–23, 127, 128, 146, 242 disinformation and fake news, 94–96, 117, 123, 173, 229, 233, 234, 237, 253, 257–58, 260, 274 on Facebook, 89, 94–96, 119, 159,
…
service, 207, 218 deactivating account, 99 decision making and organization of, 144–45, 154, 155, 160 democracy threatened by, 242–45, 258, 278, 280, 281 disinformation on, 89, 94–96, 119, 159, 165, 166, 208–9, 228, 243, 245, 258, 270, 281 early days of, 16–17 earnings in 2018,
…
Zuckerberg’s plan for addressing problems with, 158–59 Facemash, 53, 60 fact-checking, 103, 178, 179 Fair Housing Act, 11, 245 fake news, see disinformation and fake news FarmVille, 184, 195, 196 Fast Company, 53 FBI, 209, 252 fear of missing out (FOMO), 98, 99, 253, 269 Federal Communications
…
95, 102, 106, 110, 125, 183–84, 195, 233–35, 238–39, 243–45, 253, 256, 270, 278, 282, 283 Congress and, 122, 127–33 disinformation on, 177 fake accounts on, 265 Goldman’s tweets, 169–73 Jones and Infowars and, 228–29 Russia and, 121–24, 131, 169, 174 words
…
128, 156, 214, 223, 232, 235, 238–39, 242, 244, 260, 274, 279, 281 advertising and, 103, 283–84 algorithms of, 92–93, 139, 274 disinformation on, 177–78 Google and, 104, 139, 253, 261 Jones and Infowars and, 228–29 Zittrain, Jonathan, 226 Zuckerberg, Mark, 3, 16, 53–79, 141
by Peter Geoghegan · 2 Jan 2020 · 388pp · 111,099 words
to push the boundaries as far as they will go, and beyond. Donald Trump was elected US president in 2016 after a campaign marred by disinformation and electoral interference. Far from being an aberration, dirty politics is the new normal. What’s so bad about political campaigns not declaring the source
…
, and accentuates the risk of the public sphere being captured by vested interests. Dark money has gone hand-in-hand with the rise of digital disinformation. It is a truism that politics has been transformed in recent years. But it is not just the outcomes, the election of disruptive authoritarian populists
…
Britain. Once again, we will find laws that are hopelessly out of date in the digital age. We will delve into the world of online disinformation, meeting some of the people behind the online news sites that push populist messages across the Internet. We will chart the rise of Europe’s
…
-funded pro-Johnson ads flooded social media. Conservative Party sources routinely lied to journalists. Many saw the spirit of Dominic Cummings behind the onslaught of disinformation. Having vowed to “deliver Brexit” in government, Cummings was credited with instigating Boris Johnson’s controversial decision to suspend Parliament in August 2019 in an
…
playing on their fears around migrants coming to Britain. “Fear is such a powerful driving emotion, especially online,” says Claire Wardle, an expert in digital disinformation. Unlike in traditional campaigns, Vote Leave’s emotive images were not seen on posters or buses. They appeared privately, on people’s social media feeds
…
staff at Facebook and Cambridge Analytica had been brought before Collins’s committee. The inquiry initially began as a bipartisan examination of the spread of disinformation, inspired by the efforts in Washington of Democratic senator Mark Warner and his Republican counterpart Richard Burr to understand the role of Russia in the
…
.” In December 2019, Boris Johnson won a general election landslide. The campaign was a ramped-up reprise of Vote Leave. There were dubious claims and disinformation, anonymous adverts on social media and incessant lying. Journalists who asked awkward questions were sidelined. On the morning after the vote, Dominic Cummings stood smiling
…
team of journalists focused on social media. Endless fact-checks corrected the record. But they were a finger in the dyke against a flood of disinformation. Conspiracy theories swirled, in some cases actively encouraged by political parties. In Britain, as in many other countries, digital politics has become a chaotic void
…
the digital age,” he said. But even if the way politicians spend money online was circumscribed, would it stem the rising tide of lies and disinformation? Voters themselves are already conduits for mistruths and falsehoods. Tighter constraints on parties would also do little to stop another growing source of online interference
…
I asked why, almost all listed the same concern: “Emails.” Few offered more detail than that. The 2016 US presidential election also showed how online disinformation can be used not just to support a particular candidate, but also to sow discord and chaos. While the Kremlin weighed in on Trump’s
…
, often creates a false equivalence between facts and lies is as much a boon for populists and political snake oil sellers as dark money and disinformation. The shift to high-octane, 24/7 reporting has made it easier for those in power to manipulate journalistic conventions. Almost as soon as Boris
…
than a melee of Labour protesters, there were only half a dozen people and no punches had been thrown. The journalists who had amplified this disinformation apologised for their mistake, but it was too late. The dead cat had become the story. Journalists have struggled to react to this rising tide
…
advance, however, is also undergirded by networks of dark money and hidden influence, much as we have seen in Britain. Armies of digital supporters spread disinformation across the borderless Internet. Electoral rules, where they exist, are there to be broken. Europe’s populists often share similar campaigning styles and talking points
…
support of Russia’s annexation of Crimea, is closely aligned with Vladimir Putin. The billionaire businessman’s television station spreads a conservative message laced with disinformation. Frequent guests on his programmes include influential Putin acolyte Aleksandr Dugin, a neo-fascist thinker and proponent of ‘Eurasianism’ – a dream of a revived Russian
…
half million pro-Vox and anti-Islamic tweets.63 They often published identical posts that were designed to look spontaneous but were in fact coordinated disinformation. In one instance, a raft of pro-Vox accounts tweeted images of a riot said to be happening in a Muslim district in France. The
…
news and outraged headlines that could then be pumped into hypercharged, conspiratorial echo chambers.”64 Many of Vox’s digital echo chambers pushed religiously tinged disinformation. Muslims wanted to take Spain back to the time of the Moors. Leftists were encouraging children to have abortions. Highly emotive messages about moral issues
…
– especially those that spark feelings of fear – are a particularly effective way to spread disinformation. Similar tactics were used during the 2016 presidential election, when pro-Kremlin accounts appealed directly to Christian fundamentalists by sharing images that showed Hillary Clinton
…
horns protruding, arm-wrestling with Jesus.65 Religion, as digital expert Claire Wardle explained to me, “is one of the best ways to spread disinformation online.” * Digital disinformation and wealthy foreign donors are not the only sources of electoral interference. States often meddle in each other’s politics. Between 1946 and 1989
…
competing with other parties for control of Italy’s democratic institutions. We don’t have to look far, however, to find a European state where disinformation and targeted influence campaigns have already created a much more solidly grounded ‘illiberal democracy’. * In late 2017, I arrived in an icy Budapest to give
…
a much wider political project, to support authoritarian societies led by ‘strongmen’.” * As this book has looked primarily at the effect of dark money and disinformation on Britain, this chapter has focused on examples of the nativist surge in some of the UK’s European neighbours: Italy, Spain and Hungary. In
…
all three, nationalist appeals to religion and identity have been underpinned by international networks of political influence and digital disinformation. The effects of this can be seen most dramatically in Hungary, where Viktor Orbán has shown how quickly supposedly liberal democratic norms and conventions can
…
transparent, and accountable to citizens. What, if anything, can be done to reverse the crisis in democracy? Can we halt the seemingly unstoppable rise of disinformation and dirty politics? Or has democracy already gone dark? * The princess is also close to Hillary Clinton and was one of about a dozen women
…
from academics and policy wonks to the chair of the Electoral Commission, warned that the country’s democratic process was failing. The biggest source of disinformation “is the governing party, and they are the ones charged with changing the law”, said Will Moy, chief executive of Full Fact, an independent fact
…
being bought have been rendered obsolete when huge sums can be spent outside regulated periods, or by super Pac-style campaign surrogates. Politicians wilfully spread disinformation. We are being targeted online in ways that we cannot fully understand, partly because campaigns and tech platforms have to disclose so little about how
…
as the cost of doing business. * British politics, of course, is not alone in becoming increasingly Americanised. The global nexus of dark money and political disinformation that we have seen is part of an escalating war against the basic tenets of democracy. Nationalists and xenophobes from Italy to Hungary have tapped
…
, including the UK. Electoral interference is likely to get worse, not better. So how will we respond to the growing crisis of dark money and disinformation? Will we all sit back and mutely watch it unfold, complaining bitterly on social media but struggling, atomised, to find avenues to channel our anger
…
closed, another quickly opens up. The third, and biggest, obstacle to meaningful democratic reform is the political class itself. As long as politicians think that disinformation wins elections, dirty habits are unlikely to change. Not only are the fines for breaking the rules of our democracy meagre; funding politics through anonymous
…
donations and spreading disinformation seems to come at little political or reputational cost. In 2019, the Conservatives faced no electoral comeback for ‘shit-posting’ on social media, lying with
…
’t. Occasional protests outside the headquarters of tech giants hint at growing frustrations, but where are the mass movements needed to push dark money and disinformation from a niche concern to the top of the political agenda? If proven law-breaking – as in the Brexit referendum – and obvious electoral manipulation is
…
insisted that concerns about the effect of tech monopolies on democracy are overstated. Zuckerberg’s platform has introduced changes aimed at limiting the spread of disinformation. Doubtless Facebook will launch more initiatives. But promises have been made before and have failed to deliver. Meanwhile, digital influence campaigns are already migrating to
…
while dismantling the modern-day equivalent of the railroad monopolies might help, it’s not clear how such a move would stem the flow of disinformation, especially on the closed groups and anonymous forums from which armies of online trolls are feeding a populist surge across the world. There have been
…
of personal data with companies across the Internet. Tim Berners-Lee, the founder of the World Wide Web, has warned of a “digital dystopia” if disinformation and invasion of privacy are not stopped. In 2019, dozens of tech companies including Facebook and Google signed Berners-Lee’s ‘Contract for the Web
…
. Like the climate, democracy is fast reaching a tipping point. If the opportunity for change is not seized, the worst aspects of the present malaise – disinformation, dark money and spiralling polarisation – could well push us beyond a point of no return. It is not too late. I am still an optimist
…
never have been possible without the tireless team at openDemocracy and, in particular, Mary Fitzgerald, who realised early on the importance of dark money and disinformation in British politics and has been prepared to fight tooth-and-nail to tell many of the stories in this book. She has been my
…
Sport Committee, ‘Fake News’, House of Commons, June 2018. See also http://data.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/committeeevidence.svc/evidencedocument/digital-culture-media-and-sport-committee/disinformation-and-fake-news/oral/85344.html; accessed 19 Jan. 2020. 3 Ed Caesar, ‘The Chaotic Triumph of Arron Banks, the “Bad Boy of Brexit”’, New
…
Sport Committee, ‘Fake News’, House of Commons, June 2018. See also http://data.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/committeeevidence.svc/evidencedocument/digital-culture-media-and-sport-committee/disinformation-and-fake-news/oral/85344.html; accessed 19 Jan. 2020. 94 Peter Geoghegan and Jenna Corderoy, ‘Arron Banks lied to Parliament about his Brexit campaign
…
Sport Committee, ‘Fake News’, House of Commons, May 2018. See also http://data.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/committeeevidence.svc/evidencedocument/digital-culture-media-and-sport-committee/disinformation-and-fake-news/oral/82471.html; accessed 20 Jan. 2020. 24 Peter Geoghegan and Jenna Corderoy, ‘How the Electoral Commission turned blind eye to DUP
…
/culture-media-and-sport/181126-Correspondence-between-Richard-Cook-CRC-and-the-Chair.pdf; accessed 20 Jan. 2020. 43 Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee, ‘Disinformation and “fake news”: Final Report’, House of Commons, February 2019. See also https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmcumeds/1791/179112.htm; accessed 20
…
Leave staffer is running Facebook ads pushing the Greens’, Wired, November 2019. 56 Peter Geoghegan, ‘Revealed: Former Vote Leave data chief accused of pro-Tory “disinformation”’, openDemocracy, November 2019. 57 Jemima Kelly, Cynthia O’Murchu and David Blood, ‘Voters left in the dark over money behind online election ads’, Financial Times
…
2019. See also https://about.fb.com/news/2019/09/elections-and-political-speech/; accessed 26 Jan. 2020. 70 Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee, ‘Disinformation and “fake news”: Final Report published’, House of Commons, February 2019. See also www.parliament.uk/business/committees/committees-a-z/commons-select/digital-culture
…
”: Explosive new tapes reveal Cambridge Analytica CEO’s boasts of voter suppression, manipulation and bribery’, openDemocracy, January 2019. 73 Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee, ‘Disinformation and “fake news”: Final Report published’, House of Commons, February 2019. See also https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmcumeds/1791/179107.htm; accessed
…
-behind-macedonias-fake-news-sites; accessed 26 Jan. 2020. 51 Rob Faris, Hal Roberts, Bruce Etling, Nikki Bourassa, Ethan Zuckerman and Yochai Benkler, ‘Partisanship, Propaganda, & Disinformation: Online Media & the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election’, Berkman Klein Center for Internet & Society at Harvard University, August 2017. See also https://cyber.harvard.edu
by Christopher Wylie · 8 Oct 2019
of documents I provided to law enforcement revealed that the Vote Leave campaign had used secret Cambridge Analytica subsidiaries to spend dark money to propagate disinformation on Facebook and Google ad networks. This was determined to be illegal by the U.K.’s Electoral Commission, with the scheme ending up as
…
all wanted to talk to me. Within weeks, the European Union and more than twenty countries had opened up inquiries into Facebook, social media, and disinformation. I told my story to the world, and now every screen was a mirror reflecting it back at me. For two weeks straight, my life
…
narratives and virtual realities. Cambridge Analytica first piloted this new warfare in Africa and tropical islands around the world. The firm experimented with scaled online disinformation, fake news, and mass profiling. It worked with Russian agents and employed hackers to break into opposition candidates’ email accounts. Soon enough, having perfected its
…
-harvesting operation. This material demonstrated that the company had recruited hackers, hired personnel with known links to Russian intelligence, and engaged in bribery, extortion, and disinformation campaigns in elections around the world. There were confidential legal memos from lawyers warning Steve Bannon about Cambridge Analytica’s violations of the Foreign Agents
…
planting fake battle plans on a corpse dressed as a dead soldier in the fantastically named Operation Mincemeat. The well-designed use of information—and disinformation—is one of the most effective ways of gaining tactical advantage on the battlefield. In devising an informational weapon, it’s helpful to think of
…
Europe for NATO on counter–Russian propaganda initiatives. One was for a counter-narcotics program in a Latin American country, where a military client spread disinformation to turn local coca farmers against drug lords. Others detailed PSYOPS programs in Mexico and Kenya. As Nix had said before, these were projects that
…
that it would turn into something valuable. What few people know, however, is the story of who became Cambridge Analytica’s very first target of disinformation. Back when Bannon and I first met, he had rejected going to a private club on Pall Mall, preferring to meet in Cambridge. Nix clocked
…
its counterinsurgency operations in other parts of the world. It is unclear who inside the firm actually gave the final order to set up these disinformation operations, but for many of the old guard who had spent years working on projects around the world, none of this seemed unusual. They were
…
if I asked too many questions that he didn’t care for. But at the time, in spring 2014, just two years before any Russian disinformation efforts hit the U.S. presidential election, there wasn’t anything innately suspicious about these Russians beyond the typical bread-and-butter shadiness that the
…
what the firm, at least in theory, was capable of setting up were there to be a project that needed special intelligence services or scaled disinformation operations on social media. (As the memo was internal, it referenced SCL; Cambridge Analytica was merely a front-facing brand for American clients that was
…
build credibility and cultivate followers.” For many of SCL’s clients, this was a standard offer—private espionage, stings, bribes, extortion, infiltrations, honey traps, and disinformation spread through fake accounts on social media. For the right price, SCL was willing to do whatever it took to win an election. And now
…
outlined an SCL project in Nigeria aimed at undermining voters’ confidence in civic institutions. Labeled “Election: Inoculation,” the material described how to spread rumors and disinformation to sway election results. Nix played videos of emotional voters convinced that the upcoming Nigerian election would be rigged. “We made them think that,” he
…
the United States want access to our U.S. data assets? And if this was a commercial project, why was Alexander showing them slides about disinformation in Africa? But it wasn’t simply the internal data assets that were shown to the firm’s clients. The firm was eager to show
…
their opponent, including a concerted effort to leak rumors about the opposing candidate’s health. And this stolen kompromat was then combined with widespread online disinformation targeting social media networks. The overlap in events could be entirely coincidental, but many of the personnel who worked on Nigeria also worked on CA
…
system of constitutionally protected free speech, and the U.S. government did nothing to stop them. Neither did Facebook. Was Cambridge Analytica involved in Russian disinformation efforts in the United States? No one can say for sure, and there’s no single “smoking gun” proving that Cambridge Analytica was the culprit
…
other CIS countries; memos referenced ex–Russian security services; and we have Alexander Nix telling Lukoil about Cambridge Analytica’s U.S. data sets and disinformation capacity. When I had lunch with Nix to tell him I was quitting, he was clear about how he thought things would play out. “The
…
, more than a year after it first identified the issue, and seven months after beginning to investigate what was called a “five-alarm fire” of disinformation spreading on its site.) Ultimately, between the Democrats’ indifference to the threat and Silicon Valley’s inability to understand how to solve a problem without
…
(DCMS), at his office in Portcullis House, a modern glass building on the Parliamentary Estate. Collins had opened up an official inquiry into social media disinformation, and several MPs and committee chairs I’d talked with had recommended that I meet with him. Collins was extremely polite and posh and spoke
…
regulatory investigation.” The reaction on both sides of the Atlantic was instant and explosive. I was called before the parliamentary inquiry into “fake news and disinformation.” It would be the first of many public and secret hearings, covering everything from Cambridge Analytica’s use of hackers and bribes to Facebook’s
…
addicted to rage only because there was nothing to prevent it from doing so—and so, unimpeded, the company drowned them in a maelstrom of disinformation, with predictably disastrous results. But simply stopping CA is not enough. America’s newfound crisis of perception will only continue to worsen until we address
…
commit acts of hatred and, in some cases, acts of extreme violence. There is no such thing as “just online” anymore, and online information—or disinformation—that engages its targets can lead to horrific tragedies. In response, Facebook, like the NRA, evades its moral responsibility by invoking the same kind of
…
, liking, and sharing. Americans on Facebook did the Russians’ work for them, laundering their propaganda through the First Amendment. But this new era of scaled disinformation is not confined to the realm of politics. Companies like Starbucks, Nike, and other fashion brands have found themselves targets of Russian-sponsored
…
disinformation operations. When brands make statements that wade into existing social or racial tensions, there have been several identified instances in which Russian-sponsored fake news
…
could in turn create “real” footage showcasing a racist trope of an “angry black man” demanding free stuff in a store. So why would these disinformation operations target a fashion company and attempt to weaponize its brand? Because the objective of this hostile propaganda is not simply to interfere with our
…
the British Parliament, thank you for being some of the loudest voices for holding Silicon Valley to account. Your nonpartisan collaboration on the inquiry into disinformation and “fake news” put the public interest first, and you all set a shining example of how politics should be done. By working together, your
by Ben Rhodes · 1 Jun 2021 · 342pp · 114,118 words
hopeful, the unifying allure of the Internet and social media segmented people back into lonely tribes where they could be more easily manipulated by propaganda, disinformation, and conspiracy theory. Somehow, after three decades of unchecked American capitalism, military power, and technological innovation, the currents of history had turned against democracy itself
…
that could easily be repurposed to target an available Other in country after country. How the spread of social media had unleashed a flood of disinformation that undermined democracy while offering autocrats ever more powerful tools of social and political control. I saw this most clearly in three countries that were
…
a world where nationalism ran amok. Her own journey—from democracy icon to tacit collaborator in brutality fueled by Buddhist nationalism and rampant anti-Rohingya disinformation on Facebook—didn’t cut against the currents of history, it drifted in the wake of events in the wider world. In April 2017, I
…
independence of the rule of law. Keep big business on your side with low taxes and favorable treatment. Demonize your political opponents through social media disinformation. Attack civil society as a tool of George Soros. Cast yourself as the sole legitimate defender of national security. Wrap the whole project in a
…
opinion within right-wing media were turbocharged by the sharing of information on social media, chiefly Facebook, which profits off the clicks that anger and disinformation generate. Profit-driven social media algorithms, like unchecked political contributions, were treated as free speech beyond the reach of government regulation. Election laws were changed
…
real estate—the developers who remake an old Budapest neighborhood, or put up glass towers in New York. It can also be used to mount disinformation campaigns against your opponents, or to hire private espionage companies to discredit them. This is the cold reality of how power and wealth interact; if
…
America’s weakness in the same way that America once exploited the Soviet Union’s. In this case, a Facebook culture that monetized division and disinformation, media that gleefully reported on stolen emails and gossip as news, a Republican Party that had more in common with Vladimir Putin’s worldview than
…
. Wasn’t that, in a way, how the Cold War had reached its peaceful end? Now that melody was silenced, replaced with the cacophony of disinformation, a chorus of bots relentlessly hitting discordant notes on behalf of men like Orban, Putin, and Trump. And underneath that noise, there are the individual
…
; propaganda has been around as long as politics. But perhaps it was the start of something: the brute force of a new kind of Russian disinformation campaign, intent on destroying anyone who posed a danger to the new, corrupt order of things. * * * — The 1990s were a chaotic time for Russians. The
…
later, just before I left Washington, I had coffee with a journalist who had spent a lot of time looking at Russia’s use of disinformation. I described how it had taken years for me to understand the psychological toll that came from a daily bombardment of messages on social media
…
at all this, it was hard for me not to think of the rampant conspiracy theories that have infected American politics, often amplified by Russian disinformation. Of course those with power would want to make people think that their opponents are all part of the same game. He laughed at the
…
opaque corporations facilitated by a poorly regulated global economy, to the service industry that profits by running interference for the wealthy and powerful, be it disinformation campaigns, private espionage, or the occasional act of violence. Seeing all that, you can either decide, rationally, to dive into the system—as I had
…
of the dark openings in American politics and culture, particularly online, where a vast industry of right-wing conspiracy theories had created a market for disinformation. We were an easy mark. Perhaps nothing in my lifetime symbolizes the triumph and spread of American-led globalization more than the Internet and social
…
I was asking her the same question. I had my own views about social media, about the need for regulation to slow the spread of disinformation and make companies liable for hateful content on their platforms. But how could we overcome the more fundamental crisis of identity that made all of
…
Dostoyevsky and Tolstoy, that once saved Europe from fascism and sent the first satellite into space, now exports a toxic stew of conspiracy theories and disinformation that will make as little sense to people in the future as it does to anyone living in reality today. Even in the games of
…
—the misadventures of Russian intelligence agents and Trump associates, the hacking of emails whose contents seemed sensational at the time and feel meaningless today, the disinformation that could feel like a drop in the ocean of our own toxic national discourse. “We were,” Adam said, “ripe for exploitation.” He checked his
…
media wasn’t simply a threat. It could be controlled with the right firewall, and it was also a nearly ideal tool for surveillance and disinformation. Within China’s Golden Shield program, the Party monitored Internet activity within China and blocked more sensitive keywords from Internet users. Emerging Chinese tech companies
…
.” This goes far beyond the mixed authoritarianism of Hungary or the more traditional repression in Russia, where technology can be a tool of surveillance and disinformation but not achieve total social control. “This is a new model of authoritarianism,” Maya told me. “Almost all authoritarian leaders eventually face the [people’s
…
the Brotherhood in a more pragmatic direction. Then the Saudis and Emiratis started pouring money into the country—paying protesters against the Morsi government, funding disinformation campaigns against the United States, casting America as a dangerous ally of the Islamists. In July 2013, Morsi was ousted in a coup led by
…
popular mobilization to authoritarian mobilization, from revolution to counterrevolution. Even the technologies that had seemed so promising were reverse engineered and turned into means of disinformation and suppression. Mohamed went back into the streets to protest. “I didn’t mind if Morsi left through a democratic mechanism,” he said. “But I
…
ads). Elevating conspiracy theories and partisan vitriol that traveled faster and farther through its algorithm (and selling ads). Serving as an open vessel for Russian disinformation that tore down Clinton and elevated Trump (and selling ads). Collecting massive amounts of users’ data, which was in turn used to build a more
…
that radicalized American foreign policy and politics. We couldn’t control the accelerating disruptions emanating from social media platforms that were killing traditional media, spreading disinformation, and hermetically sealing Americans inside information ecosystems. But I found it hard to see what Obama could have done to achieve fundamental change—particularly in
…
right-wing trolls who’d used my every utterance about Benghazi over the years to advance the projection that I was a villainous liar spreading disinformation. In the morning, a cheerful middle-aged woman who made breakfast and looked after the place for the owners was intent on making conversation. I
…
going to take a collective effort by many tens of millions of people. While Trump and Republicans across the country bombarded the body politic with disinformation and tried to make it more difficult to vote through myriad means, with tactics that too many Americans refuse to see as the common machinery
…
that our technological innovations were ushering us into a utopian age of connectivity without anticipating what else those technologies could do—the flood of Russian disinformation on American social media, the totalitarianism of China’s social credit system, or the conspiracy theories that could make masses of Americans believe just about
by Mustafa Suleyman · 4 Sep 2023 · 444pp · 117,770 words
by James Ball · 19 Jul 2023 · 317pp · 87,048 words
by Brad Smith and Carol Ann Browne · 9 Sep 2019 · 482pp · 121,173 words
by Jacob Helberg · 11 Oct 2021 · 521pp · 118,183 words
by Peter Warren Singer and Emerson T. Brooking · 15 Mar 2018
by Max Fisher · 5 Sep 2022 · 439pp · 131,081 words
by Henry A Kissinger, Eric Schmidt and Daniel Huttenlocher · 2 Nov 2021 · 194pp · 57,434 words
by Jonathan Rauch · 21 Jun 2021 · 446pp · 109,157 words
by Nicole Perlroth · 9 Feb 2021 · 651pp · 186,130 words
by Annalee Newitz · 3 Jun 2024 · 251pp · 68,713 words
by Naomi Klein · 11 Sep 2023
by Shoshana Zuboff · 15 Jan 2019 · 918pp · 257,605 words
by Lee McIntyre · 14 Sep 2021 · 407pp · 108,030 words
by Stephen Macedo and Frances Lee · 10 Mar 2025 · 393pp · 146,371 words
by Robert Service · 7 Oct 2015
by Zeynep Tufekci · 14 May 2017 · 444pp · 130,646 words
by Colin Kahl and Thomas Wright · 23 Aug 2021 · 652pp · 172,428 words
by Jacob Siegel · 24 Mar 2026 · 348pp · 103,246 words
by Azeem Azhar · 6 Sep 2021 · 447pp · 111,991 words
by Paul Scharre · 18 Jan 2023
by Rob Reich, Mehran Sahami and Jeremy M. Weinstein · 6 Sep 2021
by Bill Browder · 11 Apr 2022 · 335pp · 100,154 words
by Mollie Hemingway · 11 Oct 2021 · 595pp · 143,394 words
by Jesselyn Cook · 22 Jul 2024 · 321pp · 95,778 words
by Yuval Noah Harari · 9 Sep 2024 · 566pp · 169,013 words
by Tom Rosenstiel · 17 Aug 2026 · 400pp · 107,776 words
by Julia Ebner · 20 Feb 2020 · 309pp · 79,414 words
by Amy B. Zegart · 6 Nov 2021
by Michiko Kakutani · 17 Jul 2018 · 137pp · 38,925 words
by Sinan Aral · 14 Sep 2020 · 475pp · 134,707 words
by Christopher Andrew · 2 Aug 2010 · 1,744pp · 458,385 words
by Eliot Higgins · 2 Mar 2021 · 277pp · 70,506 words
by Bruce Schneier · 7 Feb 2023 · 306pp · 82,909 words
by William Blum · 15 Jan 2003
by Elizabeth Williamson · 8 Mar 2022 · 574pp · 148,233 words
by Michiko Kakutani · 20 Feb 2024 · 262pp · 69,328 words
by Jonathan Haslam · 21 Sep 2015 · 525pp · 131,496 words
by Clint Watts · 28 May 2018 · 324pp · 96,491 words
by Kate Conger and Ryan Mac · 17 Sep 2024
by Ian Dunt · 15 Oct 2020
by Jeff Berwick and Charlie Robinson · 14 Apr 2020 · 491pp · 141,690 words
by Joseph Romm · 3 Dec 2015 · 358pp · 93,969 words
by Richard Kluger · 1 Jan 1996 · 1,157pp · 379,558 words
by Robert C. Martin · 1 Jan 2007 · 462pp · 172,671 words
by Dr. Paul Babiak and Dr. Robert Hare · 7 May 2007 · 345pp · 100,135 words
by Christopher Andrew · 27 Jun 2018
by Jevin D. West and Carl T. Bergstrom · 3 Aug 2020
by Daniel C. Dennett · 7 Feb 2017 · 573pp · 157,767 words
by Noam Chomsky · 1 Sep 1995
by Mark Hertsgaard · 15 Jan 2011 · 326pp · 48,727 words
by Kelly Weill · 22 Feb 2022
by Nellie Bowles · 13 May 2024 · 207pp · 62,397 words
by Matthew Williams · 23 Mar 2021 · 592pp · 125,186 words
by Ronen Bergman · 30 Jan 2018 · 1,071pp · 295,220 words
by Ben Buchanan · 25 Feb 2020 · 443pp · 116,832 words
by Ben Shapiro · 26 Jul 2021 · 309pp · 81,243 words
by Noam Chomsky · 7 Apr 2015
by Eric Berkowitz · 3 May 2021 · 412pp · 115,048 words
by Zoë Schiffer · 13 Feb 2024 · 343pp · 92,693 words
by Sergei Kostin and Eric Raynaud · 14 Apr 2011 · 485pp · 148,662 words
by Tim Berners-Lee · 8 Sep 2025 · 347pp · 100,038 words
by Barrett Brown · 8 Jul 2024 · 332pp · 110,397 words
by Ben Rhodes · 4 Jun 2018 · 470pp · 148,444 words
by Alan Rusbridger · 26 Nov 2020 · 371pp · 109,320 words
by Steve Coll · 23 Feb 2004 · 956pp · 288,981 words
by David Frum · 25 May 2020 · 319pp · 75,257 words
by Barry Meier · 17 May 2021 · 319pp · 89,192 words
by Jamie Raskin · 4 Jan 2022 · 450pp · 144,939 words
by Seumas Milne · 1 Dec 1994 · 497pp · 161,742 words
by David Hoffman · 1 Jan 2009 · 719pp · 209,224 words
by Richard Horton · 31 May 2020 · 106pp · 33,210 words
by Roger Faligot · 30 Jun 2019 · 615pp · 187,426 words
by Annie Duke · 6 Feb 2018 · 288pp · 81,253 words
by Peter F. Hamilton · 1 Jan 2006 · 1,386pp · 379,115 words
by Karen Hao · 19 May 2025 · 660pp · 179,531 words
by Gil Durán · 17 Aug 2026 · 317pp · 114,570 words
by Keir Giles · 24 Oct 2024 · 296pp · 81,440 words
by Noam Chomsky · 14 Sep 2015
by Tim O'Reilly · 9 Oct 2017 · 561pp · 157,589 words
by David Talbot · 5 Sep 2016 · 891pp · 253,901 words
by Richard A. Clarke and Robert K. Knake · 15 Jul 2019 · 409pp · 112,055 words
by Rory Cormac · 14 Jun 2018 · 407pp
by Richard Seymour · 20 Aug 2019 · 297pp · 83,651 words
by Christine Lagorio-Chafkin · 1 Oct 2018
by Talia Lavin · 14 Jul 2020 · 231pp · 71,299 words
by Huib Modderkolk · 1 Sep 2021 · 295pp · 84,843 words
by Fiona Hill · 4 Oct 2021 · 569pp · 165,510 words
by Rupert Darwall · 2 Oct 2017 · 451pp · 115,720 words
by Peter Dale Scott and Jonathan Marshall · 1 Jan 1991
by Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor · 14 Sep 2026 · 393pp · 124,539 words
by Tom Clancy · 2 Jan 1984 · 594pp · 165,413 words
by Clive Thompson · 26 Mar 2019 · 499pp · 144,278 words
by Sean McFate · 22 Jan 2019 · 330pp · 83,319 words
by Matthew Sweet · 13 Feb 2018 · 493pp · 136,235 words
by Cass R. Sunstein · 6 Mar 2018 · 434pp · 117,327 words
by Scott J. Shapiro · 523pp · 154,042 words
by Ben Tarnoff · 13 Jun 2022 · 234pp · 67,589 words
by J. David McSwane · 11 Apr 2022 · 368pp · 102,379 words
by Chris Hayes · 28 Jan 2025 · 359pp · 100,761 words
by Dennis Yi Tenen · 6 Feb 2024 · 169pp · 41,887 words
by Rana Foroohar · 5 Nov 2019 · 380pp · 109,724 words
by Alex Zevin · 12 Nov 2019 · 767pp · 208,933 words
by Robert N. Proctor · 28 Feb 2012 · 1,199pp · 332,563 words
by John Fabian Witt · 14 Oct 2025 · 735pp · 279,360 words
by Noam Chomsky · 26 Jul 2010
by Steven Levy · 25 Feb 2020 · 706pp · 202,591 words
by Mark R. Levin · 12 Jul 2021 · 314pp · 88,524 words
by Greta Thunberg · 14 Feb 2023 · 651pp · 162,060 words
by Annie Jacobsen · 16 May 2011 · 572pp · 179,024 words
by Eric O'Neill · 1 Mar 2019 · 299pp · 88,375 words
by Robert Fisk · 2 Jan 2005 · 1,800pp · 596,972 words
by Rick Perlstein · 17 Aug 2020
by Walter Isaacson · 11 Sep 2023 · 562pp · 201,502 words
by Ray Kurzweil · 25 Jun 2024
by Jacob Silverman · 9 Oct 2025 · 312pp · 103,645 words
by W. David Marx · 18 Nov 2025 · 642pp · 142,332 words
by Robert Cowley · 5 May 1992 · 546pp · 176,169 words
by Peter Tomsen · 30 May 2011 · 1,118pp · 309,029 words
by Susan Linn · 12 Sep 2022 · 415pp · 102,982 words
by William Blum · 31 Mar 2002
by Shawn Lawrence Otto · 10 Oct 2011 · 692pp · 127,032 words
by Frank Pasquale · 14 May 2020 · 1,172pp · 114,305 words
by Steven K. Kapp · 19 Nov 2019
by Christopher Summerfield · 11 Mar 2025 · 412pp · 122,298 words
by Cory Doctorow · 6 Oct 2025 · 313pp · 94,415 words
by John Kiriakou · 11 May 2017 · 299pp · 96,608 words
by Andy Greenberg · 5 Nov 2019 · 363pp · 105,039 words
by Andrew Doyle · 24 Feb 2021 · 137pp · 35,041 words
by Norman Davies · 1 Jan 1996
by Jennifer Carlson · 2 May 2023 · 279pp · 100,877 words
by Shaun Walker · 15 Apr 2025 · 465pp · 155,902 words
by Noam Chomsky · 19 Oct 2015
by Noam Chomsky · 1 Apr 1999
by Robert Stone and Alan Andres · 3 Jun 2019
by Anupreeta Das · 12 Aug 2024 · 315pp · 115,894 words
by David E. Hoffman · 9 May 2016
by Julie Battilana and Tiziana Casciaro · 30 Aug 2021 · 345pp · 92,063 words
by Gordon Thomas
by Ronald Bailey · 20 Jul 2015 · 417pp · 109,367 words
by Luciano Floridi · 25 Feb 2010 · 137pp · 36,231 words
by Emmanuel Goldstein · 28 Jul 2008 · 889pp · 433,897 words
by Romeo Dallaire and Brent Beardsley · 9 Aug 2004 · 897pp · 210,566 words
by Andrew M. Lobaczewski · 1 Jan 2006 · 396pp · 116,332 words
by Kevin Mitnick · 14 Aug 2011
by Paul Vigna and Michael J. Casey · 27 Feb 2018 · 348pp · 97,277 words
by Jazmine Ulloa · 3 Mar 2026 · 395pp · 116,052 words
by Noam Chomsky · 7 Jul 2015
by Brian Klaas · 15 Mar 2017
by Noam Chomsky · 1 Jan 1974 · 56pp · 17,340 words
by Paul Mason · 30 Sep 2013 · 357pp · 99,684 words
by Andy Greenberg · 12 Sep 2012 · 461pp · 125,845 words
by Benjamin Peters · 2 Jun 2016 · 518pp · 107,836 words
by Owen Matthews · 21 Mar 2019 · 589pp · 162,849 words
by Jonathan Calvert and George Arbuthnott · 18 Mar 2021 · 432pp · 143,491 words
by Anna Funder · 19 Sep 2011
by Taylor Downing · 23 Apr 2018 · 400pp · 121,708 words
by George Marshall · 18 Aug 2014 · 298pp · 85,386 words
by Daniel Simons and Christopher Chabris · 10 Jul 2023 · 338pp · 104,815 words
by Cory Doctorow · 22 Jun 2026 · 175pp · 51,295 words
by Beth Shapiro · 15 Dec 2021 · 338pp · 105,112 words
by Norman Finkelstein · 9 Jan 2018 · 578pp · 170,758 words
by Florence de Changy · 24 Dec 2020
by Mehdi Hasan · 27 Feb 2023 · 307pp · 93,073 words
by Brittany Kaiser · 21 Oct 2019 · 391pp · 123,597 words
by Lawrence Lessig · 5 Nov 2019 · 404pp · 115,108 words
by Steven Pinker · 1 Jan 2002 · 901pp · 234,905 words
by Hawon Jung · 21 Mar 2023 · 401pp · 112,589 words
by Ben Mezrich · 6 Nov 2023 · 279pp · 85,453 words
by Neil Postman and Jeff Riggenbach Ph. · 1 Apr 2013 · 204pp · 61,491 words
by David Wallace-Wells · 19 Feb 2019 · 343pp · 101,563 words
by Joseph E. Stiglitz · 22 Apr 2019 · 462pp · 129,022 words
by Tom Burgis · 7 Sep 2020 · 476pp · 139,761 words
by Jane McGonigal · 22 Mar 2022 · 420pp · 135,569 words
by Justin E. H. Smith · 22 Mar 2022 · 198pp · 59,351 words
by Ayana Elizabeth Johnson · 17 Sep 2024 · 588pp · 160,825 words
by Dariusz Jemielniak and Aleksandra Przegalinska · 18 Feb 2020 · 187pp · 50,083 words
by Nicole Kobie · 3 Jul 2024 · 348pp · 119,358 words
by Parmy Olson · 5 Jun 2012 · 478pp · 149,810 words
by Lawrence Freedman · 9 Oct 2017 · 592pp · 161,798 words
by Ezra Klein · 28 Jan 2020 · 412pp · 96,251 words
by William Taubman
by Max Chafkin · 14 Sep 2021 · 524pp · 130,909 words
by Steven Pinker · 14 Oct 2021 · 533pp · 125,495 words
by Andrew Yang · 15 Nov 2021
by Sarah Kendzior · 6 Apr 2020
by William Drozdiak · 27 Apr 2020 · 241pp · 75,417 words
by Joseph Menn · 3 Jun 2019 · 302pp · 85,877 words
by Safiya Umoja Noble · 8 Jan 2018 · 290pp · 73,000 words
by Maurice E. Stucke and Ariel Ezrachi · 14 May 2020 · 511pp · 132,682 words
by Ben Macintyre · 14 Sep 2026 · 531pp · 144,389 words
by Jimmy Wales · 28 Oct 2025 · 216pp · 60,419 words
by David E. Sanger · 18 Jun 2018 · 394pp · 117,982 words
by Matt Taibbi · 7 Oct 2019 · 357pp · 99,456 words
by Jeff Sharlet · 21 Mar 2023 · 308pp · 97,480 words
by Edzard Ernst and Simon Singh · 17 Aug 2008 · 357pp · 110,072 words
by Michael Kimmage · 21 Apr 2020 · 378pp · 121,495 words
by Lloyd, John and Mitchinson, John · 7 Oct 2010 · 624pp · 104,923 words
by Tim Wu · 2 Nov 2010 · 418pp · 128,965 words
by Edward Snowden · 16 Sep 2019 · 324pp · 106,699 words
by Timothy Snyder · 14 Sep 2017 · 69pp · 15,637 words
by Christopher Miller · 17 Jul 2023 · 469pp · 149,526 words
by Ian Black · 2 Nov 2017 · 674pp · 201,633 words
by Mark Bergen · 5 Sep 2022 · 642pp · 141,888 words
by Adrian Hon · 14 Sep 2022 · 371pp · 107,141 words
by Glyn Moody · 26 Sep 2022 · 295pp · 66,912 words
by Annie Jacobsen · 11 Feb 2014 · 612pp · 181,985 words
by Jeremy Scahill · 22 Apr 2013 · 1,117pp · 305,620 words
by Jamie Bartlett · 4 Apr 2018 · 170pp · 49,193 words
by Anthony Berglas, William Black, Samantha Thalind, Max Scratchmann and Michelle Estes · 28 Feb 2015
by Doug Henwood · 30 Aug 1998 · 586pp · 159,901 words
by Eliezer Yudkowsky · 11 Mar 2015 · 1,737pp · 491,616 words
by Peter F. Hamilton · 1 Jan 2007 · 773pp · 214,465 words
by Donovan Hohn · 1 Jan 2010 · 473pp · 154,182 words
by Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri · 9 Mar 2000 · 1,015pp · 170,908 words
by Stross, Charles · 13 Jan 2004 · 404pp · 113,514 words
by Eric Schmidt and Jared Cohen · 22 Apr 2013 · 525pp · 116,295 words
by Peter R. Mansoor, Donald Kagan and Frederick Kagan · 31 Aug 2009 · 423pp · 126,375 words
by Benjamin R. Barber · 5 Nov 2013 · 501pp · 145,943 words
by Jane Mayer · 19 Jan 2016 · 558pp · 168,179 words
by Bruce Sterling · 31 May 1988 · 509pp · 137,315 words
by Sarah Frier · 13 Apr 2020 · 484pp · 114,613 words
by Sally Denton · 556pp · 141,069 words
by Simon Reeve · 404pp · 119,055 words
by Ethan Mollick · 2 Apr 2024 · 189pp · 58,076 words
by Jordan Thomas · 27 May 2025 · 347pp · 105,327 words
by Adam Aleksic · 15 Jul 2025 · 278pp · 71,701 words
by Jill Lepore · 24 Aug 2026 · 363pp · 122,400 words
by Peter H. Diamandis and Steven Kotler · 13 Apr 2026 · 225pp · 76,418 words
by Kevin Roose · 481pp · 151,124 words
by Annie Jacobsen · 25 Mar 2024 · 444pp · 105,807 words
by James Barr · 8 Aug 2018 · 539pp · 151,425 words
by Noa Tishby · 5 Apr 2021 · 338pp · 101,967 words
by Simone Browne · 1 Oct 2015 · 326pp · 84,180 words
by Pieter Hintjens · 11 Mar 2013 · 349pp · 114,038 words
by Nancy Stout · 2 Feb 2013 · 519pp · 160,846 words
by Mike Mullane · 24 Jan 2006 · 506pp · 167,034 words
by Gabriella Coleman · 4 Nov 2014 · 457pp · 126,996 words
by Julia Angwin · 25 Feb 2014 · 422pp · 104,457 words
by Tamara Kneese · 14 Aug 2023 · 284pp · 75,744 words
by Kurt Andersen · 5 Sep 2017
by Kashmir Hill · 19 Sep 2023 · 487pp · 124,008 words
by Yascha Mounk · 26 Sep 2023
by Tom Clancy · 2 Jan 1986
by Noam Chomsky · 17 Dec 2014
by Steven Pinker · 1 Jan 1997 · 913pp · 265,787 words
by Ilan Pappe · 1 May 2017 · 196pp · 58,886 words
by Aja Raden · 10 May 2021 · 291pp · 85,822 words
by John P. Carlin and Garrett M. Graff · 15 Oct 2018 · 568pp · 164,014 words
by Helena Merriman · 24 Aug 2021 · 333pp · 101,677 words
by Raj M. Shah and Christopher Kirchhoff · 8 Jul 2024 · 272pp · 103,638 words
by Richard Aldrich · 10 Jun 2010 · 826pp · 231,966 words
by Peter L. Shillingsburg · 15 Jan 2006 · 224pp · 12,941 words
by Leo Marks · 1 Jan 1998 · 677pp · 195,722 words
by Jeff Flake · 31 Jul 2017 · 138pp · 43,748 words
by Yascha Mounk · 15 Feb 2018 · 497pp · 123,778 words
by Greg Egan · 13 Dec 1994 · 266pp · 78,986 words
by Michael O’sullivan · 28 May 2019 · 756pp · 120,818 words
by Andrew Keen · 1 Mar 2018 · 308pp · 85,880 words
by Matthew Hindman · 24 Sep 2018
by Rush Doshi · 24 Jun 2021 · 816pp · 191,889 words
by Annie Jacobsen · 14 Sep 2015 · 558pp · 164,627 words
by Yuval Noah Harari · 29 Aug 2018 · 389pp · 119,487 words
by Martin Gurri · 13 Nov 2018 · 379pp · 99,340 words
by Bill McKibben · 15 Apr 2019
by Nathaniel Rich · 4 Aug 2018 · 148pp · 45,249 words
by David Sumpter · 18 Jun 2018 · 276pp · 81,153 words
by Chuck Wendig · 1 Jul 2019 · 1,028pp · 267,392 words
by The Virtual Community Homesteading on the Electronic Frontier-Perseus Books (1993) · 26 Apr 2012
by Gerald Posner · 3 Feb 2015 · 1,590pp · 353,834 words
by William McGowan · 16 Nov 2010 · 316pp · 91,969 words
by Satyajit Das · 15 Nov 2006 · 349pp · 134,041 words
by Michael Lewis · 1 Jan 1989 · 314pp · 101,452 words
by Kurt Andersen · 4 Sep 2017 · 522pp · 162,310 words
by David Runciman · 9 May 2018 · 245pp · 72,893 words
by Jamie Susskind · 3 Sep 2018 · 533pp
by Nick Couldry and Ulises A. Mejias · 19 Aug 2019 · 458pp · 116,832 words
by William Davies · 28 Sep 2020 · 210pp · 65,833 words
by Scott Anderson · 5 Aug 2013
by Ivan Krastev and Stephen Holmes · 31 Oct 2019 · 300pp · 87,374 words
by Lorne Lantz and Daniel Cawrey · 8 Dec 2020 · 434pp · 77,974 words
by Mark Galeotti · 1 May 2020 · 163pp · 47,912 words
by Ashlee Vance · 8 May 2023 · 558pp · 175,965 words
by Christopher Lasch · 16 Sep 1991 · 669pp · 226,737 words
by Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson · 15 May 2023 · 619pp · 177,548 words
by William Gibson · 3 Jan 2012 · 153pp · 45,871 words
by William Fotheringham · 22 Sep 2011 · 428pp · 117,419 words
by Thomas Geoghegan · 20 Sep 2011 · 364pp · 104,697 words
by Jason Stearns · 29 Mar 2011 · 487pp · 139,297 words
by John Brockman · 18 Jan 2011 · 379pp · 109,612 words
by Edward W. Said · 29 May 1994 · 549pp · 170,495 words
by Christiana Figueres and Tom Rivett-Carnac · 25 Feb 2020 · 197pp · 49,296 words
by Noam Chomsky, Arthur Naiman and David Barsamian · 13 Sep 2011 · 489pp · 111,305 words
by Lloyd, John and Mitchinson, John · 7 Oct 2010 · 469pp · 97,582 words
by Evgeny Morozov · 16 Nov 2010 · 538pp · 141,822 words
by Richard Brodie · 4 Jun 2009 · 289pp · 22,394 words
by Thomas E. Ricks · 14 Oct 2009 · 509pp · 153,061 words
by Ernest Cline · 15 Feb 2011 · 458pp · 137,960 words
by Steven Hiatt; John Perkins · 1 Jan 2006 · 497pp · 123,718 words
by Max Boot · 9 Jan 2018 · 972pp · 259,764 words
by Victor Davis Hanson · 16 Oct 2017 · 908pp · 262,808 words
by John Yudkin · 1 Nov 2012 · 239pp · 77,436 words
by Vernor Vinge · 1 May 2006
by Michael Wolff · 5 Jan 2018 · 394pp · 112,770 words
by Elisabeth Åsbrink · 31 Jul 2016 · 215pp · 60,489 words
by Yasha Levine · 6 Feb 2018 · 474pp · 130,575 words
by Robert Verkaik · 14 Apr 2018 · 419pp · 119,476 words
by Malcolm Gladwell · 9 Sep 2019 · 328pp · 97,711 words
by Michael Shellenberger · 28 Jun 2020
by Suzanne O'Sullivan · 31 Mar 2021 · 319pp · 101,673 words
by Catherine Shanahan M. D. · 2 Jan 2017 · 659pp · 190,874 words
by Emma Williams · 7 Nov 2012 · 466pp · 150,362 words
by Renee Dudley and Daniel Golden · 24 Oct 2022 · 392pp · 114,189 words
by Alan Murray · 15 Dec 2022 · 263pp · 77,786 words
by Dr. Frank Luntz · 2 Jan 2007
by Andy Weir · 1 Jan 2011 · 410pp · 103,421 words
by Douglas Rushkoff · 7 Sep 2022 · 205pp · 61,903 words
by Jeremy Farrar and Anjana Ahuja · 15 Jan 2021 · 245pp · 71,886 words
by Victor Sebestyen · 30 Sep 2014 · 476pp · 144,288 words
by Walt Bogdanich and Michael Forsythe · 3 Oct 2022 · 689pp · 134,457 words
by David Gelles · 30 May 2022 · 318pp · 91,957 words
by Mark Bowden · 1 Dec 2007 · 193pp · 55,721 words
by Owen Jones · 3 Sep 2014 · 388pp · 125,472 words
by Peter Morville · 14 May 2014 · 165pp · 50,798 words
by Sandy Tolan · 1 Jan 2006 · 488pp · 150,477 words
by Frederick Kempe · 30 Apr 2011 · 762pp · 206,865 words
by Stephen Fried · 23 Mar 2010 · 603pp · 186,210 words
by John Abramson · 20 Sep 2004 · 436pp · 123,488 words
by James Bridle · 18 Jun 2018 · 301pp · 85,263 words
by Sarah Kendzior · 24 Apr 2015 · 172pp · 48,747 words
by Alexander R. Galloway · 1 Apr 2004 · 287pp · 86,919 words
by Peter F. Hamilton · 2 Mar 2004 · 1,234pp · 356,472 words
by Dana Priest and William M. Arkin · 5 Sep 2011 · 328pp · 100,381 words
by Noam Chomsky · 1 Jan 2003 · 351pp · 96,780 words
by Jiawei Han, Micheline Kamber and Jian Pei · 21 Jun 2011
by Peter Hopkirk · 2 Jan 1991 · 580pp · 194,144 words
by Stross, Charles · 28 Oct 2004 · 462pp · 142,240 words
by Stross, Charles · 12 Jan 2006
by Stross, Charles · 30 Sep 2007 · 414pp · 123,666 words
by Stross, Charles · 28 Oct 2003 · 448pp · 116,962 words
by Stross, Charles · 1 Jan 2002
by David Moon, Patrick Ruffini, David Segal, Aaron Swartz, Lawrence Lessig, Cory Doctorow, Zoe Lofgren, Jamie Laurie, Ron Paul, Mike Masnick, Kim Dotcom, Tiffiniy Cheng, Alexis Ohanian, Nicole Powers and Josh Levy · 30 Apr 2013 · 452pp · 134,502 words
by Stross, Charles · 22 Jan 2005 · 489pp · 148,885 words
by Michael W. Covel · 14 Jun 2011
by Marc Goodman · 24 Feb 2015 · 677pp · 206,548 words
by Ashutosh Deshmukh · 13 Dec 2005
by Chris Hedges · 14 May 2010 · 422pp · 89,770 words
by Jaron Lanier · 28 May 2018 · 151pp · 39,757 words
by Michela Wrong · 9 Apr 2009 · 403pp · 125,659 words
by Alan Dershowitz · 31 Jul 2003
by Barbara Oakley Phd · 20 Oct 2008
by Sylvere Lotringer, Christian Marazzi · 2 Aug 2005
by A. O. Scott · 9 Feb 2016 · 218pp · 65,422 words
by Ilan Pappe · 30 Apr 2012 · 387pp · 120,092 words
by Thomas Leahy · 26 Mar 2020 · 1,149pp · 141,412 words
by Eileen Ormsby · 1 Nov 2014 · 269pp · 79,285 words
by Alex Rosenblat · 22 Oct 2018 · 343pp · 91,080 words
by Rahm Emanuel · 25 Feb 2020 · 212pp · 69,846 words
by Valerie Hansen · 13 Apr 2020
by Jessica Bruder and Dale Maharidge · 29 Mar 2020 · 159pp · 42,401 words
by Daniel Crosby · 15 Feb 2018 · 249pp · 77,342 words
by Bruce Schneier · 3 Sep 2018 · 448pp · 117,325 words
by Diane Coyle · 15 Apr 2025 · 321pp · 112,477 words
by David Abulafia · 4 May 2011 · 1,002pp · 276,865 words
by Alan Weisman · 21 Apr 2025 · 599pp · 149,014 words
by Eva Dou · 14 Jan 2025 · 394pp · 110,159 words
by Dorcas Cheng-Tozun · 14 May 2023 · 217pp · 61,247 words
by Megan Greenwell · 18 Apr 2025 · 385pp · 103,818 words
by Ingrid Robeyns · 16 Jan 2024 · 327pp · 110,234 words
by Vauhini Vara · 8 Apr 2025 · 301pp · 105,209 words
by Edward Fishman · 25 Feb 2025 · 884pp · 221,861 words
by M. E. Sarotte · 29 Nov 2021 · 791pp · 222,536 words
by Joe Studwell · 6 Dec 2025 · 393pp · 148,223 words
by Denise Hearn and Vass Bednar · 14 Oct 2024 · 175pp · 46,192 words
by Adrian Wooldridge · 7 Apr 2026 · 342pp · 129,097 words
by Sonja Thiel and Johannes C. Bernhardt · 31 Dec 2023 · 321pp · 113,564 words
by Johann Hari · 25 Jan 2022 · 390pp · 120,864 words
by Andrew Simms · 314pp · 81,529 words
by Steve Coll · 27 Feb 2024 · 738pp · 196,803 words
by Norman G. Finkelstein · 1 Jan 2010 · 184pp · 55,923 words
by Nick Bostrom · 26 Mar 2024 · 547pp · 173,909 words
by James Miller · 17 Sep 2018 · 370pp · 99,312 words
by Charles Emmerson · 14 Oct 2019 · 950pp · 297,713 words
by Ian Urbina · 19 Aug 2019
by Maya Goodfellow · 5 Nov 2019 · 273pp · 83,802 words
by Brad Stone · 10 May 2021 · 569pp · 156,139 words
by Mark Urban · 291pp · 85,908 words
by Robert Bryce · 26 Apr 2011 · 520pp · 129,887 words
by Ben Goldacre · 1 Jan 2008 · 322pp · 107,576 words
by Patrick Major · 5 Nov 2009 · 669pp · 150,886 words
by Matt Savinar · 2 Jan 2004 · 127pp · 51,083 words
by Michael Harris · 6 Aug 2014 · 259pp · 73,193 words
by Will Hutton · 30 Sep 2010 · 543pp · 147,357 words
by Paul Vigna and Michael J. Casey · 27 Jan 2015 · 457pp · 128,838 words
by Astra Taylor · 4 Mar 2014 · 283pp · 85,824 words
by Iain Overton · 15 Apr 2015 · 436pp · 125,809 words
by Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri · 1 Jan 2004 · 475pp · 149,310 words
by Moises Naim · 5 Mar 2013 · 474pp · 120,801 words
by Nick Cohen · 15 Jul 2015 · 414pp · 121,243 words
by Tim Schwab · 13 Nov 2023 · 618pp · 179,407 words
by Shibani Mahtani and Timothy McLaughlin · 7 Nov 2023 · 348pp · 110,533 words
by Stephen Graham · 30 Oct 2009 · 717pp · 150,288 words
by Antonio J. Mendez and Matt Baglio · 14 Jun 2012 · 273pp · 86,821 words
by James E. Lovelock · 1 Jan 2009 · 239pp · 68,598 words
by Robert D. Kaplan · 1 Jan 1988 · 233pp · 75,477 words
by Giles Slade · 14 Apr 2006 · 384pp · 89,250 words
by Simon Winchester · 1 Jan 2008 · 385pp · 105,627 words
by Thomas L. Friedman · 22 Nov 2016 · 602pp · 177,874 words
by Tom Clancy · 2 Jan 1987
by Tom Clancy and Scott Brick · 2 Jan 2002
by Tom Clancy · 2 Jan 1989
by John Robbins · 566pp · 151,193 words
by Noam Chomsky · 16 Apr 2007
by Philip Mirowski · 24 Jun 2013 · 662pp · 180,546 words
by Noam Chomsky · 24 Mar 2000
by Jacob Silverman · 17 Mar 2015 · 527pp · 147,690 words
by Noam Chomsky · 24 Oct 2014
by Jonathan Littman · 1 Jan 1996
by Jon Ronson · 1 Jan 2001 · 341pp · 87,268 words
by Edward Luce · 20 Apr 2017 · 223pp · 58,732 words
by Jacob Bacharach · 13 Apr 2014 · 266pp · 77,045 words
by Mike Berners-Lee · 27 Feb 2019
by Michael Wolff · 3 Jun 2019 · 359pp · 113,847 words
by Eric Thompson · 18 Apr 2018 · 379pp · 118,576 words
by Raghuram Rajan · 26 Feb 2019 · 596pp · 163,682 words
by Tim Mackintosh-Smith · 2 Mar 2019
by Jason Hickel · 12 Aug 2020 · 286pp · 87,168 words
by Timothy Snyder · 2 Apr 2018
by Wolfram Eilenberger · 14 Sep 2020
by Paul Kennedy · 15 Jan 1989 · 1,477pp · 311,310 words
by Mark Mazower · 4 Nov 2021 · 887pp · 242,125 words
by Kevin Davies · 5 Oct 2020 · 741pp · 164,057 words
by Jimmy Soni · 22 Feb 2022 · 505pp · 161,581 words
by Neil Degrasse Tyson and Avis Lang · 10 Sep 2018 · 745pp · 207,187 words
by Dan Richardson and Daniel Jacobs · 1 Feb 2013
by John Markoff · 22 Mar 2022 · 573pp · 142,376 words
by Kenneth Payne · 16 Jun 2021 · 339pp · 92,785 words
by Samuel Earle · 3 May 2023 · 245pp · 88,158 words
by Madhumita Murgia · 20 Mar 2024 · 336pp · 91,806 words
by Guillaume Pitron · 14 Jun 2023 · 271pp · 79,355 words
by Angus Hanton · 25 Mar 2024 · 277pp · 81,718 words
by Vincent Ialenti · 22 Sep 2020 · 224pp · 69,593 words
by Elandria Williams, Eli Feghali, Rachel Plattus and Nathan Schneider · 15 Dec 2024 · 346pp · 84,111 words
by Michael Dobbs · 3 Sep 2008 · 631pp · 171,391 words
by Neil A. Gershenfeld · 15 Feb 1999 · 238pp · 46 words
by Dr Dominic Pimenta · 2 Sep 2020 · 304pp · 95,306 words
by Phoebe Robinson · 14 Oct 2021 · 265pp · 93,354 words
by Andrew Lih · 5 Jul 2010 · 398pp · 86,023 words
by Henry Jenkins · 31 Jul 2006
by Norman Polmar and Michael White · 1 Dec 2010 · 241pp · 64,424 words
by Neil Sheehan · 21 Sep 2009 · 589pp · 197,971 words
by John de Graaf, David Wann, Thomas H Naylor and David Horsey · 1 Jan 2001 · 378pp · 102,966 words
by Mick Hume · 23 Feb 2017 · 228pp · 68,880 words
by Alastair Reynolds · 16 Apr 2008 · 635pp · 186,208 words
by David K. Shipler · 18 Apr 2011 · 495pp · 154,046 words
by Peter F. Hamilton · 26 Sep 2012 · 1,266pp · 344,635 words
by Steve Coll · 30 Apr 2012 · 944pp · 243,883 words
by Kelly Weinersmith and Zach Weinersmith · 16 Oct 2017 · 398pp · 105,032 words
by Robert C. Martin · 13 Oct 2019 · 333pp · 64,581 words
by John Connelly · 11 Nov 2019
by Laurie Garrett · 31 Oct 1994 · 1,293pp · 357,735 words
by Laurie Garrett · 15 Feb 2000
by Joanne McNeil · 25 Feb 2020 · 239pp · 80,319 words
by Oleg Gordievsky · 13 Apr 2015 · 438pp · 146,246 words
by Steve Gibson · 2 Mar 2012 · 377pp · 121,996 words
by James Griffiths; · 15 Jan 2018 · 453pp · 114,250 words
by Steven Levy · 15 Jan 2002 · 468pp · 137,055 words
by Odd Arne Westad · 4 Sep 2017 · 846pp · 250,145 words
by Lucas Chancel · 15 Jan 2020 · 191pp · 51,242 words
by Noreena Hertz · 13 May 2020 · 506pp · 133,134 words
by Alan Allport · 2 Sep 2020 · 1,520pp · 221,543 words
by Nicholas A. Christakis · 27 Oct 2020 · 475pp · 127,389 words
by Tim Harford · 2 Feb 2021 · 428pp · 103,544 words
by Matthew Carmona, Tim Heath, Steve Tiesdell and Taner Oc · 15 Feb 2010 · 1,233pp · 239,800 words
by Vivek Ramaswamy · 16 Aug 2021 · 344pp · 104,522 words
by George Packer · 14 Jun 2021 · 173pp · 55,328 words
by Sarah Gilbert and Catherine Green · 7 Jul 2021 · 296pp · 96,568 words
by Donnie Eichar · 20 Oct 2014 · 232pp · 68,570 words
by Stanley McChrystal and Anna Butrico · 4 Oct 2021 · 489pp · 106,008 words
by Victor Davis Hanson · 15 Nov 2021 · 458pp · 132,912 words
by Alec Ross · 13 Sep 2021 · 363pp · 109,077 words
by Tim Marshall · 14 Oct 2021 · 383pp · 105,387 words
by Scott Gottlieb · 20 Sep 2021
by Vincent Bevins · 18 May 2020 · 393pp · 115,178 words
by John Darwin · 23 Sep 2009
by Joseph Henrich · 27 Oct 2015 · 631pp · 177,227 words
by Gene Sperling · 14 Sep 2020 · 667pp · 149,811 words
by Leo Gough · 22 Aug 2010 · 117pp · 31,221 words
by Lawrence Freedman · 31 Oct 2013 · 1,073pp · 314,528 words
by Tim Lee, Jamie Lee and Kevin Coldiron · 13 Dec 2019 · 241pp · 81,805 words
by Greg Palast · 14 Nov 2011 · 493pp · 132,290 words
by Jacqueline Novogratz · 15 Feb 2009 · 391pp · 117,984 words
by Anne Applebaum · 30 Oct 2012 · 934pp · 232,651 words
by Norman Stone · 15 Feb 2010 · 851pp · 247,711 words
by Abraham Rabinovich · 1 Jan 1987
by Richard Holmes · 24 Apr 2013 · 432pp · 128,944 words
by Nate Silver · 31 Aug 2012 · 829pp · 186,976 words
by Christian Caryl · 30 Oct 2012 · 780pp · 168,782 words
by Jon Ronson · 12 May 2011 · 274pp · 70,481 words
by Tom Clancy · 2 Jan 1989 · 914pp · 270,937 words
by Tom Clancy · 2 Jan 1994
by Tom Clancy · 2 Jan 1996
by E. Gabriella Coleman · 25 Nov 2012 · 398pp · 107,788 words
by Seth G. Jones · 12 Apr 2009 · 566pp · 144,072 words
by Daniel Yergin · 23 Dec 2008 · 1,445pp · 469,426 words
by Peter Frankopan · 26 Aug 2015 · 1,042pp · 273,092 words
by Abraham Rabinovich · 1 Jan 2004 · 722pp · 225,235 words
by John Kay · 2 Sep 2015 · 478pp · 126,416 words
by Dariusz Jemielniak · 13 May 2014 · 312pp · 93,504 words
by Michael Meyer · 7 Sep 2009 · 323pp · 95,188 words
by Luke Harding · 7 Feb 2014 · 266pp · 80,018 words
by Ilan Pappé, Noam Chomsky and Frank Barat · 9 Nov 2010 · 279pp · 72,659 words
by Ronald J. Deibert · 13 May 2013 · 317pp · 98,745 words
by Daniel Kurtz-Phelan · 9 Apr 2018
by John J. Mearsheimer · 1 Jan 2001 · 637pp · 199,158 words
by James Gleick · 1 Jan 1992 · 795pp · 215,529 words
by Hamish McKenzie · 30 Sep 2017 · 307pp · 90,634 words
by Peter Warren Singer · 1 Jan 2003 · 482pp · 161,169 words
by Amy Webb · 5 Mar 2019 · 340pp · 97,723 words
by Gretchen McCulloch · 22 Jul 2019 · 413pp · 106,479 words
by Matti Friedman · 2 May 2016 · 183pp · 59,209 words
by Robert Elliott Smith · 26 Jun 2019 · 370pp · 107,983 words
by Charlotte Alter · 18 Feb 2020 · 504pp · 129,087 words
by Michael Lind · 20 Feb 2020
by Howard Rheingold · 24 Dec 2011
by Nesrine Malik · 4 Sep 2019
by Steve Coll · 29 Mar 2009 · 413pp · 128,093 words
by Mark Honigsbaum · 8 Apr 2019 · 529pp · 150,263 words
by Rashid Khalidi · 28 Jan 2020 · 413pp · 120,506 words
by The Reluctant Carer · 22 Jun 2022 · 233pp · 69,745 words
by Ron Jeffries · 14 Aug 2015 · 444pp · 118,393 words
by Bill Gates · 2 May 2022 · 406pp · 88,977 words
by Robert D. Kaplan · 11 Apr 2022 · 500pp · 115,119 words
by Anya Kamenetz · 23 Aug 2022 · 347pp · 103,518 words
by Ian Hanington · 13 May 2012 · 258pp · 77,601 words
by Paul Mason · 29 Jul 2015 · 378pp · 110,518 words
by James Angelos · 1 Jun 2015 · 278pp · 93,540 words
by Tracy Kidder · 29 Feb 2000 · 267pp · 91,984 words
by Seth Mnookin · 3 Jan 2012 · 566pp · 153,259 words
by Lionel Barber · 3 Oct 2024 · 424pp · 123,730 words
by Sarah Goodyear, Doug Gordon and Aaron Naparstek · 21 Oct 2025 · 330pp · 85,349 words
by David Ariosto · 24 Mar 2026 · 433pp · 116,344 words
by Elizabeth Bear · 5 Mar 2019 · 596pp · 163,351 words
by David Pogue · 10 Mar 2026 · 686pp · 216,944 words
by David G. W. Birch and Victoria Richardson · 28 Apr 2024 · 249pp · 74,201 words
by Dorcas Cheng-Tozun
by Nicolas Niarchos · 20 Jan 2026 · 654pp · 170,150 words
by Gareth Dennis · 12 Nov 2024 · 261pp · 76,645 words
by Nigel Toon · 13 Dec 2023
by Geert Mak · 27 Oct 2021 · 722pp · 223,701 words
by Sharon Weinberger · 21 Sep 2026 · 281pp · 98,857 words
by John Gray · 11 Apr 2011 · 232pp · 67,934 words
by Thomas Frank · 5 Aug 2008 · 482pp · 122,497 words
by Franck Frommer · 6 Oct 2010 · 255pp · 68,829 words
by Tom Standage · 1 Jan 1998
by Noam Chomsky · 11 Sep 1987
by Cathy O'Neil · 5 Sep 2016 · 252pp · 72,473 words
by Michael E. Gerber · 3 Mar 1995 · 251pp · 66,396 words
by H. W. Brands · 1 Jan 2000 · 961pp · 302,613 words
by H. W. Brands · 1 Oct 2012 · 939pp · 274,289 words
by Danny Dorling and Sally Tomlinson · 15 Jan 2019 · 502pp · 128,126 words
by Lesley M. M. Blume · 3 Aug 2020
by Kevin Roose · 9 Mar 2021 · 208pp · 57,602 words
by Patrick Radden Keefe · 12 Apr 2021 · 712pp · 212,334 words
by Murong Xuecun · 7 Mar 2023 · 236pp · 73,008 words
by William Magnuson · 8 Nov 2022 · 356pp · 116,083 words
by Scott Patterson · 5 Jun 2023 · 289pp · 95,046 words
by Timothy Egan · 4 Apr 2023
by Kai Bird and Martin J. Sherwin · 18 Dec 2007 · 1,041pp · 317,136 words
by Kerry Howley · 21 Mar 2023
by Adrian Hon · 5 Oct 2020 · 340pp · 101,675 words
by Johan Norberg · 14 Jun 2023 · 295pp · 87,204 words